d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > China Closed Chengdu Us Consulate
Prev1234
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 78,723
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 493.00
Jul 31 2020 01:20pm
bolded my responses with some questions for you below
i support law and order so you'll have a hard time getting me to sympathize with the folks complaining about heavy handed actions by the government in response to civil unreset although i agree that there are problems with the police that need to be resolved

Quote (fender @ Jul 31 2020 02:09pm)
well, i'm sure that some of the news have made to under your rock:

- unwanted minorities locked away in camps
illegal immigrants held in detention facilities, something that existed under obama, what would you propose be done with them and are you against having any kind of border control at all?

- protesters labeled 'terrorists', 'adversaries'
what would you label would you prefer for people who burn down government buildings and residential buildings

- massive and brutal police crackdown without accountability, abductions of citizens in unmarked vehicles to undisclosed locations
agreed this is not good

- critical media under constant attack, coordinated (and successful) efforts to delegitimise the press
when i google trump under the news category i get a bunch of articles about how poorly he's doing, how has the news media been successfully delegitimized?

- mass surveillance and incarceration of citizens
america has had prison population problems long before trump came into office

- denial of embarrassing historical events
agreed

- coordinated efforts to hide facts and case numbers about covid-19 from the population, the CDC, and the world
agreed this is not good

- trying to delay elections due to bad polling
is he really though? the gop rebuked him from what i'm reading

- violations of the constitution under the guise of law and order
you'll have to be more specific, is this related to the kidnappings?

- constant, dangerous, and deliberate misinformation by the administration for political purposes
agreed this is not good but almost every government does this

- president above the law, not held accountable in the slightest for clear and obvious crimes and ethical violations of the office
i have a similar problem right now in canada with a guy i voted for

it's pretty bad actually, especially considering the people supporting it are pretty much those that always pretended to value freedom, individual and states rights, and said they were in favour of small government. you don't want to join the appeasers who pretend those are things that can be forgiven, or that are irrelevant just because another country is even worse - history doesn't judge them favourably...


Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jul 31 2020 01:51pm
Quote (duffman316 @ 31 Jul 2020 21:20)
bolded my responses with some questions for you below
i support law and order so you'll have a hard time getting me to sympathize with the folks complaining about heavy handed actions by the government in response to civil unreset although i agree that there are problems with the police that need to be resolved


in my own thread i already addressed many of your questions ( https://forums.d2jsp.org/topic.php?t=83706670&f=119 ), and while you're right that some of the problems predate trump, he escalated every one of those i listed critically.

your point about the protesters would only be valid if those attacked / abducted / brutalised were only those that engaged in actual rioting or destruction of buildings, but that is NOT the case as you would know if you looked beyond the sensationalist headlines that you allegedly despise so much. here is a great source documenting those transgressions with sources: https://maminian.github.io/brutality-map/

regarding trump's delegitimisation of media, just read this forum for a while and you will see that over half of its regulars, those on the right, have uncritically accepted the 'fake news' narrative, outright dismissing everything they don't like to hear when it comes from an outlet that has ever been critical of trump. confidence in the press has plummeted under this administration ( https://news.gallup.com/poll/267047/americans-trust-mass-media-edges-down.aspx ). that's what i mean with 'successful', he got his cultists to deny facts and reality by discrediting those that report it.

also, false equivalences concerning other nations (not a single of which is perfect admittedly) are hardly a good argument for someone who INTENTIONALLY made covid-19 a partisan issue. it might have been a gross miscalculation, but that doesn't change the fact that it was a very deliberate move by trump's administration - and it cost tens of thousands of americans their lives.
we see incompetence, denial, and large scale failures in other countries (predominantly those with similarly authoritarian leaders, like china, russia, iran, brazil, turkey...) that completely bungled their response for various shitty reasons (mostly related to projecting 'strength'), but amongst western democracies the US is certainly unique in politicising this pandemic.

again, appease all you want, but trump's fascist tendencies are obvious and undeniable to anyone looking at it even remotely open-mindedly.
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Jul 31 2020 03:56pm
Quote (duffman316 @ Jul 31 2020 02:20pm)
bolded my responses with some questions for you below
i support law and order so you'll have a hard time getting me to sympathize with the folks complaining about heavy handed actions by the government in response to civil unreset although i agree that there are problems with the police that need to be resolved


They also label journalists as adversaries, and we have cases where federal agents are going out of their way to target journalists who are clearly separated from the crowd and marked as journalists.

That's why you don't call them "adversaries". It encourages violence against everybody, even the ones who are doing an unambiguously good thing that is constitutionally protected.
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Jul 31 2020 04:06pm
Quote (fender @ Jul 31 2020 03:51pm)

your point about the protesters would only be valid if those attacked / abducted / brutalised were only those that engaged in actual rioting or destruction of buildings, but that is NOT the case as you would know if you looked beyond the sensationalist headlines that you allegedly despise so much. here is a great source documenting those transgressions with sources: https://maminian.github.io/brutality-map/


It is impossible to police a riot by selectively targeting the rioters. All the more so when the rioters are interspersed throughout a "peaceful" crowd and the police are assaulted when they leave the safety of their ranks to make an arrest.

This is fundamentally why police declare the assembly a riot, ask peaceful protesters to exit, and then attempt to drive the protesters away via traditional crowd control tactics. None of this is net new behavior. Police have used tear gas and other number of other tactics in countless riots, not just in the United States, but in Germany, Canada, and around the civilized world. You have fundamentally failed to make this an argument about "fascism", and have instead embarked on a meandering criticism of riot policing that applies to virtually every Western democracy.

Quote (fender @ Jul 31 2020 03:51pm)
regarding trump's delegitimisation of media, just read this forum for a while and you will see that over half of its regulars, those on the right, have uncritically accepted the 'fake news' narrative, outright dismissing everything they don't like to hear when it comes from an outlet that has ever been critical of trump. confidence in the press has plummeted under this administration ( https://news.gallup.com/poll/267047/americans-trust-mass-media-edges-down.aspx ). that's what i mean with 'successful', he got his cultists to deny facts and reality by discrediting those that report it.


As you do routinely for media you don't like, even to the point where you accuse others of regurgitating news media that they've never read. Confidence in the press has plummeted because the press is perceived as fundamentally more partisan. There are good reasons for that perception, as any number of "Snope fact-check", hypocritical CNN fact-checks, or NYTimes back-tracks will attest.

I would go so far as to say that the average "right" poster on this forum has a far more nuanced view on media than you do. Their default position is that all media is untrustworthy, whereas you only seem to feel that skepticism when it applies to sources you personally don't like.

Quote (fender @ Jul 31 2020 03:51pm)
also, false equivalences concerning other nations (not a single of which is perfect admittedly) are hardly a good argument for someone who INTENTIONALLY made covid-19 a partisan issue. it might have been a gross miscalculation, but that doesn't change the fact that it was a very deliberate move by trump's administration - and it cost tens of thousands of americans their lives.
we see incompetence, denial, and large scale failures in other countries (predominantly those with similarly authoritarian leaders, like china, russia, iran, brazil, turkey...) that completely bungled their response for various shitty reasons (mostly related to projecting 'strength'), but amongst western democracies the US is certainly unique in politicising this pandemic.

again, appease all you want, but trump's fascist tendencies are obvious and undeniable to anyone looking at it even remotely open-mindedly.


This has literally nothing to do with fascism.

You've also dropped your immigration defense? Did you have a change of heart in the handful of hours between posting it and now?
Member
Posts: 3,041
Joined: Jul 25 2010
Gold: 0.00
Jul 31 2020 05:46pm
Quote (duffman316 @ Jul 31 2020 10:16am)
You can call trump all kinds of names in the USA. Try that with xi in china.


Is fender taken seriously around here?

Every post ive seen is so troll i cant tell if hes just firing people up to tickle his jorts or what
Member
Posts: 33,928
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Jul 31 2020 06:14pm
Quote (duffman316 @ Jul 31 2020 11:16am)
You can call trump all kinds of names in the USA. Try that with xi in china.


Posting Winnie the Pooh gets you sent to the gulag there.

This post was edited by EndlessSky on Jul 31 2020 06:14pm
Member
Posts: 68,436
Joined: Mar 27 2008
Gold: 35,890.00
Jul 31 2020 06:17pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Jul 31 2020 08:29pm)
You should spend more time reflecting on why you're living in a modern day fascist dystopia hell-bent on reenacting the Holocaust Xinjiang style.

I don't think anyone has sympathy for such an insignificant added inconvenience, Trump literally did nothing wrong.


jeez you're pretty stupid arent ya?

Quote (ofthevoid @ Jul 31 2020 09:55pm)
You're going to spend money to go vote via absentee even though you're probably from a state that is like 99% going to vote one way i.e. California and in reality your vote doesn't actually decide anything?

:rofl:


im not from "probably california"

This post was edited by KungPeriodFu on Jul 31 2020 06:17pm
Member
Posts: 68,436
Joined: Mar 27 2008
Gold: 35,890.00
Jul 31 2020 06:21pm
Quote (duffman316 @ Aug 1 2020 01:44am)
Haven't been to the states lately but im not entirely sure i agree with the fascist narrative. I just see sensationalistic headlines that exaggerate what is going on. How fascist is it really?


donald trump is a fascist. the things he wants to do are fascist. he wants to be a dictator
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Jul 31 2020 06:44pm
Quote (KungPeriodFu @ Jul 31 2020 08:17pm)
jeez you're pretty stupid arent ya?


Am I the one living on the Tibetan border?
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1234
Add Reply New Topic New Poll