Quote (Thor123422 @ Jul 24 2020 08:53pm)
I disagree that the police are fundamentally not to blame. They have the "just following orders" excuse, but since when is that acceptable? The police violence of today is in direct continuity of the violence against civil rights protesters, and so is the rhetoric defending it. We haven't had a significant period where the police weren't used to brutalize minority communities to create a disconnect. Right after civil rights happened federal drug laws were created and sentences were specifically created to be worse for substances more likely to be used to groups the administration didn't like, and again the police were the ones carrying out arrests for things that the previous year was legal. In places where lynch mobs rose up and burned black neighborhoods the police were there with the white mobs. Anyway, my point is that I don't see some kind of disconnect between what's happening today and the violence of 100 years ago. The institutions and tactics are continuous even if the individuals aren't.
"Just following orders" has never been an excuse. The police aren't to blame because they fundamentally aren't what is wrong with race relations in this country. They kill blacks at proportionate rates considering the rate of black violent crime. Why blacks represent a very high rate of violent crime is a separate matter. We'd be remiss if we tried to simplify this situation into either of two extremes. Black crime is not a function of genetic inferiority. Police officers are not sadistic demons bent on racial oppression.
The war on drugs was a mistake in hindsight, but we need to be careful when we're ascribing agency to a small group of people ("...the administration") for widely held societal beliefs. The war on drugs was popular, and the NAACP was part of that crusade. Black communities recognized the perverse social ill of drug addiction and demanded action, along with the American public at large. Legislators answered the call, solved a problem by creating others, and we're left cleaning up the mess today. Let's not compound that mistake by re-imagining the origins of government policy.
Blacks have not been specifically targeted for oppression in recent decades as ignored. They tend to be statistically poor, they aren't a swing demographic, and they're electorally concentrated in a way that deprives them of relevant political power. The Democratic party has their votes, and the Republican party is loathe to contest the issue. The single best thing we could do for inner city black communities is promote school choice and crack down on gang crime. But we aren't going to make progress there, the Democratic party is in the pockets of the teacher unions and the Republican party doesn't care.
This post was edited by bogie160 on Jul 24 2020 07:51pm