Quote (bogie160 @ 3 May 2024 18:48)
The former is virulent and genocidal antisemitism representing the heart of the modern American left.
Quote (bogie160 @ 4 May 2024 00:19)
I don't like the KKK comparison, because we're talking about a handful of losers (KKK) versus millions of people (the American hard left).
If the American right was afraid of the Proud Boy demographic (are they?), I'd consider it a fair comparison. Joe Biden is afraid of what the hard left thinks, clearly, hence the bothsideism.
I think the key crux is that on the modern American (/Western) left, it is the thought leaders who have radicalized while the rank and file has mostly gone along with it (so far). By contrast, on the modern right, it was the base which demanded a more radical course while the traditional party elites and thought leaders tried to moderate and rein them in. Which created the opening for the Trumpist intra-party revolution. But even Trump is occasionally a moderating influence, e.g. on abortion or when it comes to cutting social services.
So no, I don't think that genocidal antisemitism (or, more broadly speaking, postcolonialism) is the heart of the American left, but it is the predominant ideology of its activist class. Over the past 10-15 years, the liberal rank and file have mostly followed the lead and embraced the increasingly insane and pernicious ideology and policy - but they have pushed back on their side's top-down radicalism from time to time. The prime example is the misguided 'defund the police'-movement and how "progressive" DAs who refused to prosecute crime have already been voted out of office even in many deep blue cities. I think that the current frenzy on American colleges might go the same way, with the bulk of the base eventually rejecting them.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on May 5 2024 03:23am