d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > October Invasion Of Israel
Prev14734744754764771669Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
Nov 6 2023 05:13am
Quote (ferdia @ Nov 6 2023 10:53am)
/edit, fine, thank you.

also



by all accounts Netanyahu is the moderate in his party, are you suggesting another party will / may be in government in Israel ? after the terrorist attack by Hamas, surely this will bolster his party, not weaken it, accepted that some (%? unknown) people have, misgivings, about him. And what of the Palestinian leadership? this refers specifically to that of the West Bank, right? and is completely separate from Hamas? Its their spokesman in the UN or ? I see nothing to suggest a unified Palestinian authority, either now or in the future, which includes the ppl of gaza (wherever they may live in the future).


Afaik Netanyahu has extremely low approval ratings now. Not only from his personal vendetta against Israels judicial system, essentially a cult of personality where he sought to become a dictator/president for life style leader.
But for his massive failure in allowing an attack like 10/7 to happen on his watch.
He was known as "Mr Security" ironically. Just another example of authoritarian personality cults being utterly dreadful at miltary/security operation. Due to self absorption and lack of good intel akin to Putin or Chi purging those around them that bring "bad news" on anything.

I'm not well enough informed on Israels political parties. But 2 things are clear.
Firstly Netanyahu has been in and around power for decades, he has failed to bring peace and a future for the region.
Secondly his approval is so low, he will be gone before any lasting resolution can begin in earnest.

From what I understand the PLO are very ineffective in terms of having consensus of a majority of Palestinians.
Many Palestinians do see success for the PLO in terms of abolishing the state or Israel. Something that will not happen.
An unattainable goal.
Further Mahmoud Abbas is 87 years old. He is out of touch and generally weak.
When Palestinian leaders seek progress in negotiations it can never deliver what Palestinians believe they deserve which is the whole region become a single state of Palestine.

There needs to be a re evaluation of the possible goals of the Palestinian people in terms of statehood. A leader is needed who can communicate that position and find consensus wherever that position is between abolishing Israel and never having a Palestinian state.
Member
Posts: 52,226
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Nov 6 2023 05:15am
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ Nov 6 2023 05:01am)
The Arab/Gulf states. Not Iran for obvious reasons.
Really need to step up imo. Financially and in terms of leadership.

They are happy to protest Israels reaction but many of them still don't recognize Israels existence, don't condemn Hamas terrorists and are not strong enough to assure the region is not an utter shithole rife with extremists and terrorists.

Saudi are busy building a fucking linear city while 2 millions Gazans live of 80 aid trucks per day.
Qatar are hosting world cups and investing in European football clubs.
Where is the leadership and strength to find a solution and improve the lives of Arabs across the region?

If you don't want the US policing the globe then make a deterrent of their own against terrorism and more generally against the Iranian regimes support for terrorism.


The Saudi are busy manufacturing radical Wahhabism to export globally. It focuses potential opposition to the Saudi regime and directs it elsewhere. Saudi Arabia is as much, if not more, an exporter and supporter of terrorists than Iran is.
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
Nov 6 2023 05:16am
Quote (WhiteSouned @ Nov 6 2023 11:12am)
Personally, I’m against this..
imo Israel doesn’t need any “expansion”.
You do need to understand that we have our own radicals that more or less are doing as they want.. during my service I ran after those illegal settlers all over the place. I didn’t enjoy it at all.
The police is helpless and the army is not the current authority to restrain them.
I do hope that something will change after this war. With the security of our country and with our policies for future solutions.
It’s not a secret that our public is divided in that issue (not only, but it is a major thing).. we had 4 elections just two years ago..


Isn't the issue fundamentally from radical Jews that believe the land of Israel is promised to them by God himself.

An absurd idea non compatible with modern existence imo.
Member
Posts: 56,464
Joined: Jan 19 2007
Gold: 578,201.52
Nov 6 2023 05:20am
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ Nov 6 2023 11:13am)
Afaik Netanyahu has extremely low approval ratings now. Not only from his personal vendetta against Israels judicial system, essentially a cult of personality where he sought to become a dictator/president for life style leader.
But for his massive failure in allowing an attack like 10/7 to happen on his watch.
He was known as "Mr Security" ironically. Just another example of authoritarian personality cults being utterly dreadful at miltary/security operation. Due to self absorption and lack of good intel akin to Putin or Chi purging those around them that bring "bad news" on anything.

I'm not well enough informed on Israels political parties. But 2 things are clear.
Firstly Netanyahu has been in and around power for decades, he has failed to bring peace and a future for the region.
Secondly his approval is so low, he will be gone before any lasting resolution can begin in earnest.

From what I understand the PLO are very ineffective in terms of having consensus of a majority of Palestinians.
Many Palestinians do see success for the PLO in terms of abolishing the state or Israel. Something that will not happen.
An unattainable goal.
Further Mahmoud Abbas is 87 years old. He is out of touch and generally weak.
When Palestinian leaders seek progress in negotiations it can never deliver what Palestinians believe they deserve which is the whole region become a single state of Palestine.

There needs to be a re evaluation of the possible goals of the Palestinian people in terms of statehood. A leader is needed who can communicate that position and find consensus wherever that position is between abolishing Israel and never having a Palestinian state.


whats your view on all this ? i.e. where do you see Israeli politic's heading, say, in the next 2-4 years ?

This post was edited by ferdia on Nov 6 2023 05:20am
Member
Posts: 18,128
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Nov 6 2023 05:27am
Quote (ferdia @ 6 Nov 2023 13:20)
^Many_Names whats your view on all this ? i.e. where do you see Israeli politic's heading, say, in the next 2-4 years ?


I see netanyahu going home
And benny gantz or naftali bennet becoming prime minister

I am all for settlements as long as people in it know they will be part of any agreement in the future (to use it as pressure not forever)

I also think the solution should include territorial swap.
Give palestinians land in the southern west bank so Israel will have defendable borders from east to west.
I also think west bank should be demilitarized area, and have an American and Israel to defend and help them if they are attacked from
The outside.

Furthermore, I think there will he war at the north to annihilate hezbollah.

This post was edited by Many_Names on Nov 6 2023 05:28am
Member
Posts: 18,128
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Nov 6 2023 05:30am
Quote (Prox1m1ty @ 6 Nov 2023 13:16)
Isn't the issue fundamentally from radical Jews that believe the land of Israel is promised to them by God himself.

An absurd idea non compatible with modern existence imo.


Minority and irrelevant
The settlements were part of any offer made to the PLO.
Member
Posts: 18,128
Joined: Dec 3 2006
Gold: 0.00
Nov 6 2023 05:36am
Quote (Santara @ 6 Nov 2023 13:15)
The Saudi are busy manufacturing radical Wahhabism to export globally. It focuses potential opposition to the Saudi regime and directs it elsewhere. Saudi Arabia is as much, if not more, an exporter and supporter of terrorists than Iran is.


I think saudi understands the oil will not last forever and therefore invest in education
Wahabism and education wont go together
Member
Posts: 50,915
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,335.99
Nov 6 2023 07:43am
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Nov 6 2023 03:13am)
You don't want the Indians to replace the Labor / Migrant jobs to be honest.


Yeah then Israel might be like the rest of the world....? I've learned a lot of hindu and cribbed a lot of recipes in the past few years. Heck theres a whole little delhi popping up with markets and restaurants
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
Nov 6 2023 07:48am
Quote (Santara @ Nov 6 2023 11:15am)
The Saudi are busy manufacturing radical Wahhabism to export globally. It focuses potential opposition to the Saudi regime and directs it elsewhere. Saudi Arabia is as much, if not more, an exporter and supporter of terrorists than Iran is.


I would agree with that generally. I think radical factions of Islam have brought untold misery to countless numbers of people.

I also think countries in the west should wake up now about having these naive open door policies for migrants from the middle east or any region with radical Islam.

It is a generalisation but in the round i believe it is true; That Muslims, particularly Arab Muslims will always see themselves as Muslims and or Arabs first, before they will ever identify as citizens of western nations. Perhaps understandly so. But this is 100% to the detriment of countries that hold democracy, liberty and personal freedom as tenets of their society.
Member
Posts: 50,915
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,335.99
Nov 6 2023 07:59am
Quote (Santara @ Nov 6 2023 04:43am)
Whether you remember or not, I'm generally pro-Israeli in this fight, but I don't see how this is the case when Israel continually expands settlements in the West Bank.


I can't help but feel like Netanyahu allowing the creeping settlements was more like a realist acknowledging how long dead and abandoned the 2SS was rather than an actual wrench thrown in it. It wasn't like we went straight from Rabin and the Oslo accords and Camp David summit to Israel spiking the peace efforts. It was a few decades of Hamas vowing death to all jews, the total irreconciliable fracture of Palestinian politics and end of elections and a second intifada and multiple US presidents just giving up on it. By the time Netanyahu really started appeasing his far right and leaning into a harder line, the two state solution was less realistic than korean reconciliation.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev14734744754764771669Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll