d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > October Invasion Of Israel
Prev132333435361637Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 8,130
Joined: Nov 16 2009
Gold: 58,608.00
Warn: 40%
Oct 8 2023 08:08pm
Quote (DizzyBusiness @ Oct 8 2023 07:06pm)
Doesn't make right but it does make you the owner of whatever you want, then you get to decide what is right


That’s what hitler thought too
Member
Posts: 28,856
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Oct 8 2023 08:09pm
Quote (Bazi @ Oct 8 2023 09:58pm)
The hole that is being dug is getting deep with this logic

At any rate, No point turning this into 2000 year who has claim argument. It’s just not productive and there has been modern law in play for 80 years. it’s Moreso about human rights violations, appropriate (rather not appropriate) responses, and how to move forward

Although likely there won’t be a going forward, I don’t see how hostages survive this and if they don’t then it’s done


Focusing on human rights (which often is just a selectively applied tool) misses the essence of this conflict and how existential it is. 50 years ago a bunch of Muslim countries got together and conspired to completely wipe out the Jews from that land, not to pacify them, not to prevent some sort human right but to eradicate them. We literally just saw dozens of pics and videos from southern Israel, of women and kids loaded up and kidnapped to serve as human shields. A concert with a bunch of hippies massacred. That is the reality of who Israel has to guard against.

80 years ago the Mufta of Jerusalem had a conversation with Hitler where they discussed how to get rid of the Jews once and for all from the region.

Focusing on 'human rights' is so myopic. If I was an Israeli Jew and my ancestors survived that, you think I'd give a fuck about peoples human rights that want to exterminate me like an animal? Would you?

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Oct 8 2023 08:10pm
Member
Posts: 50,701
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 4,861.00
Oct 8 2023 08:09pm
Its the same root illogic of all modern progressive liberalism: A total denial of responsibility and agency.
Here's a simple question: What can a Palestinian do, that you consider him to be responsible for?

If Palestinians can go out and slaughter hundreds of unarmed civilians, take women as sex slaves, massacre children, pillage and raid unchecked- and its all somehow Israel's fault- then what can Palestinians possibly do that they bear culpability for? If a Palestinian shows up at your door, pulls your family from your home and lops their heads off one by one, is he just acting on societal pressures and a product of circumstance? If a Palestinian rapes a young child, or throws a gay person off a roof, or blows himself up in a suicide attack. At what point can an action reach a level of barbarity that he somehow manages to bear personal culpability in your eyes? Because according to modern liberal theory, there is nothing a favored minority can possibly do, no crime, no terrorism, no act of butchery or even genocide at which point that person is treated as if they had any agency in their own actions. Whether its black mobs looting a store or carjacking people, or aliens crossing a border en masse, or muslims committing terrorist attacks, or Palestinians committing one of the worst acts of butchery in a developed country since the Holocaust- its always just someone's chickens coming home to roost, someone else's fault. Of course, not for the groups they disfavor, not for white people or jews or asians.

So again I ask, what heinous action could a Palestinian person take at which point they bear any responsibility? Do they need to kidnap a bus full of children and start a blood orgy of child rape, murder and cannibalism? Or if they were Jewish kids, would that just be decolonization? Or if they were gay kids, would that just be inconvenient and swept under the rug
Member
Posts: 4,147
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 6.42
Warn: 10%
Oct 8 2023 08:15pm
Quote (AleKsRoBerto @ Oct 8 2023 11:08pm)
That’s what hitler thought too


Yeah and then he offed himself before the people who think the same but have more guns came to do it for him, so what?
Member
Posts: 54,735
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Oct 8 2023 08:20pm
Quote (Goomshill @ Oct 8 2023 07:09pm)
Its the same root illogic of all modern progressive liberalism: A total denial of responsibility and agency.
Here's a simple question: What can a Palestinian do, that you consider him to be responsible for?

If Palestinians can go out and slaughter hundreds of unarmed civilians, take women as sex slaves, massacre children, pillage and raid unchecked- and its all somehow Israel's fault- then what can Palestinians possibly do that they bear culpability for? If a Palestinian shows up at your door, pulls your family from your home and lops their heads off one by one, is he just acting on societal pressures and a product of circumstance? If a Palestinian rapes a young child, or throws a gay person off a roof, or blows himself up in a suicide attack. At what point can an action reach a level of barbarity that he somehow manages to bear personal culpability in your eyes? Because according to modern liberal theory, there is nothing a favored minority can possibly do, no crime, no terrorism, no act of butchery or even genocide at which point that person is treated as if they had any agency in their own actions. Whether its black mobs looting a store or carjacking people, or aliens crossing a border en masse, or muslims committing terrorist attacks, or Palestinians committing one of the worst acts of butchery in a developed country since the Holocaust- its always just someone's chickens coming home to roost, someone else's fault. Of course, not for the groups they disfavor, not for white people or jews or asians.

So again I ask, what heinous action could a Palestinian person take at which point they bear any responsibility? Do they need to kidnap a bus full of children and start a blood orgy of child rape, murder and cannibalism? Or if they were Jewish kids, would that just be decolonization? Or if they were gay kids, would that just be inconvenient and swept under the rug


purely socioeconomic reasons tbh

This post was edited by majorblood on Oct 8 2023 08:20pm
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Oct 8 2023 08:21pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Oct 8 2023 07:09pm)
Focusing on human rights (which often is just a selectively applied tool) misses the essence of this conflict and how existential it is. 50 years ago a bunch of Muslim countries got together and conspired to completely wipe out the Jews from that land, not to pacify them, not to prevent some sort human right but to eradicate them. We literally just saw dozens of pics and videos from southern Israel, of women and kids loaded up and kidnapped to serve as human shields. A concert with a bunch of hippies massacred. That is the reality of who Israel has to guard against.

80 years ago the Mufta of Jerusalem had a conversation with Hitler where they discussed how to get rid of the Jews once and for all from the region.

Focusing on 'human rights' is so myopic. If I was an Israeli Jew and my ancestors survived that, you think I'd give a fuck about peoples human rights that want to exterminate me like an animal? Would you?


You brought up a good point. I feel that Jews have had to endure these things for thousands of years and this has definitely shaped their evolution. Because of the way their ancestors were treated by pretty much the entire world, and how they needed to struggle just to survive, there is tremendous selective pressure on them to evolve in such a way that kind, gentle, peaceful Jews' genes got culled. And we are left with a ferocious, lying, cruel, and some might even say evil, people known as modern-day Jews. It all makes sense.
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Oct 8 2023 08:23pm
Quote (Goomshill @ Oct 8 2023 07:09pm)
Its the same root illogic of all modern progressive liberalism: A total denial of responsibility and agency.
Here's a simple question: What can a Palestinian do, that you consider him to be responsible for?

If Palestinians can go out and slaughter hundreds of unarmed civilians, take women as sex slaves, massacre children, pillage and raid unchecked- and its all somehow Israel's fault- then what can Palestinians possibly do that they bear culpability for?


Israelis have done similarly reprehensible things, but you don't cry for them to bear culpability for it.
Member
Posts: 23,970
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,554.14
Warn: 10%
Oct 8 2023 08:25pm
Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ Oct 8 2023 09:02pm)
The answer is yes.

But if he can muster the government to assist him in maintaining his property, then you won't be able to.

That's what property is. Government deciding who owns what and using their force to keep it that way.


No person owns property.
Don't believe me?
Stop paying taxes on it and watch what happens.
They just let you use it, for now.
Member
Posts: 54,735
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Oct 8 2023 08:25pm
Quote (sirthom @ Oct 8 2023 07:25pm)
No person owns property.
Don't believe me?
Stop paying taxes on it and watch what happens.
They just let you use it, for now.


thor would agree with this why say "don't believe me?"

This post was edited by majorblood on Oct 8 2023 08:25pm
Member
Posts: 8,130
Joined: Nov 16 2009
Gold: 58,608.00
Warn: 40%
Oct 8 2023 08:26pm
Quote (JessiWan @ Oct 8 2023 07:21pm)
You brought up a good point. I feel that Jews have had to endure these things for thousands of years and this has definitely shaped their evolution. Because of the way their ancestors were treated by pretty much the entire world, and how they needed to struggle just to survive, there is tremendous selective pressure on them to evolve in such a way that kind, gentle, peaceful Jews' genes got culled. And we are left with a ferocious, lying, cruel, and some might even say evil, people known as modern-day Jews. It all makes sense.


Lol I see what you did there. Although I’m gonna just say that these kids who are trying to defend everything Israel does don’t seem to understand that saying “Israel has never done anything wrong” is akin to saying “hitler did nothing wrong.”
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev132333435361637Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll