d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Trump Taxes
Prev1192021222324Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Sep 28 2020 01:35pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 28 2020 02:10pm)
I just agreed that racialized appeals to white voters were a significant part of his platform and appeal in 2016. But I vehemently disagree with your notion that racialized stuff made up all of his appeal or platform, while the genuinely economic kind of populism didnt play a role at all.

Simple question: do you think that Trump would have won MI, WI and PA, and thus the presidency, in 2016 based on degrading Mexicans if he had simultaneously run on a Romney-esque economic platform, if he had positioned himself as pro-NAFTA and pro-neoliberal-globalization?


He won those states by turning out rural voters, who absolutely respond to the kind of white identity politics that Skinned is referencing.

The "bring back coal and reduce regulation" rhetoric is pretty standard for Republicans. Bring back manufacturing, etc. is something they always run on.

I mean, so is the white identity politics, but usually it's hidden behind dog whistles.
Member
Posts: 61,688
Joined: Mar 14 2006
Gold: 28.77
Sep 28 2020 02:09pm
If it's OK for the wealthy to cheat the system "because it's legal and makes them smart," then it's OK for poor people to exploit loopholes in the welfare system and I must assume you think that's OK and makes them smart, too.

And speaking of welfare, using public services without paying for them is also welfare. Trump is a welfare queen. Period.
Member
Posts: 50,908
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,836.00
Sep 28 2020 02:57pm
Quote (inkanddagger @ Sep 28 2020 03:09pm)
If it's OK for the wealthy to cheat the system "because it's legal and makes them smart," then it's OK for poor people to exploit loopholes in the welfare system and I must assume you think that's OK and makes them smart, too.

And speaking of welfare, using public services without paying for them is also welfare. Trump is a welfare queen. Period.


But its okay for Joe Biden to cheat the system and/or use loopholes because he's a democrat
Member
Posts: 22,442
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 76.11
Sep 28 2020 03:05pm
Quote (Goomshill @ Sep 28 2020 01:57pm)
But its okay for Joe Biden to cheat the system and/or use loopholes because he's a democrat


Imagine thinking Ink would justify the actions of someone because they're a Democrat.
Member
Posts: 54,183
Joined: May 26 2005
Gold: 4,945.67
Sep 28 2020 03:08pm
Quote (Handcuffs @ 28 Sep 2020 23:05)
Imagine thinking Ink would justify the actions of someone because they're a Democrat.


And not just your usual, far-right Democrat, no, it's Joe Biden, one of the most staunchly right-wing extremist Democrats out there.


This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Sep 28 2020 03:08pm
Member
Posts: 64,763
Joined: Oct 25 2006
Gold: 0.00
Sep 28 2020 03:16pm
Quote (Black XistenZ @ Sep 28 2020 04:08pm)
And not just your usual, far-right Democrat, no, it's Joe Biden, one of the most staunchly right-wing extremist Democrats out there.


I mean, it took beating old Joe over the head for a while to even get him to say he wanted Medicare for all, and often he still won't admit that being dependent on your employer for your healthcare in a pandemic is a shitty situation.

Joe will be about the same as Obama, in that he will be an excellent status-quo manager. Things won't get better (except for maybe how the pandemic is handled), the systemic problems will largely stay the same with a little movement on some issues that there's really wide popular support, but for the most part the issues will remain.
Member
Posts: 50,908
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,836.00
Sep 28 2020 03:28pm
Quote (Thor123422 @ Sep 28 2020 04:16pm)
I mean, it took beating old Joe over the head for a while to even get him to say he wanted Medicare for all, and often he still won't admit that being dependent on your employer for your healthcare in a pandemic is a shitty situation.

Joe will be about the same as Obama, in that he will be an excellent status-quo manager. Things won't get better (except for maybe how the pandemic is handled), the systemic problems will largely stay the same with a little movement on some issues that there's really wide popular support, but for the most part the issues will remain.


More than just a status-quo manager, I think its reasonable to say that whats at stake in this election is inversely proportional to how strongly people feel about it. Joe Biden becoming president, or Trump being reelected, is likely going to be very inconsequential in the long run compared to previous presidencies, or at least the 2016 election by a huge margin. Now that US popular opinion has rebuked the warmongering neoliberals while Trump has busted out peace processes everywhere means even the drastic difference in foreign policy that 2016 presented is going to be largely moot with Biden who won't be keen to repeat Obama's mistakes. So what you've got is Trump, who already accomplished almost all his domestic policy objectives in the wall, tax cuts, job creation / economic growth, deregulation, etc etc and has defeated ISIS and killed Baghdadi and wound down the wars and pushed Iran into a corner, etc etc- up for reelection against a milquetoast pragmatist who will bend with the popular opinion on any issue, a popular opinion generally aligned with most of Trump's legacy. We had 4 years of Republicans declining to repeal Obamacare, I imagine that even were Biden elected we'd have 4 years of Democrats declining to 'tear down the wall' or betray the Saudis & Israel on Iran or hike taxes. And on top of all of that, whoever is elected next will have a drought of judicial openings to nominate because of how prolific McConnell's factory line was for the past 4 years. The actuarial odds of another scotus opening with Breyer as the only 80+ year old aren't great and the lower courts are stuffed silly.

So we've got a world where folks are shooting each other and driving into each other's rallies in car ramming attacks because they're so hyped up over partisan politics, but the results of the election might be largely inconsequential in the long run. Biden isn't going to undo Trump's advances and whatever his foibles he's not as dangerously erratic as Clinton on an international stage
Member
Posts: 530
Joined: Mar 16 2018
Gold: 336.86
Sep 28 2020 03:28pm
Quote (Goomshill @ Sep 28 2020 04:57pm)
But its okay for Joe Biden to cheat the system and/or use loopholes because he's a democrat


But Joe Biden isnt trying to turn the system into a Dictatorship
Member
Posts: 11,757
Joined: Dec 17 2006
Gold: 0.00
Sep 28 2020 03:42pm
Quote (IroningTheMaiden @ Sep 28 2020 04:28pm)
But Joe Biden isnt trying to turn the system into a Dictatorship


You're right.

Joe Biden is only trying to take away the Second Amendment.

This post was edited by GLYC123 on Sep 28 2020 03:49pm
Member
Posts: 49,289
Joined: Jun 18 2006
Gold: 11.77
Sep 28 2020 03:51pm
Quote (bogie160 @ Sep 28 2020 11:10am)
My position on this hasn't changed from 2012 to now.

Trump is obligated to pay what he owes in accordance with the law. It's poor framing to use words "[take] advantage", he is either onside or he is not. If he did not make money, or he posted losses which offset income earned, then I don't have any fundamental issue with his tax bill.

It's fair to ask why Trump's tax reform bill did not do more to address some of the fundamental challenges with our tax law, and it's fair to expect an answer, but it has nothing to do with his personal finances. People who hate the man will feign outrage, and his supporters will cheer him on. It's a meaningless distraction.


You keep responding to points I never made. I haven't criticized Trump for what he paid, although I think it's not unreasonable to do so.

Really I'm just interested in the people who look at a story like this, and the only reaction is "nothing matters". Not even as it pertains to what he campaigned on, and how he has governed. It's just pure visceral tribalism... you guys can't even entertain why this might be relevant without someone making it abundantly clear to you.

Quote (ofthevoid @ Sep 28 2020 11:14am)
'pressure' people into doing something after they've opposed you at every level and have called you a rapist, Russian plant, etc?

In the US it's the voters job to pressure. You can call up your congress person and pressure. The president is not a king with absolute power able to force congress to change laws.


So it's the voters job to pressure politicians, but Trump deserves absolutely no blame or criticism for not following campaign promises in this area.

Wew lad.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1192021222324Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll