Quote (Surfpunk @ Sep 18 2021 02:12pm)
By what metric do you make this claim?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal)_per_capitaRemove the tax havens and you're left with Norway and the United States. The PPP per capita picture doesn't look all that different.
Quote (fender @ Sep 18 2021 01:55pm)
funny, no one even mentioned hdi (in which you rank 17 btw), it's almost like you just HAVE to strawman the issue because you don't actually have an argument against the FACT that your shitty social safety nets and policies are NOT a consequence of economic affordability, but a matter of choice (by your oligarchs).
also, it's so typically ignorant american to genuinely believe that western prosperity is a result of their ingenuity and inventions, as if the likes of germany, france, uk, japan, italy... hadn't contributed massively. if you had the slightest idea how dumb that made you sound... i mean, it's almost like the ridiculous notion that strong social safety nets were limited to a few privileged nations, wasn't hilariously wrong enough...
you really don't have the slightest clue about the rest of the world, do you? that's almost cartoonishly american, lol...
Your argument is a truism. European social safety nets are good because they're good. When we look at weighted calculations (e.g. HDI) that try to account for life expectancy, education, and wealth, we don't find that more social spending is necessarily better. Given how unhealthy Americans like to eat (our food is both affordable and plentiful), I'm shocked that the United States scores that highly. I'm really trying to give you the benefit of the doubt.
And as I said, the United States is a country on scale with the European Union. There's enormous geographic and economic diversity. Alabama is no more going to be as wealthy as Massachusetts as Greece is going to be as wealthy as Norway. But when we take it as a whole, we see that the American model has worked to provide a comparatively higher standard of living.
I'm not here to shit on the EU's spending decisions, I am pointing out that your portrayal of the United States doesn't match reality. It is a different model that, despite shouldering the defensive burden of freeloaders, has consistently delivered some of the highest living standards in the world.