Quote (Thebarba @ Dec 20 2023 12:25am)
Are you living exclusively in your own head, son? He didn't say anything about a physical civil war. I read it as a high-altitude commentary of the integrity of the system and the endemic system failure caused by shattered trust. We have a country founded based on following established rules and those rules are undermined by these attacks on the system by corrupt lawfare sleazebags.
No, I mean actual physical civil war, want to clear up any confusion. That's just the logical progression of events if the country balkanizes. Has there been any country that spiraled into partisan conflict bitter enough to have secessionist movements
without armed conflict?
Its just an issue of following that question of '
what comes next?'
Say the supreme court doesn't intervene to restore sanity. Say we go into the election year with Trump barred from ballots in multiple states. He remains the Republican candidate, its Trump vs Biden, but Democrats both try to block people from being able to vote for Trump, and maybe even issue arrest and imprisonment orders against him. Now what actually happens as a result? What happens if Florida refuses to extradite him? What happens if Texas declares it won't recognize the election as legitimate if other states bar Trump? And if that election is held, and Biden wins, what happens? We've seen plenty of precedent for this from banana republics and autocratic dictatorships around the world. If a centralized power is strong enough it can simply crush all dissent with an iron fist and force people in line, but that will never work in a partisan America, where half the country will be "uncooperative". Its a proximate spark to a conflict. People won't have the option to simply go about their daily lives and assume politics will sort itself out and go on like normal. Folks aren't just going to say, oh, the election was
actually rigged and stolen, and we were all disenfranchised, guess we'll wait another 4 years to try again. Something will have to give.
You can't just end democracy in the US and assume life will go on as before. We have 50 states with far too strong localized governance to let that fly. Just forming the country took all kinds of tooth pulling from the states to secure their rights and interests and protect them from tyranny of the majority. Why would those states remain in the union if they're being disenfranchised? And history shows that never ends peacefully. I don't think we could predict anything down a line that chaotic, only the general gist of 'hey, maybe lighting the powder keg
isn't a good idea'
But of course, I'd like to believe none of this is possible and won't happen, because no matter how demented Democrats try to be, sanity will prevail and peel us back from the edge.