d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Christian Teaching Affirmed
Prev13456711Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Mar 5 2019 03:56pm
Quote (InsaneBobb @ Mar 5 2019 03:48pm)
Interesting post. Who here said there's no slavery in the Bible? Even your wiki page doesn't indicate that it's okay to enslave others. It tries to make a strange inference that "because it doesn't say you can't enslave a non hebrew, that means you can! Ha!" That's even shakier reasoning considering:

Exodus 24:16 “Anyone who kidnaps someone is to be put to death, whether the victim has been sold or is still in the kidnapper’s possession."

1 Timothy 1:9-10 "We also know that the law is made not for the righteous but for lawbreakers and rebels, the ungodly and sinful, the unholy and irreligious, for those who kill their fathers or mothers, for murderers, for the sexually immoral, for those practicing homosexuality, for slave traders and liars and perjurers—and for whatever else is contrary to the sound doctrine"

Note that "Slaver" and "Slave Trader" are synonyms for those who actively enslave people and make their livelihoods selling slaves. So, once again, nowhere in the bible does it condone enslavement. And it does actively condemn slavers. So yeah. I'm not sure what you're trying to add here.

And why would I be enamored of the bible's philosphy? My argument is that the bible is rock hard solid on it's views regarding alternative lifestyles. Therefore expecting alternative lifestyles to be allowed into church leadership is a far-flung thought. In fact, going on the timothy verses above, it seems the Bible rather directly condemns both slave traders and alternative lifestyles.

As I ALSO said before, there is nothing to prevent those who lead alternative lifestyles from breaking off and forming their own congregation, or even denomination in the church. Why not? Protestants have been breaking off over issues of dogma for quite some time now.


Slave trader there refers to people who raid for slaves to sell

Exodus only gives rights to fellow israelites with regard to slavery. Theres plenty of OT raiding and taking slaves.

The bible was considered rock solid on lots of things no longer taken seriously by modern Christians. I agree its likely to create a fracture in the future.
Member
Posts: 21,486
Joined: Jul 21 2005
Gold: 438.40
Mar 5 2019 04:42pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ Mar 5 2019 02:56pm)
Slave trader there refers to people who raid for slaves to sell

Exodus only gives rights to fellow israelites with regard to slavery. Theres plenty of OT raiding and taking slaves.

The bible was considered rock solid on lots of things no longer taken seriously by modern Christians. I agree its likely to create a fracture in the future.


I believe you just made my point for me. Your claim:

Quote (Thor123422 @ Mar 5 2019 08:07am)
Theres virtually no nuance on slavery. Its fine, has explicit instructions on who to enslave and how, and was explicitely endorsed by Jesus.


There is no right to enslave. You yourself just confirmed it. So, we're agreed. Jesus did not endorse slavery and enslaving people was not okay. Purchasing already enslaved people? Whatever, do what you want. Indentured servitude? The more the merrier. Enslavement? Nope. Can't kidnap people. In order to enslave them, gotta kidnap them. Man oh man, that was easy.

So, the claim that slavery had almost no nuance in Christianity just happens to be false. If you live in a system that has outlawed slavery, or where no slaves are available, you can not make new slaves. According to the bible, if you live in a system where slavery is legal, or slaves are available, then you may purchase, be given, or inherit slaves.

Regarding the Raiding thing, that's a purely Jewish thing and is not allowed for with the new testament. So that's not a christian thing at all. You are referring to the whole "peaceful surrender" of a town, turning it's entire population into "forced labor" aka slaves, with all the rights and obligations slaves were outlined as having, right?
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Mar 5 2019 06:46pm
Quote (InsaneBobb @ Mar 5 2019 09:15am)
I can talk about whatever the fuck I want. A church is a church is a church. Islam exists too, and is held to a lower standard, why?

Both are Abrahamic religions. Both hold to the same core teachings (the dead sea scrolls) and both are intolerant of the same things.

Islam just takes it 10 steps farther. Yet here we are pointing the finger at Christians, for being "intolerant".

No. They just don't want alternative lifestyles in the leadership roles that preach how to lead a sin-free life.

Intolerance is hanging gays from cranes.


You can talk about what you want but we are talking about Christianity and you are talking about Islam. They are not the same thing. Ask any practitioner or educated person on the matter.

This post was edited by Skinned on Mar 5 2019 06:46pm
Member
Posts: 21,486
Joined: Jul 21 2005
Gold: 438.40
Mar 5 2019 06:57pm
Quote (Skinned @ Mar 5 2019 05:46pm)
You can talk about what you want but we are talking about Christianity and you are talking about Islam. They are not the same thing. Ask any practitioner or educated person on the matter.


More accurately, people are spending all their time shitting on the church for their alleged "intolerance" because they don't want those of an alternative lifestyle in their leadership, as their holy books claim alternative lifestyles are a sin. Can't have the preacher man preaching sin.

It's not enough that the church cheerfully welcomes those of an alternative lifestyle into their congregations. Nah, now it's required that they be promoted to leadership, otherwise INTOLERANT!!!

Rather than just forming their own congregation and/or denomination so they can have gay preachers, they have to force everyone else to compromise their own values. And when everyone else refuses to compromise their principles, oh noes! Intolerant.

No, I bring up Islam because the moment you think the Church is intolerant, take your alternative lifestyle into a mosque in Iran or Qatar and demand leadership amongst that congregation. Then you'll know the definition of intolerance.

I get that the goal is to erode the base values of Christianity. I'm not sure why. I'm also not sure why other religions are not being provided the same treatment.

And while they certainly aren't the same thing, ALL Abrahamic religions are in perfect agreement that alternative lifestyles violate their principles. The difference? The Christian version isn't going to expel you from the congregation, community, or attempt to kill you because of it.

So, want an alternative lifestyle-led denomination? Go build it. Nobody is going to stop you.
Member
Posts: 28,884
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Mar 5 2019 07:40pm
Good.

Can't have mutually exclusive claims both be right at the same time.

Homosexuality & other forms of sexual immorality are pretty clearly outlined as sin in the Bible. It's impossible to be a Bible-believing Christian and try to deny something that's so clearly stated.
Member
Posts: 57,901
Joined: Dec 3 2008
Gold: 286.00
Mar 5 2019 08:25pm
Quote (InsaneBobb @ Mar 5 2019 07:57pm)
More accurately, people are spending all their time shitting on the church for their alleged "intolerance" because they don't want those of an alternative lifestyle in their leadership, as their holy books claim alternative lifestyles are a sin. Can't have the preacher man preaching sin.

It's not enough that the church cheerfully welcomes those of an alternative lifestyle into their congregations. Nah, now it's required that they be promoted to leadership, otherwise INTOLERANT!!!

Rather than just forming their own congregation and/or denomination so they can have gay preachers, they have to force everyone else to compromise their own values. And when everyone else refuses to compromise their principles, oh noes! Intolerant.

No, I bring up Islam because the moment you think the Church is intolerant, take your alternative lifestyle into a mosque in Iran or Qatar and demand leadership amongst that congregation. Then you'll know the definition of intolerance.

I get that the goal is to erode the base values of Christianity. I'm not sure why. I'm also not sure why other religions are not being provided the same treatment.

And while they certainly aren't the same thing, ALL Abrahamic religions are in perfect agreement that alternative lifestyles violate their principles. The difference? The Christian version isn't going to expel you from the congregation, community, or attempt to kill you because of it.

So, want an alternative lifestyle-led denomination? Go build it. Nobody is going to stop you.


I don't care what churches do, I'm atheist. Christians are cool though; I work for the ministry of Jesus.
Member
Posts: 54,217
Joined: Feb 15 2006
Gold: 62,205.16
Mar 5 2019 08:29pm
Divorce is clearly stated as a sin all over the Bible. Jesus himself brought that up several times (and not even once homosexuality, but never mind that). And yet there’s millions of divorced-and-remarried Christians within the churches all over the world today. But does a member blink an eye about it? No. “It’s okay, he was abusive; she was a cheat; bla bla”. Hypocrites.

This post was edited by pwb3 on Mar 5 2019 08:31pm
Member
Posts: 22,442
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 76.11
Mar 5 2019 08:31pm
Quote (pwb3 @ Mar 5 2019 06:29pm)
Divorce is clearly stated as a sin all over the Bible. Jesus himself brought that up several times (and not even once homosexuality, but never mind that). And yet there’s millions of divorced-and-remarries Christians within the churches all over the world today, and not one member blinks an eye about it. No one cares. Hypocrites.


Your sig is really gay.
Member
Posts: 54,217
Joined: Feb 15 2006
Gold: 62,205.16
Mar 5 2019 08:32pm
Quote (Handcuffs @ Mar 5 2019 10:31pm)
Your sig is really gay.


:hug:
Member
Posts: 70,459
Joined: Feb 3 2006
Gold: 28,299.69
Mar 5 2019 08:32pm
Quote (Handcuffs @ Mar 5 2019 07:31pm)
Your sig is really gay.


That sig is welcome in my church
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev13456711Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll