He's "Right," in the strictest sense about her weight at least, but is he really right about her being some kind of role model who's marching kids down the road of fat? Is that really a major concern, or is this guy just trying to use a chance to be self-righteous and bring up all of the weight that he's personally managed to lose?

The idea that this woman just didn't know she was fat and was totally going to change her life behind this letter is laughable beyond belief.



The non-sequitur is the part where you can't answer the question.

"What is it about you that makes you do this" can't be answered by pointing at someone else's actions. Feel free to be as smug as you'd like, but seriously.

This post was edited by AiNedeSpelCzech on Oct 7 2012 09:19am

...okay , since you refuse to look inside your own heart and mind I am just going to tell you why...you have your own body image issues that have nothing to do with being overweight .

people need to be told these things

I see someone post one thing and decide to post a counteractive response

must mean i have body issues

This post was edited by cambovenzi on Oct 7 2012 09:22am

It's okay, don't stop and reflect at all. God forbid you actually pay any attention to yourself, and the rants that you were going on long before Lifebane mentioned size 0s.

that's what i said. he just wants to show off, the fact he was once obese confirms it. Ex fatties look down on fat people because they did what other fatties couldn't - lost weight. Overall i think people are too sensitive about everything. No one should actually give a fuck about this letter, but everything now revolves about political correctness. If you are fat - you gonna be called fattie. That's life.

Which actually shows that he is truly concerned and has a position to speak from.

Because we all know that Widow's internet psychoanalysis is relevant to the conversation and isn't just trying to dig up an ad hominem to divert attention away from the issue at hand.

...let's be honest here . You are a wisp of a man , a bare sliver of masculinity and probably borderline anorexic . If I saw you on the street I would give you a McDonalds coupon book because I have seen heavier Kenyan marathoners .

Nah the non sequitur is the part where you jump to an unfounded representation of what I believe despite multiple posts expressly against what you said.

When I post "she doesnt have to lose weight" like 4 times and you post something saying I think 'anyone who does struggle with their weight must be a big ol' lazy fat ass who should just live like me'

it couldn't be further from the truth and IS a fallacy. The logic does not follow.
Its a petty attempt to make me look bad and insult my character.