Quote (IceMage @ 6 Jun 2020 23:39)
What I'm interested in is why so many feel the need to focus on his past wrongs as a way to somehow justify his death or invalidate the protests.
Part of it, I'm guessing, is that every issue in America has to become another battle in the culture war. Right-wingers aren't comfortable agreeing with liberals on anything, so this is a way to create a new narrative surrounding Floyd's horrific death, where you guys can fight against liberals.
You've got it all backwards. Even the overwhelming majority of right-wingers agree that Floyd's death was horrific and unjustifiable. They agreed that there is something fundamentally broken about the mindset of too many police departments, and about the oversight which lets too many cases of police brutality go unpunished.
But then, BLM and liberals had to make this about more than that, they had to make this about "systemic racism", about the idea that America is racist to its core. And that's simply a very contentious, polarizing assertion which is far less agreeable for people on the right.
We had a case of police brutality with racist subtext. The police brutality-aspect of it was widely agreeable, the racialized aspect of it not so much. By making the latter the focus of the protests, BLM and liberals have wasted a chance to form a bipartisan coalition which could have lead to real change. (Change from which blacks would have benefitted the most btw!) It was the liberal side which dragged these protests back into the usual, partisan trenches.
Quote
My guess is there's some sort of larger racial motivation as well, considering this sort of argument has happened after so many police beatings/killings of black men.
A lot of people are beating around the bush, so I'll go ahead and say it out loud: a non-negligible share of whites in America does not want society to be openly racist, to have cops murder blacks in broad daylight or stuff like that - but who, at the same time, totally do NOT want to see the country's racial hierarchy, where whites are on top and blacks at the bottom, upended.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Jun 7 2020 08:09am