Quote (Black XistenZ @ 30 Nov 2018 15:08)
For real though: can you imagine the radicalization and the electoral success on the local and state level that the GOP would have had under a clinton presidency?
I honestly dont think that the country would be any less divided at this point in time, or the public discourse any less dysfunctional and toxic, if Clinton had won.
In the long run, Clinton losing to Trump was probably for the better of the Democratic party and its electoral prospects.
I agree, I think the country would be almost as divided if HRC won. I do think Trump has probably made political polarization worse, and I also think the public discourse would be slightly less toxic - but just as dysfunctional and unproductive.
If Clinton wins, the GOP probably strengthen their grip on both chambers of Congress and then have an even larger majority with a good shot at taking the White House in 2020. They'd also clean up on the local and state level.
I would agree that Clinton losing to Trump is better for Democrats in the long-term except for the fact that it cost them at least 1 SCOTUS seat and probably more. It would be much better for Democrats long-term to have a SCOTUS that struck down gerrymandering and defended voting rights.
Besides, Clinton losing didn't change the party for the better that much, anyways. The Democratic Party hasn't really learned from it's mistakes and is rolling out a lot of the same leaders and rhetoric as they did in 2016.
Quote (Black XistenZ @ 30 Nov 2018 15:12)
Honestly, can we just stop talking about "Trump vs Clinton"? We're through with this, it has been discussed to death, and I really dont see anyone changing his perspective/getting persuaded by the arguments of the other side after all this time.
I would very much like that, but it's difficult for many Trump supporters to discuss topics or criticisms of the President without bringing up Hillary Clinton.
In this case, this whole discussion was started with me asking if Trump should have divested himself more from his business, and then the whatabout Clinton stuff started rolling in, and here we are.
I've proposed creating a Trump thread and a Clinton thread in PaRD where conversations and criticisms should remain on topic without all the whataboutisms that tend to derail discussion. This idea would inevitably fail, but it's nice to think about.