d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Official Political Picture Thread
Prev1261226132614261526165001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 93,001
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Jan 16 2019 12:17pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 16 2019 12:12pm)
Drugs: Yes, even tight border enforcement would not completely prevent drugs from coming into the country, but the harder it gets for them, the less drugs will be floating around. If you consider drug usage to be harmful, low accessability of drugs is desirable, and high accessability is problematic.


this part is just not true. mexican weed was harder to get across the border and harder to smuggle around. when production was localized the supply went way up. but they didn't need to localize production until the border started ramping up spot checks and drug dogs along the points of entry in the 90s.

if you stop Heroin from crossing the border there's a very real chance the amount of it in US hands could go up or at the very least be entirely unchanged. that's what happened with weed, all the literature is there but might be behind collegiate paywalls.

tl;dr the % chance to get caught with illegal drugs is vastly higher on the border than domestically. and therefore removing that risk could increase drug supply, as well as 1st world production techniques instead of columbians sweating over a table for 12 hours a day.

This post was edited by thesnipa on Jan 16 2019 12:18pm
Member
Posts: 54,769
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 1,463.83
Jan 16 2019 12:17pm
Quote (Jupe @ Jan 16 2019 11:12am)


Member
Posts: 57,138
Joined: Nov 7 2009
Gold: 2,195.68
Jan 16 2019 12:18pm
Member
Posts: 54,187
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Jan 16 2019 12:25pm
Quote (thesnipa @ 16 Jan 2019 19:17)
this part is just not true. mexican weed was harder to get across the border and harder to smuggle around. when production was localized the supply went way up. but they didn't need to localize production until the border started ramping up spot checks and drug dogs along the points of entry in the 90s.

if you stop Heroin from crossing the border there's a very real chance the amount of it in US hands could go up or at the very least be entirely unchanged. that's what happened with weed, all the literature is there but might be behind collegiate paywalls.

tl;dr the % chance to get caught with illegal drugs is vastly higher on the border than domestically. and therefore removing that risk could increase drug supply, as well as 1st world production techniques instead of columbians sweating over a table for 12 hours a day.


What a defeatist attitude. What do you suggest to do about drugs? Just surrender and legalize all of them, even the really dangerous, really hard stuff? Imho, there's a world of a difference between weed, and hard shit like heroin or cocaine.


Btw: large-scale poppy growing is not possible in the american climate, while weed can be grown in a greenhouse. So while it was possible to localize weed production, I actually dont think that the same would be possible with heroin.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Jan 16 2019 12:26pm
Member
Posts: 93,001
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Jan 16 2019 12:33pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 16 2019 12:25pm)
What a defeatist attitude. What do you suggest to do about drugs? Just surrender and legalize all of them, even the really dangerous, really hard stuff? Imho, there's a world of a difference between weed, and hard shit like heroin or cocaine.


Btw: large-scale poppy growing is not possible in the american climate, while weed can be grown in a greenhouse. So while it was possible to localize weed production, I actually dont think that the same would be possible with heroin.


actually combat drugs and drug abuse, rather than putting 137 bandaids over the fucking wound. ive been asked what i'd do many times, and ive spent the time to post hundreds of bullet points over many posts.

as to heroin i would legalize medical pot to offset some pain med usage and attempt to more harshly regulate the pain pill market, to start with. i'd also go right into mexico and fuck the shit out of those cartels. a process that was underway before Trump came along and shut down all cooperation.

as to the poppy supply, lol. you think they'll have drug dogs at every port? sniffing every container (1000s per ship) off hundreds of ships a day?

water follows the path of least resistance, currently that's the border. plug a hole and a new one comes along.

as to the defeatist bullshit, i get that daily. try harder. i want to actually fix stuff, excuse me for not living with a "let's just try shit and see what happens, at least then we can pretend we did our best" attitude. this is what my undergrad was in, this is what all my term papers were in, etc. i know the issue, the wall is a fucking joke. period. on drugs anyway. it's only valid purpose is to stop foot traffic, that's it. disbelieve me all you want i frankly dont care. ive typed it all out with hundreds of sources provided in the past just to get the same bullshit from people incapable of nuance of planning ahead.
Member
Posts: 63,058
Joined: Jul 15 2005
Gold: 152.00
Jan 16 2019 08:09pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 16 2019 01:12pm)
wrong. it had accelerated during the 80s and early 90s, reached extreme levels during the late 90s and early 00s, then slowed down after the great recession, and is picking up pace again right now. what has indeed remained flat ever since the great recession is immigration of mexicans, but it has been replaced by immigration from central america.


Nah.






Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 16 2019 01:12pm)
This figure is floated a lot, but I highly doubt it. No matter one's immigration status, the majority of crimes are committed within the neighborhood/social peer group and dont affect strangers. How do you estimate crimes committed within communities of illegal immigrants, a group which has a strong incentive to not report them to the police?


You're welcome to provide contradictory evidence if you don't accept the evidence which suggests they commit fewer crimes. Your speculation does not constitute a convincing argument unless you can provide some evidentiary basis for it.

Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 16 2019 01:12pm)
Crime: No matter the crime rate of the illegal immigrant group, every crime committed by them against a local american would not have happened if the illegal immigrant hadnt been in the country in the first place.


And far fewer crimes would be committed if we just got rid of all that natural-born citizens. Irrelevant point.

Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 16 2019 01:12pm)
Drugs: Yes, even tight border enforcement would not completely prevent drugs from coming into the country, but the harder it gets for them, the less drugs will be floating around. If you consider drug usage to be harmful, low accessability of drugs is desirable, and high accessability is problematic.


Accessibility of hard drugs has very little impact on addiction and overdose rates, and may even have an inverse relationship, where states with more lenient drug laws and more compassionate recovery options tend to have lower abuse and death rates. Either way, I see no reason why a wall would reduce illicit drug accessibility.

Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 16 2019 01:12pm)
Culture: Many of the immigrants, particularly those from central america, grew up in an environment and a culture of violence. Everyone is shaped by the circumstances under which they grew up. Moreover, most latin americans are more left-leaning than the average american. Therefore, in the long run, thanks to birthright citizenship, the US-born children of illegal immigrants will eventually pull the entire country in this direction. We're already seeing the beginning of this effect with figures like Ocasio-Cortez.


One can hope.

Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 16 2019 01:12pm)
Welfare/taxes: due to the typically low education level of those coming across the southern border, and due to the language barrier, this type of immigrant is typically paying less in taxes than what the government is spending on them, either directly in the form of welfare, food stamps, or child benefit, or indirectly by providing for roads, schools, hospitals and so on. Illegal employment exacerbates this effect, and leads illegal immigrants to be a big fiscal net drain on our communities.


Immigrants are more likely to pursue higher education after emigrating than native-born citizens. Second generation immigrants exceed the educational level of native-born citizens, as well as perform better in school and attain higher-tier employment.

Quote (Black XistenZ @ Jan 16 2019 01:12pm)
Wages: illegal immigration causes an influx of cheap labor. Due to their precarious situation, they are particularly easy to exploit, and are often times paid below minimum wage, not receiving certain benefits and so on. Overall, the influx of illegal immigrants from latin america creates pressure on the wages of low-education americans.


With the benefit of significant economic growth. More comprehensive welfare policies could pretty easily address this issue.
Member
Posts: 54,187
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Jan 16 2019 08:35pm
Quote (Voyaging @ 17 Jan 2019 03:09)


those charts are mostly consistent with what I said.



Quote
You're welcome to provide contradictory evidence if you don't accept the evidence which suggests they commit fewer crimes. Your speculation does not constitute a convincing argument unless you can provide some evidentiary basis for it.

it's in the nature of things that crimes amongst undocumented immigrants go... wait for it... undocumented. *badummtsss*



Quote
And far fewer crimes would be committed if we just got rid of all that natural-born citizens. Irrelevant point.

A sovereign nation has to deal with its own people, while it can chose its immigrants. Relevant difference.


Quote
One can hope.

She Guevara 2024?!



Quote
Immigrants are more likely to pursue higher education after emigrating than native-born citizens. Second generation immigrants exceed the educational level of native-born citizens, as well as perform better in school and attain higher-tier employment.

Do you have a source for this? And is this referring to all immigrants pooled together, or does this statement still hold if applied to only illegal immigrants and their offspring? Because a lot of the legal immigrants are highly educated professionals who were specifically allowed in based on their merit. That the children of Rajesh, the Indian PhD holder who's working for Google in Silicon Valley, will reach high educational attainment is hardly surprising. Pooling them together with the children of Jose, the illegal immigrant who's picking vegetables in Central Valley at half the minimum wage and who's barely literate even in his native language, would confound and obscure the actual trends within two very different demographics.


Quote
With the benefit of significant economic growth. More comprehensive welfare policies could pretty easily address this issue.


The wealth of a nation largely depends on its GDP per capita, not on its nominal/raw GDP. Immigration is only beneficial in fiscal terms if it increases a country's productivity, or at least leaves it unaffected. Therefore, the simple rule of thumb is: well-educated immigrants = good, low-education immigrants = bad. In the United States, we have a lot of both. The positive contributions of legal immigrants should be acknowledged, but this does not reduce the negative impact of poverty immigrants from the south in the slightest.

This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Jan 16 2019 08:36pm
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Jan 16 2019 08:44pm
Member
Posts: 33,928
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Member
Posts: 29,008
Joined: Jun 20 2007
Gold: 34.51
Jan 16 2019 09:24pm
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ Jan 16 2019 10:44pm)


Can we do a before and after for France.

Hot chick

Hot chick being raped then beheaded.


Ooo, or beautiful quaint streets

Mattress tent covered piss city.

This post was edited by SBD on Jan 16 2019 09:26pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1261226132614261526165001Next
Closed New Topic New Poll