Quote (AEtheric @ 9 Jun 2013 02:19)
I agree, but this doesn't mean that everyone doesn't cling to more absolute beliefs in the face of adversity. I believe that is a horse that has been dead and beaten for quite a long time. If we used another study for a control with the same methods, most likely, we would receive the same results, except one of them would use religious faith instead of faith in science. If you want, I could probably pull up some studies with religion to see if they behave in a similar manner. It doesn't matter how religious the people were in the control group, as they didnt' have one, and if it is shown through other, non-identical studies, that they turn to their faith in the face of adversity, would you still have something against this study?
my comments were directed against the way this study was conducted
whatever other studies you would be able to link would have to stay on their own merits
so to answer the bolded:
yes because other studies cannot justify the poor quality of this study