Quote (Black XistenZ @ May 23 2019 12:23am)
if the chinese really gave in on one of the key demands of Trump/the US/the West:
- a large reduction to their state subsidies
- truly open their market for foreign investors
- no more forced technology transfer for any company cooperating with Chinese companies
- no more economic spying
-----
note that the Chinese, despite being a juggernaut, have a lot of weaknesses as well:
- their government is anti-democratic and authoritarian, the Chinese people dont enjoy the same civil liberties as the people of the West. the unwritten compact between the Chinese government and its people is that the people go along with the rule of the Communist Party and put up with this lack of civil liberties in exchange for ever increasing material wealth. as soon as their economic growth slows down, the CP loses a significant pillar of its legitimization and this compact is at risk of breakign down..
- their banking sector is filled to the brim with bad and/or untransparent loans, there is a huge housing bubble which might burst at any moment.
- their cities suffer from pollution to a degree not seen in any western city.
- they are making heavy investments in the wake of their belt and road initiative in places like central asia and africa where the West has failed to induce meaningful progress or a fruitful economic relationship. at the moment, it looks as if the Chinese will be more successful, but the whole thing still remains a high stakes high risk investment.
- due to their one-child policy, China is aging rapidly. the share of elderly people will increase by a lot over the coming years, reducing the "demographic dividend" that had been giving China an extra boost over the last 40 years. demographically, they're running out of steam in the medium term. what this means is that they have less time than it seems to close the gap to the West in terms of gdp/capita if they want to be continue to catch up and compete with us in the long term.
due to those weaknesses, destructive tariffs which are hurting both sides could very well cause one side to reach its breaking point first and force them to cave in. not saying that it will be the Chinese side, but I wouldnt entirely rule it out either.
obviously, none of this will work if Trump is out in 2020, but if he truly gets 5 more years of his trade war, who knows.
if I had to guess out of my ass, I'd say the probability of Trump's tariffs hurting the Chinese so much that they make meaningful concessions is perhaps 20-25% if Trump gets another term. so yes, I wouldnt bet money on Trump on this issue, but ruling it out entirely like you do with smug, self-righteous conviction is short-sighted.
so we're talking about the same country that's a socio-communist run fake democracy, with a record of human right's violations still occurring as i type this, who also manipulates currency and is imposing a social credit system to control it's population. right? that country?
but a 1-2% profit loss, that can just become a poor tax given their structure, will cause them to make major concessions?
i said it before, and i'll say it again. i find the entire premise to be so ridiculous that i cant even earnestly discuss it. it's just silly. its almost as bad as the "If enough people starve in North Korea we'll finally win" narrative. Westerners don't understand these people will toss people into a meat grinder to maintain the power they have. and waiting out a POTUS for 8 years, hell even 16 years, with a downturn in exports is no big deal.
how people can think "china is the evil enemy" and "we can bring them around with some light choking" at the same time boggles my mines. its stupid.
This post was edited by thesnipa on May 23 2019 08:52am