d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Ask A Christian > No Spam, Flaming, Etc. Etc.
Prev1515253545557Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Oct 11 2014 11:49am
Quote (nineinchnailz @ Oct 11 2014 11:45am)
What do you make of the story where God stops the sun in the sky?  It sounds as if God doesn't know the sun doesn't move through the sky but the Earth rotates.


That sounds pretty awesome actually.

Quote (nineinchnailz @ Oct 11 2014 12:46pm)
This is the obvious answer and point of bringing it up.  It's a story with an act of God that doesn't make sense given what we now know.


What we know now will change, do you think it won't?

That would be very naive.

Also scientific truth has more to do with power distribution in a given society than any real relationship to the truth, which is more or less undefinable as a concept, or very very difficult. We have theories, and they all have weaknesses.

I'm tempted to say that truth is inexpressible in words unless using a closed system logic, and then it is just a game .

This post was edited by Skinned on Oct 11 2014 11:51am
Member
Posts: 9,060
Joined: May 15 2010
Gold: 18,470.03
Oct 11 2014 11:53am
Quote (Skinned @ Oct 11 2014 12:49pm)
That sounds pretty awesome actually.



What we know now will change, do you think it won't?

That would be very naive.

Also scientific truth has more to do with power distribution in a given society than any real relationship to the truth, which is more or less undefinable as a concept, or very very difficult.  We have theories, and they all have weaknesses.

I'm tempted to say that truth is inexpressible in words unless using a closed system logic, and then it is just a game .


The fact that the earth rotates while orbiting the sun is not likely to change.
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Oct 11 2014 12:00pm
Quote (nineinchnailz @ Oct 11 2014 01:53pm)
The fact that the earth rotates while orbiting the sun is not likely to change.


It's guaranteed to change.
Member
Posts: 9,060
Joined: May 15 2010
Gold: 18,470.03
Oct 11 2014 12:05pm
Quote (Voyaging @ Oct 11 2014 01:00pm)
It's guaranteed to change.


You ignore the context sir. We're talking about biblical times not 2 billion years from now.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Oct 11 2014 12:05pm
Quote (Voyaging @ Oct 11 2014 01:00pm)
It's guaranteed to change.


And people will laugh at us for our beliefs. I think the things that future humans will ding us the most on is abortion and the use of money. But they won't understand us much like we don't understand our ancestors.
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Oct 11 2014 12:08pm
Quote (nineinchnailz @ Oct 11 2014 02:05pm)
You ignore the context sir.  We're talking about biblical times not 2 billion years from now.


Oh, then yes probably has been like that for a little while :P

Quote (Skinned @ Oct 11 2014 01:49pm)
I'm tempted to say that truth is inexpressible in words unless using a closed system logic, and then it is just a game .


Why do you think so? I think the opposite, there are loads of true propositions.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Oct 11 2014 12:20pm
Quote (Voyaging @ Oct 11 2014 01:08pm)
Oh, then yes probably has been like that for a little while :P



Why do you think so? I think the opposite, there are loads of true propositions.


I don't think that words and what they represent are quite the same. Our relationship to words is so personal and subjective that creating any sort of non-subjective truth from this is impossible. Math does this, but only in a closed and self-defined system. 2+2=4 because we made up 2s and 4s and assigned them meaning. 2s and 4s don't exist somewhere in Plato's world of Perfect Forms.
Member
Posts: 7,450
Joined: Jun 26 2008
Gold: 410.00
Oct 11 2014 01:11pm
Quote (bitg_pj @ Oct 11 2014 09:45am)
I'm curious how Christians believe only they are saved ... And in the same breath believe that anyone who doesn't isn't saved ...


But somehow ignore the convenient fact that billions of people live where Christianity is almost non existent ...

More than two thirds of the world will be sent to damnation . Lots of which will never hear of Christianity or will never be taught it... But those lucky ones born into Christian families must just be loved a lot more by Jesus



I definitely want to address this. First off, Christians as a whole do not ignore the fact that billions are not being told the gospel. In fact not Christians criticize us...either we get criticized for being outgoing about what Jesus has done in our lives or we get criticized because people don't know the good news. I addressed this in more detail a few pages back about those who haven't heard the gospel and how God is still just.

2nd: you are right more than two thirds of the world will probably be condemned. It does seem unfair, but actually the whole world should be condemned. The whole world...everyone...from a kid to a 100 year old sage...everyone has fallen short of the glory of God. Since all fall short, all should receive the punishment. But God loved people so much, he offered up his son in exchange...that isn't fair...so that a few can be saved.

3rd: God doesn't love anyone more or less because they are a Christian. This is a touchy topic even among Christians, but it can be defended biblically. "But God demonstrated his Love for us, that while we were sinners Christ died for us." The word "sinners" in this context lost/unsaved/condemned. God loved the lost even before they became Christians. Furthermore it says that all were created in the image of God. So I would agree by design it is easier for some people to find God, but there are plenty of people who grew up in Christian homes and are not Christian. In fact one of my friends was a pastor kid and stark Pagan.
Member
Posts: 7,450
Joined: Jun 26 2008
Gold: 410.00
Oct 11 2014 01:21pm
Quote (nineinchnailz @ Oct 11 2014 11:45am)
What do you make of the story where God stops the sun in the sky?  It sounds as if God doesn't know the sun doesn't move through the sky but the Earth rotates.


There is a reason we say the Bible is written by men and inspired by the Holy Spirit. Yes they were speaking out of their understanding of celestial bodies at the time. No, I don't believe God dictated exactly the words of the Bible, but God guided the authors of it. I would say he dictated the Judaic law as well as the actual spoken words of Jesus.

Now let's look at some of the truth behind the sentence. As you know the earth orbits around the sun assuming the sun is at a geometrically constant state. Well you can assume the sun is constant only when compared to the Earth and same with the moon. But in the universal picture the sun, the moon and the earth drift away from the core of the universe. So is it possible on that day God literally halted the outward expansion of the galaxies? I only bring this up to show that many people point to exact meanings in the Bible and say "ha! let me discredit it by this flaw!" But really much of Bible's teachings can be proven and many have even foreshadowed future scientific advancements.
Member
Posts: 60,934
Joined: Jan 24 2007
Gold: 351.00
Oct 11 2014 01:40pm
Quote (wofire @ Oct 11 2014 03:11pm)
I definitely want to address this. First off, Christians as a whole do not ignore the fact that billions are not being told the gospel. In fact not Christians criticize us...either we get criticized for being outgoing about what Jesus has done in our lives or we get criticized because people don't know the good news. I addressed this in more detail a few pages back about those who haven't heard the gospel and how God is still just.

2nd: you are right more than two thirds of the world will probably be condemned. It does seem unfair, but actually the whole world should be condemned. The whole world...everyone...from a kid to a 100 year old sage...everyone has fallen short of the glory of God. Since all fall short, all should receive the punishment. But God loved people so much, he offered up his son in exchange...that isn't fair...so that a few can be saved.

3rd: God doesn't love anyone more or less because they are a Christian. This is a touchy topic even among Christians, but it can be defended biblically. "But God demonstrated his Love for us, that while we were sinners Christ died for us." The word "sinners" in this context lost/unsaved/condemned. God loved the lost even before they became Christians. Furthermore it says that all were created in the image of God. So I would agree by design it is easier for some people to find God, but there are plenty of people who grew up in Christian homes and are not Christian. In fact one of my friends was a pastor kid and stark Pagan.


I'm sure the odds are astronomically small that someone from a rural village/hamlet like say....Pakistan...

would ever even meet a Christian or see a Bible , much less have the opportunity to convert....

Yet because you were born into Christianity you are nearly assured salvation because of your upbringing...

If that is a "just" god....I don't think I'd worship him either way
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1515253545557Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll