d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Sanctions Are Useless
Prev1345679Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 52,225
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Feb 28 2022 09:09pm
Quote (Vastet @ Feb 28 2022 08:57pm)
Poland had a very bad time, doesn't mean Germany or USSR wasn't worse.

Noone is one word or two words, or even a hyphenated word. I'm always amused when someone attempts to make a statement on how language should be and is demonstrably wrong. Something like a 95% rate of failure in my experience.


More Polish civilians died than Germans.

Except it's not demonstrably wrong. The opposite is true. https://www.grammarly.com/blog/no-one-noone/

/e and China. China lost WAY more civilians.

This post was edited by Santara on Feb 28 2022 09:14pm
Member
Posts: 1,559
Joined: Nov 11 2021
Gold: 11.65
Feb 28 2022 09:15pm
Quote (Santara @ 28 Feb 2022 22:09)
More Polish civilians died than Germans.

Except it's not demonstrably wrong. The opposite is true. https://www.grammarly.com/blog/no-one-noone/


Except it is demonstrably wrong. As any linguist will tell you, once a word is used it exists. I used it, therefore it exists. Furthermore, it was in use before anyone alive today was born.
Death is better than what Germany did to it's own people.
Member
Posts: 52,225
Joined: Jan 3 2009
Gold: 8,902.00
Feb 28 2022 09:20pm
Quote (Vastet @ Feb 28 2022 09:15pm)
Except it is demonstrably wrong. As any linguist will tell you, once a word is used it exists. I used it, therefore it exists. Furthermore, it was in use before anyone alive today was born.
Death is better than what Germany did to it's own people.


That's like saying ballisticbubblegum or jkhdsdiub are words simply because I wrote them. This isn't quantum physics, I'm not disputing that they exist, I am disputing that they are words.
Member
Posts: 1,559
Joined: Nov 11 2021
Gold: 11.65
Feb 28 2022 09:41pm
Quote (Santara @ 28 Feb 2022 22:20)
That's like saying ballisticbubblegum or jkhdsdiub are words simply because I wrote them. This isn't quantum physics, I'm not disputing that they exist, I am disputing that they are words.


You don't get to decide what is and isn't a word by yourself. It's a social decision everyone who speaks the language gets a voice in, including people who aren't born yet. If ballisticbubblegum starts getting used then it will appear in the dictionary once the makers of said dictionary are satisfied it sees sufficient use. Stranger words have become commonplace.
Member
Posts: 27,151
Joined: Mar 11 2016
Gold: 9.77
Warn: 10%
Feb 28 2022 09:48pm
Quote (Dolphy @ 28 Feb 2022 20:42)
my point is that rather than being a product of sanctions, germany is a product of massive economic investment post ww2.

look further to the east if you wanna know how decades of heavy sanctions and exclusion treats national economies


He isn't going to stop moving the goal post even if his ever changing premises start to not make any sense.
Member
Posts: 22,026
Joined: Jun 14 2012
Gold: 334,073.27
Warn: 10%
Feb 28 2022 10:12pm
Biden the strongest american president ever in history *muscle emoji*

Russia doesn't know who it's messing with

Bone spurs trump couldn't have done this good of a job

Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Feb 28 2022 10:12pm
Quote (Vastet @ Feb 28 2022 01:48pm)
Sanctions are a great way to make sure the target of sanctions doubles down on whatever they were sanctioned over. They do occasionally work, but never against an economic or military power of significance. Whenever deployed against such a nation, it hurts the sanctioner as much as the sanctionee, and everyone in a position of leadership in a nation knows it. It's a way to mollify the masses. To pretend to punish an adversary without having to risk lives so the people stop or simply never start demanding military action.


Sanctions obviously work, or Russia would not have spent a decade or more trying to build effective defenses against economic sanction.
Member
Posts: 4,078
Joined: Dec 24 2018
Gold: 177.93
Feb 28 2022 10:17pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Mar 1 2022 05:12am)
Sanctions obviously work, or Russia would not have spent a decade or more trying to build effective defenses against economic sanction.


Out of all ~110 sanctions given until now, 5 changed the behavior of the sanctionee to the wanted behavior.

So no, they don't work, at least not if you can actually believe politicians goals.

Maybe they want them all to double down, who knows.
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Feb 28 2022 10:26pm
Quote (massmarines @ Feb 28 2022 11:17pm)
Out of all ~110 sanctions given until now, 5 changed the behavior of the sanctionee to the wanted behavior.

So no, they don't work, at least not if you can actually believe politicians goals.

Maybe they want them all to double down, who knows.


Iran's a useful case study. It had an authoritarian regime, but not so authoritarian that it didn't require public approval. Russia is in a similar boat. When Iranian standards of living were impacted, animosity towards the regime, already festering, started to get out of hand. It's unfortunate that the United States gave them an out when it did, because the regime may well have fallen. Russia's situation is similar. It needs Russia's approval, and approval within Russia for the war is already falling. Will that lead to the collapse of the regime on its own? Unlikely, but it will keep Russia occupied and not in a position to invade other countries.
Member
Posts: 16,174
Joined: Dec 27 2019
Gold: 69.69
Mar 1 2022 01:26am
don't buy vodka
lose braincells shitposting on jsp instead
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1345679Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll