d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Kusher/trump Peace Plan Outline
Prev1234568Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 12,201
Joined: Feb 13 2010
Gold: 14.88
Jan 29 2020 08:20pm
Quote (lll420lll @ Jan 29 2020 05:09pm)
Whole middle east should just be leveled. Religious fucks been fighting for too long


My grandfather wasn't butchered by murderous Nazis at the age of 9 just to have proto-Hitlers like you telling me I need to forget the six gorrilian.
Member
Posts: 50,915
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,335.99
Jan 29 2020 08:28pm
Quote (PlasmaSnake101 @ Jan 29 2020 08:20pm)
My grandfather wasn't butchered by murderous Nazis at the age of 9 just to have proto-Hitlers like you telling me I need to forget the six gorrilian.


3 of my grandparents survived the nazis shooting at them, its all about the zigzag I guess (literally in the case of my french grandmother getting strafed)
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jan 29 2020 09:52pm
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ 30 Jan 2020 03:13)
Brexit was provoked by horrible populists who lied to their people.
The peace plan is a scam, annexion, war plan.


i think that more than anything it's a hastily cobbled together distraction from both US and israeli domestic political affairs (trump's impeachment / netanyahu's corruption scandal).

this administration has sufficiently demonstrated through ACTIONS where they stand on this issue, so no one with the slightest clue regarding the intricacies of this conflict would ever take this 'plan' seriously, or describe it as remotely fair or promising. it's a PR stunt, a cheap and cynical distraction, that's it.

Quote (bogie160 @ 30 Jan 2020 03:04)
The EU can't offer good terms because they need to deter other countries from leaving. Is this Britain's fault?

Israel is in a dominant position, the Palestinians have lost several wars and are in a poor position. They need to negotiate fairly with respect to their relative strengths and come to an agreement.

It's irrelevant as to why the Palestinians can't dictate their future. If they continue to force their people to wage war against Israel, they will suffer. It's a matter of life and death. You can appease whatever twisted sense of morality you want, their people suffer the longer this conflict goes on.

The British have chosen self determination over the rule of a German dominated EU. I would encourage you to respect that and remain consistent with your ideology. I respect the EU's response, but that's consistent with how I view international affairs.


what are you even on about, you weirdo? apparently you don't know ANY of my positions regarding brexit (which would of course be totally fine, if you didn't just assume them - wrongly - repeatedly).

i not only respect, i WELCOME the british decision to leave the EU, and i have said for years that it's time to end this unfortunate alliance, rather sooner than later. and while i elaborated that in an ideal world i'd prefer a britain actively engaged in leading and shaping the EU to everyone's benefit, i also unmistakenly acknowledged that was clearly not a role they sought to assume. they have been cherry picking their advantages, while trying to avoid financial and political responsibility as best they could for decades.
maybe you are confused, because you think my arguing that voters were systematically lied to by right wing demagogues concerning the advantages of leaving the EU, implied that i opposed the UK leaving, but those are issues you have to separate. yes, the referendum was a joke, and the promises made were ridiculous and false, but i still welcome the result of it.

probably too much nuance for you though... which would also explain your utterly moronic takes on the palestinian question and the legality and relevance of a decades long occupation.
Member
Posts: 50,915
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,335.99
Jan 29 2020 09:58pm
Quote (fender @ Jan 29 2020 09:52pm)
i think that more than anything it's a hastily cobbled together distraction from both US and israeli domestic political affairs (trump's impeachment / netanyahu's corruption scandal).


Its 80 pages long, with detailed proposals for virtually every facet of the conflict, maps, appendixes, etc etc
We have already known it was in the works and being drafted for 2+ years. In fact we received the economic half of the proposal a year ago.
Nobody was predicting 2 years ago that Netanyahu would want a distraction from domestic corruption scandals on this exact day after winning his election but being unable to form a coalition government.
And if you want to gauge what is politically motivated, its not a good look that Israeli prosecutors filed charges against Netanyahu just hours before his summit with Trump that had been planned well in advance.
There's no imaginable way they just happened to bring charges immediately in advance of Netanyahu's big moment if it wasn't politically motivated.
Member
Posts: 38,671
Joined: Apr 1 2007
Gold: 8.21
Jan 29 2020 10:13pm
wow who could have guessed that when a 2 state solution was finally ready the palestinians would continue to whine and go ape shit
Member
Posts: 12,379
Joined: Jul 14 2008
Gold: 2,620.00
Jan 29 2020 10:19pm
I don't think the US should necessarily be commenting on how Israel and Palestine should divvy up their lands and ports. The US has intervened far too much into this particular foreign affair.
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jan 29 2020 10:55pm
Quote (Goomshill @ 30 Jan 2020 04:58)
Its 80 pages long, with detailed proposals for virtually every facet of the conflict, maps, appendixes, etc etc
We have already known it was in the works and being drafted for 2+ years. In fact we received the economic half of the proposal a year ago.
Nobody was predicting 2 years ago that Netanyahu would want a distraction from domestic corruption scandals on this exact day after winning his election but being unable to form a coalition government.
And if you want to gauge what is politically motivated, its not a good look that Israeli prosecutors filed charges against Netanyahu just hours before his summit with Trump that had been planned well in advance.
There's no imaginable way they just happened to bring charges immediately in advance of Netanyahu's big moment if it wasn't politically motivated.


you of all ppl should know that length of text says nothing about the sanity of its content, its political feasibility, or the actual time put into compiling 80 pages (what an anti-intellectual world we live in when that is considered extensive, and that alone is then regarded as evidence of substance) - without a shred of involvement or even consultation of one of the two concerned parties (such 'effort').

so please let's not act like anyone who isn't desperately looking for an excuse to dismiss the 'distraction' argument, actually believes your underlying assumption, that they released this stunt right as they finished drafting it. also, nice try, but netanyahu's corruption scandal was exposed long before this PR stunt saw the light of day, so your little "nO yUo!" attempt there does not at all refute its distraction function for netanyahu. this IS without a doubt incredibly 'convenient' timing for both of them, and you'd have to be incredibly naive to assume that it's purely coincidental.

Quote (proccy @ 30 Jan 2020 05:13)
wow who could have guessed that when a 2 state solution was finally ready the palestinians would continue to whine and go ape shit


"wow, the saints said they didn't want to get fucked by the refs anymore, so when we excluded their franchise from the league, why are they still whining?"

seriously, do you simply not think before you post, or are you genuinely that clueless when it comes to the israel / palestine conflict? also, who is 'going ape shit'? elaborate please.
Member
Posts: 38,671
Joined: Apr 1 2007
Gold: 8.21
Jan 29 2020 11:00pm
Quote (fender @ Jan 29 2020 08:55pm)
you of all ppl should know that length of text says nothing about the sanity of its content, its political feasibility, or the actual time put into compiling 80 pages (what an anti-intellectual world we live in when that is considered extensive, and that alone is then regarded as evidence of substance) - without a shred of involvement or even consultation of one of the two concerned parties (such 'effort').

so please let's not act like anyone who isn't desperately looking for an excuse to dismiss the 'distraction' argument, actually believes your underlying assumption, that they released this stunt right as they finished drafting it. also, nice try, but netanyahu's corruption scandal was exposed long before this PR stunt saw the light of day, so your little "nO yUo!" attempt there does not at all refute its distraction function for netanyahu. this IS without a doubt incredibly 'convenient' timing for both of them, and you'd have to be incredibly naive to assume that it's purely coincidental.


"wow, the saints said they didn't want to get fucked by the refs anymore, so when we excluded their franchise from the league, why are they still whining?"
seriously, do you simply not think before you post, or are you genuinely that clueless when it comes to the israel / palestine conflict? also, who is 'going ape shit'? elaborate please.


Calm down cock boy I'm not talking to you
Member
Posts: 50,915
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,335.99
Jan 29 2020 11:07pm
Quote (fender @ Jan 29 2020 10:55pm)
so please let's not act like anyone who isn't desperately looking for an excuse to dismiss the 'distraction' argument, actually believes your underlying assumption, that they released this stunt right as they finished drafting it. also, nice try, but netanyahu's corruption scandal was exposed long before this PR stunt saw the light of day, so your little "nO yUo!" attempt there does not at all refute its distraction function for netanyahu. this IS without a doubt incredibly 'convenient' timing for both of them, and you'd have to be incredibly naive to assume that it's purely coincidental.


Quote (fender @ Jan 29 2020 09:52pm)
i think that more than anything it's a hastily cobbled together distraction from both US and israeli domestic political affairs (trump's impeachment / netanyahu's corruption scandal).


So it was both hastily cobbled together in response to a recent scandal... and finished as a draft long ago and sat on it until the right moment.
:bouncy:
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jan 29 2020 11:11pm
Quote (proccy @ 30 Jan 2020 06:00)
Calm down cock boy I'm not talking to you


no need to be upset, cock girl - this is a public forum and you didn't address anyone specifically, so if you want to prevent being called out for your idiotic posts, you should try thinking before pressing 'add reply' - or just send a PM to whoever you're "talking to". you're welcome.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1234568Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll