Quote (thundercock @ 4 Sep 2022 21:30)
As for the movement itself, I'm not sure what else to call something where if you win, it's legitimate, but if you lose, it's rigged. How would you define such a principle?
I think you're really doing Republicans dirty when you describe it like that. Sure, the MTG-style hardcore MAGA-heads would have cried foul with every outcome, but they are a fringe group. Say the polls in 2020 had been right and Biden had defeated Trump by 9% in the popular vote and ~6% in the EC tipping point state, and he had been ahead since election night - do you really believe that the GOP rank and file would have been as open to kooky election fraud conspiracies in that scenario?
Fact of the matter is that Trump was just a 0.65% uniform swing away from winning reelection and that he lead by big margins on election night in the pivotal states. Then, over night, a huge drop of Dem-leaning ballots came in and Biden narrowly pulls ahead in PA, GA. At the same time, their party made inroads in the House (against expections) and was in position to hold the Senate (until Trump fucked it up with his selfish post-election antics). Yes, the mail ballot vs election day vote split was due to the pandemic, but the mean voter is stupid and uneducated, like... really really fucking stupid. You surely agree with this notion, don't you?

So is it a surprise that they can't grasp the effect that these unique circumstances would have on the order in which ballots were counted? I, for my part, am not surprised that Republican rank and file were open to believe Trump's lies considering these circumstances, voters which were predisposed to rather believe that their side won and was cheated than that the other side won fair and square anyway.
Quote
We get the government that we deserve.
Indeed. I have been convinced that every democratic nation gets the government it deserves for a long time. You deserved GWB and Trump and Biden, just like my country deserved Merkel and Scholz, the Frenchies deserve Macron and the Canadians deserve Trudeau.
Quote
What could Republicans have done? Is this a serious question? After Trump lost the election, they could have cast him away as a loser. After Jan 6, they could have cast him away as a fascist. Hell, they could cast him away NOW over the stolen defense information. It's not like there is a void either. They could literally use DeSantis to "own the libs!" The GOP and right wing media is so tight-knit that they could easily blanket the media with coverage on why Trump was successful but he is no longer the right person to lead the party.
This goes back to Trump's selfish post-election antics I mentioned above. In the GA Senate runoffs, his influence depressed GOP turnout just enough for them to lose both seats. It was a show of force by Trump, a thinly veiled threat that he has enough influence over his base to ruin any competitive election for the GOP if he tells his supporters to stay home. By doing this, Trump signalled to the party establishment that he can ruin them if they turn on him and try to cast him away. Trump's big lie about the stolen election was horrible for the country, but it allowed him to shake off the stink of being a loser (SAD!) and retain the support of his base. Likewise, the way he blew the GA runoffs was horrible for the GOP, but allowed him to keep his grip over the party.
The party and their media ecosystem could have taken the risk of divorcing from Trump and sat out the turmoil if they had held the Senate, so that there would have been no threat of a Democratic trifecta implementing wide-ranging structural reforms which lock Republicans out of power (DC statehood, packing the Supreme Court etc.) - but with a Dem-trifecta looming, they shied away from ripping the bandaid off.
Quote
Lastly, you're drawing a false equivalence between Democrats and Republicans on what is a Republican issue. It's one thing for Dems to stupidly fund a handful of insane candidates. It's another thing to, you know, VOTE FOR THEM and like what they have to say. I'm going to repeat this again: Democrats and Republicans are NOT monoliths. There are Democrats who are willing to roll the dice when it comes to these issues and there are Democrats (the majority) who think it's completely unacceptable. Likewise, there are plenty of Republicans who accept Joe Biden as legitimate (this is more of a spectrum but if you have the cut off as 'did Joe Biden win the electoral college' then it's a vast majority).
That's a fair point. More blame has to go to those who vote for loons than for those who prop them up. My point still stands though: Democrats spending millions of dollars to prop up election deniers is a direct and irrefutable contradiction to their argument that these election deniers are a lethal threat to American democracy.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Sep 5 2022 02:38am