d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Why Is There No Green Right Movement?
Prev14567811Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 65,046
Joined: Jul 7 2008
Gold: Locked
Jan 30 2020 03:55pm
Because the fundamental worldview that guides the right is individualism. It is "me and mine". It is one of creating great personal success.

Climate change is unlikely to radically affect my life. From the point of view of maximizing my personal success, why would I expend resources on something unlikely to impact me?

Why make large investments in solving the problems of the next generation, when solving the problems of the current one pay so much better?
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Jan 30 2020 03:57pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jan 30 2020 04:52pm)
Second time you posted this notion of religion being somehow behind the right not caring for the earth and to be honest it's not consistent with reality.

Economics/money is the real reason not religion. I'm a christian and have been for a long time and literally never heard the argument in real life being used that because there's an afterlife we could essentially have a yolo lifestyle here and screw the earth which is pretty antithetical to core christian doctrine. I'm sure some people do have this view but most Christians i know view themselves as stewards, as it's talked about in the Bible of both money and the environment.



Yeah it's a possibility, i do think as people age out of their 20s and 30s they tend to get more conservative


I'm aware that most christians aren't aware of the etiology of their beliefs. Asking average Christian what happened at the council of Trent or the council of nice and they will you a blank stare. How transubstantiation works... Lot of them don't know the Gospels outside of The Bible... Or why the Gospels that are in The Bible are in The Bible.

They ultimately fail at knowing thyself. To the average Christian religion is a regional phenomenon and a social club.

I will reiterate that religion is typically a regional thing like sports teams.

This post was edited by Skinned on Jan 30 2020 04:00pm
Member
Posts: 54,185
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Jan 30 2020 04:00pm
To quote myself:

Quote (Black XistenZ @ 29 Jan 2020 16:53)
Abandoning fossils right now in favor of renewables would cause all of us to become poorer, less mobile and to lose comfort.
I'm all for adding renewables into the mix where it is economically prudent and technologicaly feasible to do so. The true crux is that this wont be enough if the climate models are to be believed.
So, at the end of the day, we're talking about a movement/ideology which tries to sell "sacrifice for the greater good" and "inevitable radical change into an uncertain future" to people, and that's naturally not very attractive.

It seems very logical to me that such a movement/ideology is gaining more traction with the political left, which emphasizes postmaterial values like fairness, cooperation and internationalism. On top, climate change is very welcome as a door opener for a radical restructuring of the economic system, towards a (more) planned economy, which obviously appeals to leftists. Similarly, it seems very logical to me that the message of the climate change movement doesnt play well with the political right, which emphasizes wealth, growth, economic freedom and national sovereignty.


Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Jan 30 2020 04:02pm
Quote (Skinned @ Jan 30 2020 04:57pm)
I'm aware that most christians aren't aware of the etiology of their beliefs. Asking average Christian what happened at the council of Trent or the council of nice and they will you a blank stare.


Asking average humans obscure historical events and getting blank stares is expected. If i ask the average college student, even graduate student if they believe science to be important and then subsequently ask about Descartes contribution to science then i'll also be met with blank stares.

So not really sure what your obsession with Christians is really, or do you just have higher standards for us?
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Jan 30 2020 04:10pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jan 30 2020 05:02pm)
Asking average humans obscure historical events and getting blank stares is expected. If i ask the average college student, even graduate student if they believe science to be important and then subsequently ask about Descartes contribution to science then i'll also be met with blank stares.

So not really sure what your obsession with Christians is really, or do you just have higher standards for us?


The difference is people don't worship rene Descartes as a living God dumb ass.

If people truly believed that rene Des cartes gave them life a created the universe then they might know more about him.

I'm sure the God you worship really loves being compared to the man that codified the atheistic materialistic worldview.

This post was edited by Skinned on Jan 30 2020 04:11pm
Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Jan 30 2020 04:16pm
Quote (Skinned @ Jan 30 2020 05:10pm)
The difference is people don't worship rene Descartes as a living God dumb ass.

If people truly believed that rene Des cartes gave them life a created the universe then they might know more about him.

I'm sure the God you worship really loves being compared to the man that codified the atheistic materialistic worldview.


Neither do Christians worship the council of Trent.

How stupid can you be to equate Catholic church history to belief in God? Does not knowing a specific piece of church history invalidate my belief in a Biblical God?

Logic really isn't your strong suit is it.

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Jan 30 2020 04:16pm
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Jan 30 2020 04:27pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jan 30 2020 05:16pm)
Neither do Christians worship the council of Trent.

How stupid can you be to equate Catholic church history to belief in God? Does not knowing a specific piece of church history invalidate my belief in a Biblical God?

Logic really isn't your strong suit is it.


I have a bachelors degree in philosophy along with my BSW and MSW, which covers ethics, logic, metaphysics, and epistemology.

A few others here can probably do predicate calculus or Boolean logic.

Thundercock is a computer scientist so I suspect he could be better at logic than me. The guy who taught me predicate calculus created the Cincinnati Bell long distance network :)

I expect you'll probly have to Google those things, while saying I'm bad at those things.

Honestly you know key just hit one of my pet peeves which is people misusing the word logic.

This post was edited by Skinned on Jan 30 2020 04:28pm
Member
Posts: 7,365
Joined: Mar 3 2016
Gold: 0.70
Warn: 20%
Jan 30 2020 04:39pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Jan 30 2020 05:16pm)
Neither do Christians worship the council of Trent.

How can you equate Catholic church history to belief in God? Does not knowing a specific piece of church history invalidate my belief in a Biblical God?


Fixed. IMO insults during a conversation make you look pretty stupid yourself. We are all adults here.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Jan 30 2020 04:58pm
Quote (lll420lll @ Jan 30 2020 05:39pm)
Fixed. IMO insults during a conversation make you look pretty stupid yourself. We are all adults here.


He's all pathos thinks he's logos.

What can you do?

I'll affirm the consequent and deny the antecedent in arguments just to fuck with him for now on.

Sometimes you just have to lean in and have fun.

A lot of people here call me stupid because I disagree with them on value statements.

I don't think anyone who thinks about politics and religion are stupid.

This post was edited by Skinned on Jan 30 2020 04:58pm
Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Jan 30 2020 05:00pm
Quote (Skinned @ Jan 30 2020 05:27pm)
I have a bachelors degree in philosophy along with my BSW and MSW, which covers ethics, logic, metaphysics, and epistemology.

A few others here can probably do predicate calculus or Boolean logic.

Thundercock is a computer scientist so I suspect he could be better at logic than me. The guy who taught me predicate calculus created the Cincinnati Bell long distance network :)

I expect you'll probly have to Google those things, while saying I'm bad at those things.

Honestly you know key just hit one of my pet peeves which is people misusing the word logic.


Cool appeal to authority but that doesn't change that you equated a specific piece of church history to belief in God. I don't need to know who the pope was in the 1500's to believe in God, just like a scientist doesn't need to know every detail of Descartes findings to practice science today.

Your argument is illogical though, it's neither cogent or valid.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev14567811Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll