Quote (NetflixAdaptationWidow @ Sep 16 2022 06:34pm)
How so? 25 million watches the first 24 hours seems pretty good
Too early to tell, Amazon is obviously heavily invested in its success, given the price-tag, and they've delayed some of their other product offerings (e.g. Wheel of Time) in an effort to concentrate eyeballs on Rings of Power. They're banking on casual fans taking over and becoming regular watchers, but it's hard to do that without good writing, and the writers in all of these "made of TV" fantasy epics are terrible (see : GOT season 7-8).
The challenge is that they've already squandered any goodwill from fans of the underlying work. Galadriel's a very important character. She's one of the most powerful beings in the actual story. There's no need to turn her into a warring elf princess, aside from the fact that the writers are so unoriginal that they can't imagine a powerful female character that isn't climbing mountains or swinging a sword. You can do the same sort of analysis with Elrond. There's a broader trend among recent adaptions that fundamentally misunderstand the world in Tolkien's work (i.e. Anglo-Saxon), and try to turn it into something it's not. I have no idea how the Hobbit played at the box office, but I watched the first and was so thoroughly disgusted that I swore off the rest.