d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Christianity Is Obviously Fake
Prev1268269270
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 16,002
Joined: Dec 27 2019
Gold: 69.69
Jun 5 2026 06:46pm
i've already pointed out the incoherence of your thanos marvel comic position, I don't know why you cling to this it does not have the necessary attributes to ground the preconditions for intelligibility. your example is attempting to grasp at some of the metaphysical attributes of the Triune God but falls short, which is why the reductio ad absurdum is so effective against your false worldview.

you can take the position that logic is not justifiable or capable of being grounded but this would be an incoherent one because you'd be saying knowledge itself is impossible, your capability to make an argument would collapse. I am making the argument to ground logic because without grounding logic I cannot possibly make an argument on the validity of my own worldview, which is where your materialistic worldview fails and you cling at comic book characters in some weird immature desperation. this is the entire point of the critique

yes, if logic is universal, invariant and immaterial it would necessarily imply these very specific preconditions that the Triune God has, which part of this do you not understand?

I don't know what you're referring to when you say God "constantly changes". God does not change in essence or attributes, we experience His energia or activities in the world.

is your worldview materialistic and you are taking the position that logic itself cannot be grounded aka knowledge is impossible?


Your "necessary" attributes aren't justified they are simply presumptive. Also you conveniently ignored my counterpoint that jesus is a localized physical entity just like Thanos which disqualifies him from your own criteria.

Saying that knowledge itself is impossible without logic being grounded is an argument from ignorance.

You stated god is or has invariant mind. This is clearly not the case since he changes his mind and actions constantly in the bible from deciding to kill or spare people. The very act of learning new information creates a change.
Member
Posts: 17,568
Joined: Mar 13 2009
Gold: 0.00
Jun 5 2026 07:53pm
If that's the case it's not too late to change your mind, just like God will change His mind. Just like that Superannuation commercial, it's not too late. There is still time.
Member
Posts: 54,730
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Jun 5 2026 08:09pm
Your "necessary" attributes aren't justified they are simply presumptive. Also you conveniently ignored my counterpoint that jesus is a localized physical entity just like Thanos which disqualifies him from your own criteria.

Saying that knowledge itself is impossible without logic being grounded is an argument from ignorance.

You stated god is or has invariant mind. This is clearly not the case since he changes his mind and actions constantly in the bible from deciding to kill or spare people. The very act of learning new information creates a change.

the necessary attributes are a priori from the category of transcendentals, this isn't "presumptive" if by that you mean "baseless".

Jesus is fully God and fully human, I don't see the issue or any strength in your "counterpoint".

it is not an argument from ignorance, you have no idea what you're talking about. this is an argument from necessity.

if you cannot justify reason there is no justified reason to believe you have knowledge using your worldview. do you understand this? you can still have knowledge but it means your worldview is not the correct one as it does not justify knowledge. if we work purely within the grounds of your own worldview and say there is no possibility of intelligibility knowledge becomes impossible.

God does not change his mind nor does he learn anything, holy tradition is meant to reveal God to us, not to take in whatever weird personal hyper literal interpretation you are making right now. I don't have interest in debating your strawman of my worldview so if you have questions just ask, in the same way I ask:

What is your worldview and how does it account for the possibility of intelligibility? how does it ground universal, invariant and immaterial laws of logic?
Member
Posts: 54,730
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Jun 5 2026 08:14pm
If that's the case it's not too late to change your mind, just like God will change His mind. Just like that Superannuation commercial, it's not too late. There is still time.


God never changes his mind, this is bad theology. He is calling everyone to participate in being healed by being in communion with Him
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1268269270
Add Reply New Topic New Poll