d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Should The Left Split Away From Gender Politics?
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 2,614
Joined: Sep 17 2021
Gold: 0.00
Oct 14 2024 01:49pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Oct 14 2024 03:43pm)
i dont largely disagree, but im not sure i understand what you mean. are you saying f2m trans people under-report on surveys and dont even mention that they're trans?

on a related not i cant tell most f2m trans people in 2024 look any different than most lesbians in say 2010. whereas if we contrast that with gay men, its night and day.


The idea is societal acceptance regardless of anectdote. Homophobia was the last scare tactic, alot of trans women look like crossdressing men, I'll concede this point, and society still has hatred for gay men, now amplified towards trans people because of the rampant media attention to drag queens who have nothing to do with trans people but, society sees no difference through a lens of hate
Member
Posts: 92,928
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Oct 14 2024 02:03pm
Quote (blahaj @ Oct 14 2024 02:49pm)
The idea is societal acceptance regardless of anectdote. Homophobia was the last scare tactic, alot of trans women look like crossdressing men, I'll concede this point, and society still has hatred for gay men, now amplified towards trans people because of the rampant media attention to drag queens who have nothing to do with trans people but, society sees no difference through a lens of hate


female privilege i guess, lesbians are accepted and gay men aren't. f2m is accepted, m2f isnt.

id certainly not say drag queens have NOTHING to do with trans people, but lumping them together is pretty silly as many people do.

i do tend to agree with blacks post in the other thread a bit, m2f trans people seem to require more be done to integrate them seamlessly into society, and men are the more dangerous of the genders. its still a lot of latent homophobia because gay people for a long time have been labelled as child predators, when in reality the rates of pedophilia among gay, trans, etc people doesnt seem any higher than the cis population.

but that's really the crux, the waters are so muddy with nonissues that we often lose focus on real issues. if we just took m2f people out of female sports we'd likely see a lot of movement, thats a concession a lot of people are oddly invested in.
Member
Posts: 3,908
Joined: Jun 20 2022
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Oct 14 2024 02:24pm
Quote (blahaj @ Oct 14 2024 02:24pm)
Again, it's not trans people pulling some god string, it's out of touch corporations intentionally sowing seeds of hate and doubt into the community because that's what gets interest to their brand product business etc and the public largely just buys into it

Like go look into anti trans legislation being passed, who funds it, vs pro trans legislation, it's super obvious but you all let the wool pull over your eyes because got forbid a man transition to be a woman, not in the homophobic bigots mind, no way


Please cite “anti trans” legislation.
Member
Posts: 2,614
Joined: Sep 17 2021
Gold: 0.00
Oct 14 2024 02:34pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Oct 14 2024 04:03pm)
female privilege i guess, lesbians are accepted and gay men aren't. f2m is accepted, m2f isnt.

id certainly not say drag queens have NOTHING to do with trans people, but lumping them together is pretty silly as many people do.

i do tend to agree with blacks post in the other thread a bit, m2f trans people seem to require more be done to integrate them seamlessly into society, and men are the more dangerous of the genders. its still a lot of latent homophobia because gay people for a long time have been labelled as child predators, when in reality the rates of pedophilia among gay, trans, etc people doesnt seem any higher than the cis population.

but that's really the crux, the waters are so muddy with nonissues that we often lose focus on real issues. if we just took m2f people out of female sports we'd likely see a lot of movement, thats a concession a lot of people are oddly invested in.


Well I'd say you understand far more than most, appreciate your post
Member
Posts: 9,114
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Oct 14 2024 03:23pm
Quote (blahaj @ Oct 14 2024 02:22pm)
The thing is, trans ideology isn't new, just hate tactics for it are. Trans people existed before the past decade bro, I'm one of them. The hate clicks media make up random shit and eventually people begin to roll with it, but a lot of it is just straight up fake news that people like you and op buy into immediately without ever doing any verification of information lol


Like the southern poverty hate map of the recent decade? Suddenly everyone is blanketed as a hate group against fringe minorities they historically have been disproportionately indifferent about. These people aren't self identifying as hateful groups, it's a group of people pushing the ideology further doing that.

This post was edited by RedFromWinter on Oct 14 2024 03:24pm
Member
Posts: 28,980
Joined: Jun 20 2007
Gold: 34.51
Oct 14 2024 03:30pm
I think most forms of media also need to move away, this includes entertainment. There's really no reason for them to constantly be trying to ram square pegs in round holes just for virtue signalling purposes.

I also think were starting to see a lot of that backfire though so we will see how long that trend continues. There's fantastic diverse work out there, but were seeing so many giants try to fit people in roles they don't belong hurting both storytelling and the actors career as well. Its a double loss. A lot of that though can just be attributed to corporate b/s. Trying too hop on and profit off whatever bandwagon they can.

I think its all detracting from what the goal is. But that's just my opinion and we certainly have made leaps and bounds in the last 100 years with progression so who am I to say.

This post was edited by SBD on Oct 14 2024 03:41pm
Member
Posts: 54,072
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Oct 14 2024 09:52pm
Quote (SBD @ 14 Oct 2024 23:30)
I think most forms of media also need to move away, this includes entertainment. There's really no reason for them to constantly be trying to ram square pegs in round holes just for virtue signalling purposes.

I also think were starting to see a lot of that backfire though so we will see how long that trend continues. There's fantastic diverse work out there, but were seeing so many giants try to fit people in roles they don't belong hurting both storytelling and the actors career as well. Its a double loss. A lot of that though can just be attributed to corporate b/s. Trying too hop on and profit off whatever bandwagon they can.

I think its all detracting from what the goal is. But that's just my opinion and we certainly have made leaps and bounds in the last 100 years with progression so who am I to say.


Hollywood has been sneaking in a little bit of virtue signaling and pushing of a liberal/progressive social agenda for literally decades. But at some point during the 2010s, things imho changed.

In the past, it felt like they were mostly preoccupied with making good movies and telling a good story, and only then added a sprinkle of liberal politics.
Since a point somewhere between 2014 and 2019, it feels as if the actual storylines and characters have been taking a backseat to the political messaging... as if the ostensible story is just a pretext for the attempt by the authors/studios to shove their politics down the throats of their audience.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Oct 14 2024 09:54pm
Member
Posts: 15,936
Joined: Jun 27 2010
Gold: 102,354.50
Oct 15 2024 01:04am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Oct 15 2024 05:52am)
Hollywood has been sneaking in a little bit of virtue signaling and pushing of a liberal/progressive social agenda for literally decades. But at some point during the 2010s, things imho changed.

In the past, it felt like they were mostly preoccupied with making good movies and telling a good story, and only then added a sprinkle of liberal politics.
Since a point somewhere between 2014 and 2019, it feels as if the actual storylines and characters have been taking a backseat to the political messaging... as if the ostensible story is just a pretext for the attempt by the authors/studios to shove their politics down the throats of their audience.


Nowadays if you make a movie and don't comply to Hollywood's woke standard then your movie cannot win an Oscar no matter how good the story, the actors and so on.

They're literally counting how many men, woman, white / black people etc appear in your movie.

Because movies cost a ton of money to produce and Oscars are important all producers adhere to Hollywood's woke rules.

Sad but true
Member
Posts: 54,072
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Oct 15 2024 01:23am
Quote (Djunior @ 15 Oct 2024 09:04)
Nowadays if you make a movie and don't comply to Hollywood's woke standard then your movie cannot win an Oscar no matter how good the story, the actors and so on.

They're literally counting how many men, woman, white / black people etc appear in your movie.

Because movies cost a ton of money to produce and Oscars are important all producers adhere to Hollywood's woke rules.

Sad but true

That doesn't make a lot of sense since most movies have no chance of winning an oscar by virtue of their genre or target audience, nor even aspire to win one.
If only movies with hopes of winning an oscar would get produced, there would never be another horror movie and virtually no more comedies.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Oct 15 2024 01:23am
Member
Posts: 15,936
Joined: Jun 27 2010
Gold: 102,354.50
Oct 15 2024 02:41am
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Oct 15 2024 09:23am)
That doesn't make a lot of sense since most movies have no chance of winning an oscar by virtue of their genre or target audience, nor even aspire to win one.
If only movies with hopes of winning an oscar would get produced, there would never be another horror movie and virtually no more comedies.


Agreed but try to convince the wokies (mostly filthy rich Hollywood big shots and movie stars who don't even realize what's going on in the real world).

A bunch of B-movie producers prolly don't care but the big title producers absolutely do.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev12345Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll