Quote (IceMage @ 7 Mar 2020 22:26)
Uh... of course some people thought that. Remember Obama's "magic wand" comment? It was basically making this point, that reversing globalization and automation isn't actually possible.
Do you think the uneducated voters who Trump loves base their votes on data?
Trump's election was based on a fantasy. It was the last(or second to last) gasp of a population who have been marginalized by the modern economy. The inner cities and rusted out factories haven't been revitalized. So the question is whether Trump can keep the fantasy alive for people who don't see America's renewed greatness in their own lives. The "marginal benefit" argument isn't going to bring voters out.
Even the most uneducated Trump voters will be smart and realistic enough to know that Trump cant reverse 50 years of globalization and deindustrialization in just 4 years. The key difference, in my opinion, is that Trump is at least TRYING to bring these jobs back, he's trying to renegotiate those free trade agreements which were a disaster for the Rust Belt, he's at least trying to offer some opposition against China and so on and so forth.
Yes, globalization, automation etc are mighty, transnational forces, and one president of one country almost surely wont be able to really
reverse this trend. But an American president can at least slow down and mitigate these forces which are wrecking parts of Middle America instead of doubling down on them (like signing TPP, TTIP, selling out to the Chinese). And that's what Trump is trying to do.
And most crucially: Trump is the first president in half a lifetime who even acknowledges this problem in the first place and tries to do something about it. Reagan, Bush, Clinton, W. Bush, Obama - they all didnt care because globalization and automation made their donors (Republicans) and/or their coastal base (Democrats) richer. So yes, the "marginal benefit" argument wont bring the voters out - but the "he's the first one in decades to see our misery and fight for us"-argument will.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Mar 7 2020 11:26pm