d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > The Present (with Religion)
Prev1495051525354Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 576
Joined: Mar 5 2012
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 27 2012 11:14pm
Quote (mike14e @ Oct 27 2012 10:59pm)
Not rejecting everything in the book, its a legit question. Args against dualism? I wont list them here bc ill have to go thru my notes/books but check out Foucault's Arg, simon de Beauvoir, judith butler, luce irigaray for starters. You probably know or have heard of foucault, the other 3 are pretty well known feminist philosophers.


Lol tbh I've never researched the other side. It just makes sense to what ive experienced and would need a serious rebuttal that wouldn't need to be complicated, just something to refute everything has an opposite, or 2 directions, in every direction. I understand how it doesn't look like two sides but two sides in every direction. I don't see more than two directions and I have never heard anyone say differently. But I will look up what is said against it for sure.
Member
Posts: 21,265
Joined: Mar 8 2006
Gold: 55.44
Oct 28 2012 05:35am
Quote (mike14e @ 28 Oct 2012 04:02)
What kind of shitty dualism is this guy rambling on about?

Does he every justify dualism or is it just an underlying assumption he makes?


Everything that is physical has its opposite, physical life is balanced.
I find the explanation on that quote pretty clear, isn't it ?
Member
Posts: 20,217
Joined: Mar 20 2007
Gold: 431.00
Oct 28 2012 07:22am
Quote (Eti_fr @ 27 Oct 2012 08:34)
What exactly enrages you in this thread ?
The only purpose of this thread is to show people the truth... If you are not ready to face reality it is ok, I do not judge you, you do not have to get so angry.
Remember : your mind creates your emotions. If you are angry it is not my fault, it is your mind's fault.

Throw your hatred down :) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HXzDH92rrc8


What makes me rage is that you have a single answer to every single critic, and it doesn't matter who or for what reason.

"You aren't ready to face reality".

Well guess what. If you told somebody on the street any number of these comments that you have written in the thread, you might get arrested for public intoxication. But since the internet is a cold and (unusually) forgiving place, you will never see your own reality check. Feel free to continue bumping your own topic.

Quote (Cannabist @ 27 Oct 2012 09:42)
I lol'd hard.


My roommate is making me buy a new IKEA table today so we get our stupid deposit back. Fucking thing is toasted.
Member
Posts: 21,265
Joined: Mar 8 2006
Gold: 55.44
Oct 28 2012 07:43am
Quote (general_patton @ 28 Oct 2012 15:22)
What makes me rage is that you have a single answer to every single critic, and it doesn't matter who or for what reason.

"You aren't ready to face reality".
Well guess what. If you told somebody on the street any number of these comments that you have written in the thread, you might get arrested for public intoxication. But since the internet is a cold and (unusually) forgiving place, you will never see your own reality check. Feel free to continue bumping your own topic.



My roommate is making me buy a new IKEA table today so we get our stupid deposit back. Fucking thing is toasted.


Well, if you do not agree 2+2=4 (there is only one truth), you are not ready to face reality... I am sorry if it makes you rage, but it is a true fact.
I do not judge anyone, we live in a world where almost everything is lies and illusions, so it is not easy to face the truth.
You just have to understand on simple fact : you are more than your body (which includes your mind), you are the spirit listening to your senses (including your mind).
Just open your mind and listen to your 5 other senses.
Reality (the present moment) can not be experienced through your mind, it can be experienced through your 5 other senses.

About what you said about the street... Remember Jesus was crucified. Actually, most people telling the truth was persecuted in the past.
The internet is one of the tools that makes us ready to wake up and face the truth. Think about the impact of Jesus message, and how it would be even much bigger if he could use the internet instead of mouth to mouth (the main positive aspect is he would not be translated/interpreted... and he would also reach the whole world directly or at least much faster) :)
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Oct 28 2012 11:01am
Quote (mike14e @ Oct 27 2012 11:59pm)
Not rejecting everything in the book, its a legit question. Args against dualism? I wont list them here bc ill have to go thru my notes/books but check out Foucault's Arg, simon de Beauvoir, judith butler, luce irigaray for starters. You probably know or have heard of foucault, the other 3 are pretty well known feminist philosophers.


None of the people you named are even slightly respected in the academic community.
Member
Posts: 24,983
Joined: Jun 28 2011
Gold: 165.86
Oct 28 2012 03:02pm
Quote (Voyaging @ Oct 28 2012 01:01pm)
None of the people you named are even slightly respected in the academic community.


You serious? Don't know what academic communtiy you are talking about, and not trying to be condescending, but are you part of the philosophical academic community in any way? If so how? Have you read any feminist philosophy? Because the three I mentioned are very well known and respected. And Michel Foucault lol if you are trying to say his work isn't respected I'm going to assume you have little to no philosophical training, or you are highly concentrated in one area (this is possible bc based on what I've seen in your other posts you seemed well educated on philosophy, but this comment is extremely misinformed).
"Foucault was listed as the most cited scholar in the humanities in 2007 by the ISI Web of Science.[233]" - from Foucault's wikipedia page.

And Eti_fr for the benefit of everyone ill create a separate thread some time giving a critique/critiques of dualism from a few diff sources so we can openly debate it.
Member
Posts: 21,265
Joined: Mar 8 2006
Gold: 55.44
Oct 28 2012 03:25pm
Quote (mike14e @ 28 Oct 2012 23:02)
You serious? Don't know what academic communtiy you are talking about, and not trying to be condescending, but are you part of the philosophical academic community in any way? If so how? Have you read any feminist philosophy? Because the three I mentioned are very well known and respected. And Michel Foucault lol if you are trying to say his work isn't respected I'm going to assume you have little to no philosophical training, or you are highly concentrated in one area (this is possible bc based on what I've seen in your other posts you seemed well educated on philosophy, but this comment is extremely misinformed).
"Foucault was listed as the most cited scholar in the humanities in 2007 by the ISI Web of Science.[233]" - from Foucault's wikipedia page.

And Eti_fr for the benefit of everyone ill create a separate thread some time giving a critique/critiques of dualism from a few diff sources so we can openly debate it.


Ok sure, pm me the link once it is done... but I fear there is not much to debate about, physical life is balanced no matter what you think :)
Read my last post on my blog here, I talk about balance http://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=64459387&f=276

This post was edited by Eti_fr on Oct 28 2012 03:25pm
Member
Posts: 21,265
Joined: Mar 8 2006
Gold: 55.44
Oct 29 2012 04:47pm
Quote
Plants: Plants are non-conscious forms of life. They are like your arm or leg. They are alive, but not conscious. Non-conscious life supports conscious life. You are connected to trees and other plants as certainly as you are connected to your arms and legs. You are also connected to all non-living things, the earth and the air etc., because they make our life possible. Everything in the universe is as much a part of you as your skin. Some people think human beings are somehow separate from the rest of nature. The truth is, we are just a part of nature. It should be obvious; everything is a part of the whole. Nothing is separate in the truth and the life. We are interdependent and all part of the same reality.

The history of nature is our history, because we are just part of nature.
We would not be here without plants. They give us physical life by feeding our bodies directly and indirectly, and they support our spiritual life with their presence. You can open up anywhere, anytime, but it is easiest to live in the present (especially for beginners), when you are out in nature. Camping, hiking, boating, and other activities out in nature will become more popular. Gardening, home and community farming are going to get much more popular. Spiritual people will bring as much of nature as we can into our lives. Everyone is going to go green and live lives that help the natural environment. The Bible tells us to. The environment will become sacred to everyone that sees the truth.

People have a misconception about animals living in the wild. We grew up watching Bambi and Disney movies, and we do not realize what life is really like in the wild. It is literally dog eat dog, predators and their prey, eat and be eaten.

Nature is only beautiful if you do not look at the nature of nature.
All animal life is like living with serial killers on every block that eat you, and there would be no police or weapons to protect ourselves. That is the reality of life in the animal world. We were there (in their skin) for more than ninety-nine percent of the time we have been on earth, and we are still there now. We are not out of the woods yet.

Only humans and their pets die of old age. Most wild animals get eaten before they reach old age. They live in a very brutal and savage world.

When we want something to eat, we just go to a store or a restaurant. It was not too long ago that we had to go out, catch another animal, kill it, clean it and cook it. We had to work from dawn to dusk just to get enough food to survive. It took up all of our time and we failed and starved to death most of the time. While doing this hunting, we were being hunted; we became the killed and eaten until just recently. Natural life is a constant struggle for survival. We were food for other animals as recently as ten-thousand years ago. No animals die of old age; most are killed by other animals. It would be like having a serial killer kill all of us just past middle age. It is not a good way to go, and keeps you in the cycle.

Our children were the preferred meal, and starvation and being eaten was the fate of most of our children until just recently. It still is for all lower animals that live in the wild. That is why most animals have so many offspring. They have to, because most will be eaten. Seeing your children being eaten is not happiness.


From page 129 of The Present (with religion) at http://www.truthcontest.com/
Member
Posts: 576
Joined: Mar 5 2012
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 30 2012 01:29pm
:thumbsup:
Member
Posts: 112,095
Joined: Jul 25 2008
Gold: 40.42
Oct 30 2012 01:33pm
lol, such horseshit. Everything that is alive and not conscious shares the quality of being like your legs because your legs are alive and not conscious. I seriously haven't read such bad logic since the last quote.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1495051525354Next
Closed New Topic New Poll