d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Mass Shooting / Terror Attack In Germany > 11 Dead
Prev156789Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 92,996
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Feb 20 2020 04:21pm
Quote (fender @ Feb 20 2020 04:11pm)
you're wrong. i gave you every chance to overthink and change your stance, telling you how your repeated insistence on downplaying the current rise in right wing populism and violence, by pointing to times when it was worse, looked - but you just kept doubling down - and now you clutch your pearls over the only logical conclusion that leads to.

here's a more fitting version of your sky analogy: we're both looking at a brown sky, we both claim we want it to be blue, and while i'm saying "i hate this brown sky, people should know this is neither normal nor acceptable", you say "well, it's not THAT brown, is it? also, it has been much browner in the past. ackshually, it's the least brown it has ever been".

and again, i have no magic button to turn off racism. educating people surely helps. holding political parties and their representatives to a minimum standard of truth-telling, and aggressively fighting back against blatant propaganda and fear-mongering, protesting and opposing those people wherever they assemble to show them their ideas are objectionable and disgusting...
but i'm sure you have a pretty good idea that there aren't any foolproof ways to eliminate bigotry for good, that's why you keep insisting i present policy solutions, even though i told you from the very start there's no such thing. you know what might actually help? travel and international food court vouchers for afd voters and trump supporters, haha...

that being said, let me reiterate the point i made in my previous post: even the 'just angrily yelling at nazis and not actually doing anything substantial' caricature you conjured up, in order to mock my opposition to fascists and bigots, would STILL be better than just marginalising the problem by 'correctly' pointing out that the sky has been browner once...


U seem lost, let me guide you.

Is radicalization a problem? Yes. Here we agree.

Is it an existential problem? No. Here I think we agree u just think it's more of an issue than I do.

Is it a combatable problem? Largely no. Here I also think we agree, yet when I pointed out that I think media scrutiny for publishing manifestos is far more realistic to combat and yields better results it seemed to upset u.

Honestly u just got mad that I said it's not an existential problem, even tho that was a bit of a throwaway comment rather then my point. And here we are 5 posts later with u pretending like I'd say horrible things to black people despite me trying to steer the conversation back into productive waters repeatedly.

One of my real ideas was exposing right wingers to other cultures via food and community events. So it seems we're in agreement on that aspect too. I'm just a bit confused why each of ur posts read like were on opposite ends of a spectrum. The constant accusations of marginalizing minorities are just u being rude tbh. I don't mind tho, I can burn time engaging rudeness or earnest conversation.
Member
Posts: 40,852
Joined: Sep 17 2011
Gold: 0.00
Feb 20 2020 04:28pm
Quote (thesnipa @ 20 Feb 2020 22:21)
U seem lost, let me guide you.

Is radicalization a problem? Yes. Here we agree.

Is it an existential problem? No. Here I think we agree u just think it's more of an issue than I do.

Is it a combatable problem? Largely no. Here I also think we agree, yet when I pointed out that I think media scrutiny for publishing manifestos is far more realistic to combat and yields better results it seemed to upset u.

Honestly u just got mad that I said it's not an existential problem, even tho that was a bit of a throwaway comment rather then my point. And here we are 5 posts later with u pretending like I'd say horrible things to black people despite me trying to steer the conversation back into productive waters repeatedly.

One of my real ideas was exposing right wingers to other cultures via food and community events. So it seems we're in agreement on that aspect too. I'm just a bit confused why each of ur posts read like were on opposite ends of a spectrum. The constant accusations of marginalizing minorities are just u being rude tbh. I don't mind tho, I can burn time engaging rudeness or earnest conversation.


It seems to be a growing problem. Much like Islamic terror was in the 2000s and 2010s. I don't think we've seen the last of it's growth either especially as the FBI has limited powers when investigating foreign orgs not designated terror groups and the majority of white nationalist groups are not designated such in the USA and a large portion of ethnonationalist terrorism is stochastic.

Security forces the world over have to seriously rethink how they deal with terrorism from decentralised movements. Organised terror is far easier to deal with and they don't even have a proper handle on that.
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Feb 20 2020 04:29pm
Quote (thesnipa @ 20 Feb 2020 23:21)
U seem lost, let me guide you.

Is radicalization a problem? Yes. Here we agree.

Is it an existential problem? No. Here I think we agree u just think it's more of an issue than I do.

Is it a combatable problem? Largely no. Here I also think we agree, yet when I pointed out that I think media scrutiny for publishing manifestos is far more realistic to combat and yields better results it seemed to upset u.

Honestly u just got mad that I said it's not an existential problem, even tho that was a bit of a throwaway comment rather then my point. And here we are 5 posts later with u pretending like I'd say horrible things to black people despite me trying to steer the conversation back into productive waters repeatedly.

One of my real ideas was exposing right wingers to other cultures via food and community events. So it seems we're in agreement on that aspect too. I'm just a bit confused why each of ur posts read like were on opposite ends of a spectrum. The constant accusations of marginalizing minorities are just u being rude tbh. I don't mind tho, I can burn time engaging rudeness or earnest conversation.


tf are you on about? read my reply to that again, i completely agreed with you on that point, i merely added that it does not address the underlying problem of initial radicalisation. stop strawmanning so hard.

and no, i'm not saying you're marginalising minorities, i'm saying you're marginalising the problem of rising political violence, by repeatedly insisting that 'it's not that bad, actually it's the best it has ever been' - which i strongly disagree with, considering the rise of right wing populism in the last couple of years. try to keep up...
Member
Posts: 6,517
Joined: Oct 22 2005
Gold: 12.79
Feb 20 2020 04:37pm
A gun? Aren't guns banned in fascist Germany? Hmmm.
Member
Posts: 40,852
Joined: Sep 17 2011
Gold: 0.00
Feb 20 2020 04:44pm
Quote (LA-Leviathan @ 20 Feb 2020 22:37)
A gun? Aren't guns banned in fascist Germany? Hmmm.


No. That's why he had a legal firearm.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Feb 20 2020 04:55pm
Quote (LA-Leviathan @ Feb 20 2020 05:37pm)
A gun? Aren't guns banned in fascist Germany? Hmmm.


When I lived there we would shoot small caliber rifles recreationally. They were .22lr I'm not sure if any German civilians can get any of the cool weapons that they make that we can get, those H&Ks brother and original uzi.

But where there's restrictions there is a black market.

/e just checked because I thought uzi were Israeli and they are, but German military used them.

This post was edited by Skinned on Feb 20 2020 04:57pm
Member
Posts: 92,996
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Feb 20 2020 05:12pm
Quote (fender @ Feb 20 2020 04:29pm)
tf are you on about? read my reply to that again, i completely agreed with you on that point, i merely added that it does not address the underlying problem of initial radicalisation. stop strawmanning so hard.

and no, i'm not saying you're marginalising minorities, i'm saying you're marginalising the problem of rising political violence, by repeatedly insisting that 'it's not that bad, actually it's the best it has ever been' - which i strongly disagree with, considering the rise of right wing populism in the last couple of years. try to keep up...


I'm not saying thatu disagreed with the media's role. I'm saying once I said that I thought it was less of a problem than u and that we should avoid that point to have a more constructive conversation about what we do agree on u declined and post after post went back to a disagreement I already knew we couldn't reconcile.

Is this not demonstrated by the fact that in ur 5th or so reply u said an actual plan and were in agreement it would help?

This post was edited by thesnipa on Feb 20 2020 05:13pm
Member
Posts: 2,660
Joined: Mar 28 2010
Gold: 0.00
Feb 20 2020 06:12pm
Quote (MxVivianWulf @ Feb 20 2020 04:28pm)
It seems to be a growing problem. Much like Islamic terror was in the 2000s and 2010s. I don't think we've seen the last of it's growth either especially as the FBI has limited powers when investigating foreign orgs not designated terror groups and the majority of white nationalist groups are not designated such in the USA and a large portion of ethnonationalist terrorism is stochastic.

Security forces the world over have to seriously rethink how they deal with terrorism from decentralised movements. Organised terror is far easier to deal with and they don't even have a proper handle on that.


The actual fatal attacks aren't committed by any defined groups within the white nationalist movement. You can't broadly label the movement as terrorist since its 99% political.

The FBI has little reason to investigate any of these groups unless they find evidence of an attack being planned. The attacks we see are lone attackers who act with little notice.
Banned
Posts: 1,571
Joined: Jul 18 2018
Gold: 61.00
Feb 20 2020 07:12pm
i'm firmly of the belief that redcaps should be interviewed and strip searched before boarding airplanes
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Feb 20 2020 07:31pm
Quote (Devil_cuck @ Feb 20 2020 08:12pm)
i'm firmly of the belief that redcaps should be interviewed and strip searched before boarding airplanes


Im on an airplane right now and thankfully dont see any

Waiting on runway for ice to be removed

This post was edited by Thor123422 on Feb 20 2020 07:31pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev156789Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll