d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Western Subservience To Israel
Prev1345679Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2024 05:09pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jul 3 2024 03:53pm)
There's also plenty of useless domestic spending, so your "but there are starving Americans"-talking point can be used against so many things the government is spending money on.


Why do you think feeding starving Americans is just a talking point?

And yes, I agree that there is a lot of useless government programs, but I don't think feeding the starving is one of them. In fact, ask the average American if he wants billions sent to Israel, or spent on Americans.

This post was edited by JessiWan on Jul 3 2024 05:36pm
Member
Posts: 4,063
Joined: May 24 2008
Gold: 719.75
Jul 3 2024 05:20pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jul 3 2024 06:35pm)
This is perfectly reasonable if the ROI on these billions is ultimately higher. Just a hypothetical, albeit drastic scenario: there is a second Arab spring, but this time around, it spreads from Syria and Egypt to Jordan and then spills over into Iraq. By that point, the islamist revolt has so much momentum that even Saudi Arabia is overrun by it. Oil production in the Middle East completely collapses, and with it the global economy. You have rampant inflation and fuel shortages all across the world, which leads to far more Americans starving.

So yes, the US have a vital interest in keeping the ME stable, which implies that they have a vital interest in maintaining a potential base of operations in the region, particularly a base which is based in a non-Muslim-majority country. If shit truly hits the fan, you can't rely on military bases in SA, Qatar and the like.

It is of course difficult to put a price tag on such geostrategic considerations, but the idea that the US itself would be guaranteed to be better off without this investment in a crucial geostrategic ally doesn't hold up to scrutiny.





Could the same goals be achieved for less money? Probably, but by how much? Calculating the exact tipping point is imho impossible.



Is Israel really the power preventing such an uprising in the Middle East or could it be the American presence and the potential for a another war that’s keeping some groups quiet? If "shit hits the fan" at the magnitude you’re describing is Israel really in any capacity to defend itself? I’m all for having a strong presence in Israel if it acts as a deterrent, but it does have to be paid for entirely by the US when Israel and its population has a lot more to lose (i.e. their lives). If the threat you describe is real, shouldn’t Israel be more concerned by America’s strength than their own since they won’t be doing most of the fighting anyway?

Anyway, that’s all hypothetical and the day where someone gets elected and decides to cut spending is not in any foreseeable future.
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Jul 3 2024 05:39pm
Member
Posts: 9,896
Joined: Sep 29 2013
Gold: 1,804.12
Jul 3 2024 05:57pm
Quote (IceMage @ Jul 3 2024 07:39pm)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KP-CRXROorw


I really love the part where he breifly skips over the jews being kicked out of countries across the globe, no reason specified..

But it was really funny when he said, "newsflash, we're not going anywhere.."

pretty sure they've been moving from one country to another, being banished along the way.. for quite a long time now..

I enjoyed the zionist boomer take from Bill, t4t
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Jul 3 2024 06:11pm
Quote (WhiskeyRunz @ Jul 3 2024 04:57pm)
I really love the part where he breifly skips over the jews being kicked out of countries across the globe, no reason specified..

But it was really funny when he said, "newsflash, we're not going anywhere.."

pretty sure they've been moving from one country to another, being banished along the way.. for quite a long time now..

I enjoyed the zionist boomer take from Bill, t4t


Well during World War 2 a lot of Jews were moving moved around.

If it's bad when the "Jew" is a globalist cosmopolitan, you should be happy they've found a place to stay in their historic homeland.
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2024 06:15pm
Quote (WhiskeyRunz @ Jul 3 2024 04:57pm)
I really love the part where he breifly skips over the jews being kicked out of countries across the globe, no reason specified..

But it was really funny when he said, "newsflash, we're not going anywhere.."

pretty sure they've been moving from one country to another, being banished along the way.. for quite a long time now..

I enjoyed the zionist boomer take from Bill, t4t


I don't understand the psychology of Jews. Nobody wants them, they get kicked out of every country they have ever been in. I would have thought to myself, why is this happening? Why am I unwelcome in every place I have been in? Was it something I did? Was it something about me? Maybe I should change my ways because people seem to dislike me". But instead they just smugly say, "Look world, we are not going anywhere".

Can you imagine the chutzpah and total lack of introspection of these people?
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Jul 3 2024 06:25pm
Quote (JessiWan @ Jul 3 2024 05:15pm)
I don't understand the psychology of Jews. Nobody wants them, they get kicked out of every country they have ever been in. I would have thought to myself, why is this happening? Why am I unwelcome in every place I have been in? Was it something I did? Was it something about me? Maybe I should change my ways because people seem to dislike me". But instead they just smugly say, "Look world, we are not going anywhere".

Can you imagine the chutzpah and total lack of introspection of these people?


If Jews met the bigotry they face with weakness you would hold that against them. There's no logic to anti-Semitism, just hatred looking for a reason.

Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2024 06:35pm
Quote (IceMage @ Jul 3 2024 05:25pm)
If Jews met the bigotry they face with weakness you would hold that against them.


How about you don't talk in the hypothetical?

Quote


There's no logic to anti-Semitism, just hatred looking for a reason.


Yes, Jews have been kicked out of literally every country they have been in, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with them. Everybody else is the ones with a problem.

Maybe you should actually try and ask these evil "haters" why they don't like Jews. Where there is smoke, there is always a fire. Jews are hated for a reason.

Quote


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QK5stz_o2_c


You need a video to make a point for yourself. Guess writing is hard for you.

Didn't click, btw.
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Jul 3 2024 06:44pm
Quote (JessiWan @ Jul 3 2024 05:35pm)
How about you don't talk in the hypothetical?



Yes, Jews have been kicked out of literally every country they have been in, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with them. Everybody else is the ones with a problem.

Maybe you should actually try and ask these evil "haters" why they don't like Jews. Where there is smoke, there is always a fire. Jews are hated for a reason.



You need a video to make a point for yourself. Guess writing is hard for you.

Didn't click, btw.


Why not? What would be gained if I didn't?

African-Americans have been kicked out of every state in our country... but rational people recognize this is (generally) because of racism, not some inherent problem with black people.

But looking at your guild name, I suppose that's not an argument that will work with you.

Hatred doesn't justify itself. You don't get to say "this group is hated in a lot of places, therefore there's good reason for the hatred". The truth isn't determined by popular vote. People(like yourself) believe a lot of stupid shit, the fact that many people believe stupid shit is not a good argument for stupid shit.

He makes the point more convincingly than I could writing it. Writing is easy for me, at least on this forum.
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2024 07:10pm
This post is a violation of the site rules and appropriate action was taken.

Quote (IceMage @ Jul 3 2024 05:44pm)
Why not? What would be gained if I didn't?

African-Americans have been kicked out of every state in our country... but rational people recognize this is (generally) because of racism, not some inherent problem with black people.

But looking at your guild name, I suppose that's not an argument that will work with you.

Hatred doesn't justify itself. You don't get to say "this group is hated in a lot of places, therefore there's good reason for the hatred". The truth isn't determined by popular vote. People(like yourself) believe a lot of stupid shit, the fact that many people believe stupid shit is not a good argument for stupid shit.

He makes the point more convincingly than I could writing it. Writing is easy for me, at least on this forum.


I don't hate Jews because "they have been hated in a lot of places so it's OK to hate them". I hate them because I have 1. personally suffered tremendously at their hands; and 2. observed their general behavioral patterns and seen the damage they do to other human groups. I genuinely believe that Jews as a whole are a blight on humanity. This doesn't mean all Jews are bad. However, saying that "there are some good Jews" does not excuse the fact they as a group are a source of great suffering in this world.

And funny you should think I believe in "stupid shit". Ffs, you think there is nothing wrong with Jews. You are the one who believes in stupid shit. So I guess we are now even?
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1345679Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll