Quote (JessiWan @ Aug 6 2023 03:52am)
In theory, anyone can convert to Judaism. However 1. he might still not be considered a real Jews by some Rabbis, 2. just because religiously, he's a Jew, it does not mean that biologically he's a Jew.
I think you are confused. You don't seem to know that being Jew has two meanings, one being a religious identity, and the other a racial one.
If you are born to two biologically Jewish parents, then you are a Jew, by blood.
What is the difference between having Hebrew ancestry and being a Jew, in your opinion.
True, except that being a Jew is not just a religious identity.
How is it a contradiction?
Dude, you don't have the right to call anybody simple.
If you see no difference between being a Hebrew or a jew then you don't see a difference between beliefs and race. We have words that define meaning, can't just cherrypick what they mean based on your feelings lol. You are identical to those lgbtq community people who identify as toasters. You really went turbo simp mode.
When a priest or a rabbi tells you that to be Jewish you need to have be born from a jew are contradicting themselves because their origin story begins with 2 people. Then again from Noah and his family. According to Bible or Torah everyone is a descendant everyone has the same "blood" coming from Abraham and Noah. If you have ancestors who were not from the Bible meaning a completely different blood line that means the bible story didn't originate with Adam and Eve. It means that the bible is not true. Hence the contradiction.
This includes you. Everyone according to Jewish, Christian and Muslim religious propaganda has a common ancestor we are all one blood.
Ofc this is a bs story since we know everyone has different blood and different genes and different physiology. We didn't come from from 2 people is some magical garden and a talking snake that is fermented camel milk and magic mushrooms talking.
If you can be born a jew from 2 Jewish parents then one can pick and choose their race at will. Right before having a baby 2 parents can decide to be orthodox jews and their baby is automatically an orthodox jew?
Or what if 2 parents want to identify as 2 non binary black Christians. Does it mean the baby is now born a black non binary Christian?
Beliefs are seperate from the biological race. Otherwise anyone can identify as anything.
Maybe you are confusing the word race with ethnicity?
Race - Physical characteristics that define a person as being a member of a specific group, Skin color, hair color and texture, eye color, facial features, physical build
Ethnicity - Cultural characteristics that define a person as being a member of a specific group. Language, accent, religion, styles of dress, hairstyles, social customs, food and dietary preferences or restrictions
Nationality - The legal sense of belonging to a specific political nation state Citizenship (birthright or naturalized)