Quote (Thor123422 @ 23 Sep 2020 05:58)
It's almost like... like.... there are systems built to oppress specific groups.... and they're still around to this day....
No, no. That can't be it. That would be like, systemic racism, and I've been assured that doesn't exist.
(I don't see access to abortion as a negative, but you get the idea. You're literally arguing for a version of systemic racism here, which is super ironic since you deny it in virtually every other facet of life.)
See, this line of flawed reasoning is exactly why I and many others reject this whole "systemic racism" thing.
- First, you will obviously have more abortion clinics in states which welcome and fund them than in states which defund them and pass laws to hamper their operations.
- Second, there is a strong reciprocal association between the share of non-whites and a place's political lean. Diversity makes places more liberal, and more liberal places attract non-whites (think of NYC or Atlanta). Hence, places which are liberal on everything, including abortion, will automatically show a strong correlation with the share of PoC.
- Third, there are social/cultural factors at play too. Rates of teenage pregnancy are higher among poorer and less educated segments of population. Additionally, pregnant women will be less inclined to look for an abortion if they have a strong family network and/or a sizable family net worth to fall back on - two things which are, for various reasons, less common in black neighborhoods than in white ones. Taken together, this means that there will naturally be a higher demand for abortions in less white places.
Simply put, your line of reasoning here is badly violating Hanlon's Razor in the variation from Jane West:
"Let us not attribute to malice and cruelty what may be referred to less criminal motives."
The correlation between abortion rates and abortion clinic density and the share of blacks in a neighborhood can be plausibly explained by a wide variety of confounding factors. One has to go out of one's way to instead ascribe it to some sort of
systemic targetting by nefarious white cryptoracists who secretly plot to murder black babies. These days, Planned Parenthood is not an organization driven by a racist mission, no matter which afterthoughts its founder had a lifetime ago. And needless to say that PP is not forcing its services onto anyone. Even if one considers the outcome of their operations to be a disproportionate decimation of blacks, the responsibility for this outcome still falls onto the individuals who voluntarily chose to use their services.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Sep 22 2020 11:00pm