Quote (ThatAlex @ 18 Sep 2018 22:22)
Hindsight is 20/20, but Kethledge probably didn't have as many direct political ties and no questionable perjury or rape accusations.
Democrats would certainly ree against any pick short of Garland, but Kavanaugh has turned out to be a tricky pick to ram through. Hardiman probably would have been easier, too.
Afaik, with Kethledge, there were serious concerns that he might be weak on immigration. There was (is?) a real risk that he might become another David Souter.
Anyway, the real dealbreaker that put Kavanaugh in first place on Trump's list certainly was his opinion on executive prerogative and presidential immunity against criminal charges.