d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > October Invasion Of Israel
Prev12902912922932941646Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 20,044
Joined: Apr 13 2016
Gold: 32,397.50
Oct 22 2023 06:20am
Quote (RedFromWinter @ Oct 22 2023 01:13pm)
Sentiment around here is neither should be getting aid from US with the domestic silent depression circumstance we in. Doesn't take a genius to realize foreign policy calculus with Israel is failed under current status quo unless goal is actual genocide.

Also Economist rank Israel 4th most successful economy among developed nations in 2022. They don't need the aid


Lend lease and the military industrial complex have entered the conversation.*
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Oct 22 2023 06:29am
Quote (RedFromWinter @ Oct 22 2023 05:13am)
Sentiment around here is neither should be getting aid from US with the domestic silent depression circumstance we in. Doesn't take a genius to realize foreign policy calculus with Israel is failed under current status quo unless goal is actual genocide.

Also Economist rank Israel 4th most successful economy among developed nations in 2022. They don't need the aid


That's not the sentiment.
Member
Posts: 9,123
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Oct 22 2023 06:30am
Quote (IceMage @ Oct 22 2023 07:29am)
That's not the sentiment.


It very much is in my jurisdiction of the USA.
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Oct 22 2023 06:33am
Quote (RedFromWinter @ Oct 22 2023 05:30am)
It very much is in my jurisdiction of the USA.


Are you trying to make an argument here?
Member
Posts: 28,875
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Oct 22 2023 06:37am
Quote (IceMage @ Oct 22 2023 07:57am)
I'm struggling to understand the "new right" support of Israel in this moment, compared against their opposition to the Ukraine struggle. Based on their stupid logic, it's just another war far away which drains resources from the US. Both wars were started by an enemy of the United States which seek to destroy their target, not just militarily, but as a people and country. But the nuts on the right think Israel should get support and Ukraine shouldn't.


Well your framing of 'their stupid logic' is pretty nonsensical, so no wonder you can't understand the conclusion. Ukraine is a geopolitical war, to undermine and weaken Russia's influence on a country that historically has been under their sphere of influence. It was backed and funded by the US starting with a coup in 2014. Israel on the other hand is not that. Historically the Jews have almost always been on the defensive with several wars of aggression by surrounding Muslims, that if they ever succeeded would almost certainly wipe out Israel as a country and the barbaric shit we've seen at the onset of this would be reality for millions. Again not something you would see in Ukraine. Ukraine under Russian influence would look like Ukraine prior to 2014, people peacefully living their lives.

But personally, I don't really think we should be funding either. Israel is more than able and rich enough to buy these weapons and not have them subsidized by the US taxpayer. Context also matters. If this new tranche of 60Bn goes through, between last year and this year, our funding for the Ukraine war would eclipse 70+years of Israel funding, which goes to show we're really dedicated to weakening Russia. I mean what's the alternative? Ukraine is a bigger more crucial ally vs Israel? lol.

This post was edited by ofthevoid on Oct 22 2023 06:53am
Member
Posts: 9,123
Joined: May 11 2009
Gold: 5.01
Oct 22 2023 06:37am
Quote (IceMage @ Oct 22 2023 07:33am)
Are you trying to make an argument here?


Adding my 2-cents. I can only explain it to you, I can't understand it for you. Your 'new right' assertion has nothing to do with the new right base. It's the usual suspects from old right taking advantage of a moment. Rural America is very much focused on America, not Israel, for sure not Ukraine. This is Iron Range timber north land middle-low class laborers with high probability of being a military family. The sentiment around here.
Member
Posts: 4,147
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 6.42
Warn: 10%
Oct 22 2023 06:50am
Quote (IceMage @ Oct 22 2023 08:57am)
I'm struggling to understand the "new right" support of Israel in this moment, compared against their opposition to the Ukraine struggle. Based on their stupid logic, it's just another war far away which drains resources from the US. Both wars were started by an enemy of the United States which seek to destroy their target, not just militarily, but as a people and country. But the nuts on the right think Israel should get support and Ukraine shouldn't.


Seems like struggling to understand things is a regular occurrence for you. It helps to learn about what you post about before posting about it, FYI.
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Oct 22 2023 07:01am
Quote (IceMage @ Oct 22 2023 07:57am)
I'm struggling to understand the "new right" support of Israel in this moment, compared against their opposition to the Ukraine struggle. Based on their stupid logic, it's just another war far away which drains resources from the US. Both wars were started by an enemy of the United States which seek to destroy their target, not just militarily, but as a people and country. But the nuts on the right think Israel should get support and Ukraine shouldn't.


Siding with the guy who "has been wrong on nearly every major foreign policy and national security issue over the past four decades" is the smart decision. Listening to Kissinger makes you a moron. How could it be otherwise, when the very smart people who brought us Iraq, Afghanistan, and Syria are all in support? And don't let the disaster of each of those debacles dissuade you, after all, we know they had the right idea because... well sometimes you just know.

After talking for years about the strategic necessity of "pivoting" to Asia, it should not be difficult to understand why it might not be in our interest to find ourselves locked into a forever war in Europe, the only guaranteed outcome of which is the subordination of Russia to Chinese interests. This after we've been told in no uncertain terms (circa 2014) that Ukraine is not a "core interest" of American foreign policy and that Europe must shoulder the lion's share of their own security. What changed between then and now is never explained. Just keep cutting the cheques and never judge a crisis by the results.

I don't follow pundit personalities online, so I don't know what they saying, but you're conflating support for Israel's "right to action" with support for sending Israel endless trunks of cash. Israel has a very pragmatic view of it's relationship with the United States, we ought to return the favor.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Oct 22 2023 07:21am
Quote (bogie160 @ 22 Oct 2023 03:28)
We needed to occupy Germany and Japan at the end of the second world war. The Gazan Arabs are far less cohesive a society than either. Stop making excuses for genocidal regimes and you'll feel happier.


Stop excusing a long process of a slow stealing, appartheid, ending up into a slow, planned, genocide of palestiians eventually.
Seems you will say, like the local radicalized far right neo-zionists, thatU.N & trusted NGOs reports on the matter "Do not count"...

U.S are vastly involved and the whole story reminds to everyone the 9/11 "retalations", which killed a million civilians. Repeated over and over.
Creating terrorists in order to justify massacres ? I would tell to these people: get lost, you are less than animals...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2014/07/30/how-israel-helped-create-hamas/

This post was edited by Meanwhile on Oct 22 2023 07:23am
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Oct 22 2023 07:32am
Quote (Meanwhile @ Oct 22 2023 09:21am)
Stop excusing a long process of a slow stealing, appartheid, ending up into a slow, planned, genocide of palestiians eventually.
Seems you will say, like the local radicalized far right neo-zionists, thatU.N & trusted NGOs reports on the matter "Do not count"...

U.S are vastly involved and the whole story reminds to everyone the 9/11 "retalations", which killed a million civilians. Repeated over and over.
Creating terrorists in order to justify massacres ? I would tell to these people: get lost, you are less than animals...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2014/07/30/how-israel-helped-create-hamas/


You are correct, I hold the UN's opinions (and that of left-wing NGOs) of virtually no account.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev12902912922932941646Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll