d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > The Free Market Case Against Charity
Prev12345614Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Sep 7 2017 12:51am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 7 2017 12:45am)
your trolling is weak.


If the overall risk isn't less than other areas they shouldn't be in need of any special aid. They can save money like the rest of us or buy insurance.
Member
Posts: 54,124
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Sep 7 2017 12:58am
Quote (fender @ 7 Sep 2017 08:50)
remember your reaction for the next time our "libertarians" use these arguments...


I dont deny that there are some libertarians here on PaRD who go too far with their arguments, but what thor is presenting here are not true libertarians arguments, they are a malicious caricature of libertarian thinking.
Member
Posts: 92,367
Joined: Dec 8 2005
Gold: 1,351.22
Sep 7 2017 01:06am
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ 7 Sep 2017 03:11)
20 candidates, each one with just a knife & a N.A.P notice in the pocket, destination: some desert island with enough food & water for 2 people.
Name of the game: "Free Market"


http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0266308/
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Sep 7 2017 01:48am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 7 2017 12:58am)
I dont deny that there are some libertarians here on PaRD who go too far with their arguments, but what thor is presenting here are not true libertarians arguments, they are a malicious caricature of libertarian thinking.


Nah, just the logical consequence they're unwilling to acknowledge
Member
Posts: 5,984
Joined: Jan 8 2010
Gold: 745.69
Sep 7 2017 07:53am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 7 2017 02:58am)
I dont deny that there are some libertarians here on PaRD who go too far with their arguments, but what thor is presenting here are not true libertarians arguments, they are a malicious caricature of libertarian thinking.


Do you need a special decoder ring to tell these two things apart? You realize Thor isn't trying to mock all libertarian arguments, he's mocking these specific people.

This post was edited by Magicman657 on Sep 7 2017 07:54am
Member
Posts: 78,723
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 493.00
Sep 7 2017 08:16am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 7 2017 01:58am)
I dont deny that there are some libertarians here on PaRD who go too far with their arguments, but what thor is presenting here are not true libertarians arguments, they are a malicious caricature of libertarian thinking.


i've been to r lib, it represents that demographic quite well
to their credit they haven't banned me yet despite my statist leanings

This post was edited by duffman316 on Sep 7 2017 08:17am
Member
Posts: 5,984
Joined: Jan 8 2010
Gold: 745.69
Sep 7 2017 08:44am
Quote (duffman316 @ Sep 7 2017 10:16am)
i've been to r lib, it represents that demographic quite well
to their credit they haven't banned me yet despite my statist leanings


There DO exist some number of reasonable libertarians. Sometimes they have legitimate points, even if I don't 100% agree with them. Based on the ones I've met thus far, I'd say they aren't the majority, but they do exist and are often more reasonable than the more authoritarian people. The posters from the thread this one is mocking are not among those, however. Not even close.
Member
Posts: 78,723
Joined: Nov 30 2008
Gold: 493.00
Sep 7 2017 09:00am
Quote (Magicman657 @ Sep 7 2017 09:44am)
There DO exist some number of reasonable libertarians. Sometimes they have legitimate points, even if I don't 100% agree with them. Based on the ones I've met thus far, I'd say they aren't the majority, but they do exist and are often more reasonable than the more authoritarian people. The posters from the thread this one is mocking are not among those, however. Not even close.


they aren't a united lot, there is a lot of disagreement amongst them over what constitutes real libertarianism

it was somewhat refreshing to find out not everyone in there is as blindly devoted to the free market as cam is
Member
Posts: 17,271
Joined: Apr 26 2006
Gold: 0.00
Sep 8 2017 08:24am
Quote (Thor123422 @ Sep 6 2017 07:54pm)
The price gauging thread really got me thinking.

All these people donating money to Houston victims are ultimately hurting them by giving them a handout. They are subsidizing their poor decision making (to live in Houston, a known flood-prone area).

I argue that we should not give to Charity for any tragic event, and instead let the free-market and cost of rebuilding ultimately dictate where people move.

We have a moral obligation to NOT give to charity and instead let the free market sort it out.

So I make a call to all of you. Please DO NOT give money to Hurrican Irma victims or Houston victims. You are just going to make lives worse in the long run.

This also goes with private companies like Anheuser-Bush. We need to boycott them over their charity.

Who's with me? I expect full support from our local libertarians.


Charity is part of the free market :D In the absence of welfare and all sorts of government programs, individuals acting in their own self interest will provide goods and services to help their fellow man.

Also, many of the social programs and expenses caused by illegal immigrants have actually soaked up a lot of the funds needed to invest in appropriate infrastructure in Houston to accommodate the sprawl. We really need to shake these do-gooder politicians making unrealistic, or short sighted promises because there is only so much funding to go around, and infrastructure should always take precedent over the worst of our society.

Remember those airplane safety booklets? You put the oxygen mask on yourself first BEFORE you put the mask on your child.

Quote (Thor123422 @ Sep 7 2017 06:51am)
If the overall risk isn't less than other areas they shouldn't be in need of any special aid. They can save money like the rest of us or buy insurance.


If someone did not pay for flood insurance and their house was destroyed they aren't getting a new one Thor...

This post was edited by tric-isHUGE on Sep 8 2017 08:39am
Member
Posts: 5,984
Joined: Jan 8 2010
Gold: 745.69
Sep 8 2017 12:04pm
Quote (tric-isHUGE @ Sep 8 2017 10:24am)
Charity is part of the free market :D In the absence of welfare and all sorts of government programs, individuals acting in their own self interest will provide goods and services to help their fellow man.

Also, many of the social programs and expenses caused by illegal immigrants have actually soaked up a lot of the funds needed to invest in appropriate infrastructure in Houston to accommodate the sprawl. We really need to shake these do-gooder politicians making unrealistic, or short sighted promises because there is only so much funding to go around, and infrastructure should always take precedent over the worst of our society.

Remember those airplane safety booklets? You put the oxygen mask on yourself first BEFORE you put the mask on your child.



If someone did not pay for flood insurance and their house was destroyed they aren't getting a new one Thor...


It's funny how people like Ted Cruz are willing to ration / deny funds to hurricane victims when it's other states affected by them because funding is tight, but when it's his own state, guess who's all about getting those federal dollars? :rolleyes:
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev12345614Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll