d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Kenosha Is Burning
Prev1495051525385Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 15,275
Joined: Sep 30 2009
Gold: 1,790.00
Aug 27 2020 11:16pm
Quote (Plaguefear @ Aug 28 2020 12:09am)
Hi, the cop that killed philandro castile walked, anything else?


In my earlier reply I acknowledged he was wrongly killed and I agree that he should've been imprisoned. How did this conversation go from "being shot for resisting arrest" to "murderer didn't get due justice"? There's a disconnect somewhere....
Member
Posts: 61,688
Joined: Mar 14 2006
Gold: 28.77
Aug 27 2020 11:22pm
Quote (TritonV8 @ Aug 27 2020 09:55pm)
In an instance where they would be complying with an officer, I would definitely be on your side for those cases. I'm not sure how a situation like this could be prevented 100% of the time or ensure accountability to the officers 100% of the time, but the best option currently would to require all law enforcement to wear body cams at all times. Unfortunately, there are departments across the US right now that can't afford them. There are probably better methods that make more sense fiscally, but I'm not sure what those would be. Until something is found, the only option I see currently is increasing police funding for body cams and definitely more training/better hiring screening/frequent psych and wellness evals/etc.



If Antifa cuffed you, tossed you to the ground, kneeled on you neck, and had AKs pointed at your head and told you to comply, would you comply with Antifa?

Let me rephrase that. If Antfia was about to do that to you but you had a chance to escape, what would you do? Knowing they see you as their enemy and would love to kill you. Would you let them?

This post was edited by inkanddagger on Aug 27 2020 11:25pm
Member
Posts: 49,896
Joined: Jun 19 2006
Gold: 3.88
Aug 27 2020 11:30pm
Quote (TritonV8 @ Aug 28 2020 03:16pm)
In my earlier reply I acknowledged he was wrongly killed and I agree that he should've been imprisoned. How did this conversation go from "being shot for resisting arrest" to "murderer didn't get due justice"? There's a disconnect somewhere....


The blm movement has always been about murder victims not getting justice.
You brought up reaching for something which WAS the defence the cop that killed philandro used, and he WALKED, i stated that you can use this defence to murder someone and get away with it.
Member
Posts: 15,275
Joined: Sep 30 2009
Gold: 1,790.00
Aug 27 2020 11:38pm
Quote (inkanddagger @ Aug 28 2020 12:22am)
If Antifa cuffed you, tossed you to the ground, kneeled on you neck, and had AKs pointed at your head and told you to comply, would you comply with Antifa?

Let me rephrase that. If Antfia was about to do that to you but you had a chance to escape, what would you do? Knowing they see you as their enemy and would love to kill you. Would you let them?


This is a ridiculous comparison. Antifa's motivations would be based on personal motivations and not because I broke the law. There are checks and balances for a reason. Since antifa is a group with domestic terrorist tendencies that doesn't adhere to any laws, I would try to escape since I don't have the option to be judges by 9, only the option of being lowered by 6.

Also using the absolute extreme examples (which happens in extreme rarity) doesn't point to a massive widespread problems through the system.
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Aug 27 2020 11:39pm
Member
Posts: 15,275
Joined: Sep 30 2009
Gold: 1,790.00
Aug 27 2020 11:42pm
Quote (Plaguefear @ Aug 28 2020 12:30am)
The blm movement has always been about murder victims not getting justice.
You brought up reaching for something which WAS the defence the cop that killed philandro used, and he WALKED, i stated that you can use this defence to murder someone and get away with it.


Which is why I oppose defunding the police. Taking funds away from police departments when they need body cams (which I think should be mandatory) would resolve this issue. The Blake incident clearly didn't happen this way and video clearly showed they tried tasing (didn't work), wrestling (didn't work), and finally him going to his vehicle and reaching for something. Completely justified in this instance.
Member
Posts: 61,688
Joined: Mar 14 2006
Gold: 28.77
Aug 27 2020 11:53pm
Quote (TritonV8 @ Aug 27 2020 10:38pm)
This is a ridiculous comparison. Antifa's motivations would be based on personal motivations and not because I broke the law. There are checks and balances for a reason. Since antifa is a group with domestic terrorist tendencies that doesn't adhere to any laws, I would try to escape since I don't have the option to be judges by 9, only the option of being lowered by 6.

Also using the absolute extreme examples (which happens in extreme rarity) doesn't point to a massive widespread problems through the system.


The cops actually do to black communities what terrified conservatives like you believe Antifa wants to do to you.

The police are personally motivated by racism and nationalism, enjoy a system of almost no checks and balances, and they are domestic terrorists who don't adhere to any laws.

This post was edited by inkanddagger on Aug 27 2020 11:54pm
Member
Posts: 15,275
Joined: Sep 30 2009
Gold: 1,790.00
Aug 28 2020 12:03am
Quote (Thor123422 @ Aug 28 2020 12:09am)
Video won't do anything without a system willing to hold the police to account.

Currently the prosecutors that charge the police are also the prosecutors that work with the police to charge suspects apprehended by the police. It's pretty easy to see how getting a fair trial there would be impossible.
The judiciary has also created some pretty ludicrous rules as well, such as qualified immunity, that severely restrict police accountability.
And then there's the fact that there's a straight line from the police administrations that abused minorities during Jim Crow, then during the drug war, to today.
And there's the fact that police officers have a shittier job than they should. We really should defund the police and allocate the newly freed funding to other services such as mental health workers so they can respond where the police aren't needed. The police shouldn't be expected to respond to everything from an armed robbery to John's autistic kid freaking out for the third time this week.

Anyway, the best part of these riots is people are taking these problems seriously now. It's not just seen as an attack on the police to want to fix these problems.


I can agree with the bolded parts above.
For the third point, I don't understand why you would support Biden since he authored the '94 Crime Bill that could play a role in this.
I disagree on defunding the police and replacing some police responses with mental health workers. Any situation that requires a call to police can escalate to something that a mental health worker couldn't handle. And in order for them to handle it, I think they would need to be able to handle it as well as a standard officer.
Member
Posts: 15,275
Joined: Sep 30 2009
Gold: 1,790.00
Aug 28 2020 12:12am
Quote (inkanddagger @ Aug 28 2020 12:53am)
The cops actually do to black communities what terrified conservatives like you believe Antifa wants to do to you.

The police are personally motivated by racism and nationalism, enjoy a system of almost no checks and balances, and they are domestic terrorists who don't adhere to any laws.


Responding to your "antifa holding me at gunpoint" example doesn't make me a terrified conservative. Do you always use this kind of intellectual dishonesty?

Since we're making blanket statements about police, I'm sure you mean the black/other minority officers as well, right? Or is this more intellectual dishonesty?
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Aug 28 2020 12:49am
Quote (TritonV8 @ Aug 28 2020 01:03am)
I can agree with the bolded parts above.
For the third point, I don't understand why you would support Biden since he authored the '94 Crime Bill that could play a role in this.
I disagree on defunding the police and replacing some police responses with mental health workers. Any situation that requires a call to police can escalate to something that a mental health worker couldn't handle. And in order for them to handle it, I think they would need to be able to handle it as well as a standard officer.


The most fundamental reason I support Biden is because Trump has, with absolutely no exaggeration, been the most corrupt president of our, our parents, and probably our grandparents lifetimes. His interference with the justice department alone is a level of corruption that dwarfs Nixon. Additionally, he is fundamentally incompetent in the position and as a result has cost us our position in the world and has allowed dangerous enemies like China to become policy makers in our place. We will likely never be able to make good deals with other countries again because Trump has shown how dangerously unbalanced our system can be if one bad president gets into office.

I could really go on for quite a while, but when the choice is one "meh" candidate and one unacceptably terrible candidate, that's pretty obvious.

In the primary I would have voted for Bernie, but it was after Super Tuesday where Biden had basically wiped him out.


If an autistic kid is having a fit, why would you have an armed police officer with only basic first aid training respond? You wouldn't. But that's the system we have, and we've literally had cases where cops were called to assist with a mentally handicapped person and ended up shooting them. Defunding the police is an absolute necessity and is actually supported by the police as long as you call it by a different name. People hear "defund the police" and they just hear take away money, but it actually means "shift funding from police to other services to take unnecessary burden from the police"

This post was edited by Thor123422 on Aug 28 2020 12:52am
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1495051525385Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll