d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > On Religion.
Prev12345618Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 64,772
Joined: Oct 3 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 20%
Nov 17 2009 11:23am
Quote (Ghidorah @ Nov 18 2009 03:20am)
you never made a really good point though. you just told us that we aren't open minded because your random rant didn't change our way of thinking completely?


But why did it not change your way of thinking? Not that was my goal anyway, I just figured it would be a nice introduction for a little religious discussion. You can tell me that what I'm saying is having no effect, but you are not telling me why, proving my arguments false. It is as if you do not care whether they are false or true at all, I find that closed minded.
Member
Posts: 9,430
Joined: Nov 21 2007
Gold: 4.84
Nov 17 2009 11:25am
Quote (pissed247 @ Nov 17 2009 10:38am)
Please don't put words into my mouth, I never suggested or even implicated that you are closed minded. I am open-minded, but I also understand the dangers of blind faith.


Please show me how believing in a higher power is "dangerous".
Member
Posts: 7,472
Joined: Nov 17 2007
Gold: 51.00
Warn: 10%
Nov 17 2009 11:27am
Quote (pissed247 @ Nov 17 2009 05:23pm)
But why did it not change your way of thinking? Not that was my goal anyway, I just figured it would be a nice introduction for a little religious discussion. You can tell me that what I'm saying is having no effect, but you are not telling me why, proving my arguments false. It is as if you do not care whether they are false or true at all, I find that closed minded.


you presented an opinion in your op that was intended to convert me to your way of thinking by saying my way of thinking was silly and superstitious.. this can't be proven wrong, it can be proven ineffective at the best. your opinion was ineffective in converting me.
Member
Posts: 64,772
Joined: Oct 3 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 20%
Nov 17 2009 11:27am
Quote (bpfergu @ Nov 18 2009 03:25am)
Please show me how believing in a higher power is "dangerous".


I never said that believing in a higher power is dangerous. I said blind faith is dangerous, and history proves that correct. You follow a book full of hate-mongering scripture, and there is no decent evidence to even suggest your god exists. Blind faith causes wars and impedes progress.
Member
Posts: 64,772
Joined: Oct 3 2008
Gold: Locked
Trader: Scammer
Warn: 20%
Nov 17 2009 11:30am
Quote (Ghidorah @ Nov 18 2009 03:27am)
you presented an opinion in your op that was intended to convert me to your way of thinking by saying my way of thinking was silly and superstitious.. this can't be proven wrong, it can be proven ineffective at the best. your opinion was ineffective in converting me.


Explain to me how your way of thinking is not superstitious.

Superstition: A belief, practice, or rite irrationally maintained by ignorance of the laws of nature or by faith in magic or chance.
You don't know 100% that god exists, yet you still believe in him. That defines superstition.

This post was edited by pissed247 on Nov 17 2009 11:31am
Member
Posts: 21,750
Joined: Dec 1 2007
Gold: 12,525.00
Nov 17 2009 11:31am
I didnt want my edit to get lost.

Quote (pissed247 @ Nov 17 2009 12:00pm)
Explain to me how God is like infinity. God tells you that you are special, he offers humans a chance at eternal life, he brings us his only son. Does he do this for every intelligent creature in the universe? If that is the case, the fact the he does not make any mention of this reeks of dishonesty, and implicates that the universe he created is an experiment, and his worksmanship reeks of incompetency.


We're going to get deep here. Are you ready?

There are many different perspectives within Christianity that disagree. You've pinpointed a few that many people, including myself, struggle with...one being predestination, the others being God's qualities (omnipotences, omniscience, etc.).

Does he bring salvation to every intelligent creature in the universe? If the intelligent beings need salvation then the answer is yes. If they aren't a fallen race, like humans, then there isn't a need for salvation. As the reasoning for our existience, I don't think God expects us to understand much further than we are here, like everything He created, to worship him.
Member
Posts: 9,430
Joined: Nov 21 2007
Gold: 4.84
Nov 17 2009 11:31am
Quote (pissed247 @ Nov 17 2009 11:27am)
I never said that believing in a higher power is dangerous. I said blind faith is dangerous, and history proves that correct. You follow a book full of hate-mongering scripture, and there is no decent evidence to even suggest your god exists. Blind faith causes wars and impedes progress.


I absolutely disagree.

Just because I believe in a God that may or may not exist does not endanger me in any way, shape, or form. Just because you don't doesn't make you any less "dangerous" than me.

Please, don't use wars fought over religion as means for stereotyping a whole group of people. I have accomplished more in my life since becoming a Christian than I ever did before due to my ability to overcome depression and having a reason for getting up every morning.

This post was edited by bpfergu on Nov 17 2009 11:32am
Member
Posts: 7,472
Joined: Nov 17 2007
Gold: 51.00
Warn: 10%
Nov 17 2009 11:32am
Quote (pissed247 @ Nov 17 2009 05:27pm)
I never said that believing in a higher power is dangerous. I said blind faith is dangerous, and history proves that correct. You follow a book full of hate-mongering scripture, and there is no decent evidence to even suggest your god exists. Blind faith causes wars and impedes progress.


umm.. science created guns, tanks, and the atomic bomb.. biological weapons.. chemical weapons.... i don't follow a book full of hate mongering scripture also, i'm not a muslim. and, there is no decent evidence to suggest god doesn't exist, so you lose that one too.
Member
Posts: 7,472
Joined: Nov 17 2007
Gold: 51.00
Warn: 10%
Nov 17 2009 11:33am
Quote (pissed247 @ Nov 17 2009 05:30pm)
Explain to me how your way of thinking is not superstitious.

Superstition: A belief, practice, or rite irrationally maintained by ignorance of the laws of nature or by faith in magic or chance.
You don't know 100% that god exists, yet you still believe in him. That defines superstition.


you don't know 100% that anything exists. you place faith in your 5 senses that they are accurately interpereting your surroundings.
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Nov 17 2009 11:36am
Quote (pissed247 @ Nov 17 2009 12:14pm)
I thought you wanted a debate, I don't see you posting any arguments.
Yet still, you are arguing.
;)

EDIT: BRB, making coffee.


Nah, I don't feel like debating. But I've got to kill time before my next class.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev12345618Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll