d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Is European Gun Control Working
Prev123459Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 33,358
Joined: Dec 20 2007
Gold: 11,245.00
Jul 3 2022 06:04pm
lol @ this thread

Shall not be infringed.
Member
Posts: 16,161
Joined: Dec 27 2019
Gold: 69.69
Jul 3 2022 06:24pm
Quote (fender @ Jul 4 2022 09:51am)
can you show me a statistic supporting your claim that "hundreds of thousands" of people were saved from being shot by evil people?
anyway, even if that were true, they wouldn't have to be "saved" if the evil people didn't have guns in the first place, genius.

maybe compare homicide rates in the US with those in the civilised world - and that's despite the US already locking up more people per capita than any other nation in the world, meaning many of the "evil people" don't even have the chance to do their thing.

it's almost like the common sense conclusion, guns being a net negative, is supported by facts and stats, and all you have is some ridiculous fantasy scenario that gun manufacturers and their advocacy groups implanted in your gullible brain...


Name me one time in human existence since cavemen when bad/evil guys obeyed the law and respected no weapons mandates of any kind? Even in prisons with maximum security bad guys manage to make, smuggle weapons and do their thing. Your dream theory is invalid
Can you please for the love of God go dig a hole and never come out ever again. You are getting hard clapped by literally everyone in this thread.

This post was edited by addone on Jul 3 2022 06:36pm
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2022 06:27pm
Quote (thundercock @ 4 Jul 2022 01:55)
Probably. But criminals need to give up their guns first. Then the cops and THEN upstanding citizens.


here's the problem with that: a lot of them ARE "upstanding citizens" - just until the point that they aren't any more. that percentage is even higher for those dying to self-harm or firearm accidents - and those are most definitely not prevented by "good guys with a gun"...

so let's be honest here, the net negative is not a "probably", but a "definitely" - and while your "solution" might sound fair and reasonable at first glance (i'm just waiting for it to crop up in some self-proclaimed "libertarian's" sig or profile, since it's exactly the kind of quote they would consider deep or intellectual, even though it makes no sense whatsoever if you think about it for just a second), it's obviously (i say that because i'm well aware that you don't genuinely think that could or would ever happen) not much more than virtue signalling...
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2022 07:05pm
Quote (addone @ 4 Jul 2022 02:24)
Name me one time in human existence since cavemen when bad/evil guys obeyed the law and respected no weapons mandates of any kind? Even in prisons with maximum security bad guys manage to make, smuggle weapons and do their thing. Your dream theory is invalid
Can you please for the love of God go dig a hole and never come out ever again. You are getting hard clapped by literally everyone in this thread.


that's not the argument i'm making, nor is it an argument anyone has ever made, my brave conqueror of vicious strawman hordes. the actual argument (which is well supported by statistical evidence from around the globe) is that bad guys in civilised countries simply will have a much more difficult time to obtain a gun, and much less of a "need" for one to begin with. criminals, police, and everyone else would not consider literally every single fellow citizen as a potentially lethal threat.

the thing that gun-sexuals always seem to forget while day-dreaming about the incredibly unlikely (compared with the multiple times higher chance of you or one of your family members getting hurt or killed by your own firearm) "my gun saves the day" scenario is that if you live a reasonably normal life, chances are that there simply isn't anyone out there hell-bent on ending your sorry little existence.

let me paint a more likely scenario: while raiding your mom's fridge in your pink anime panties (not judging) at night, you surprise a burglar - in a civilised society, chances are they would not be prepared or even just equipped to kill you. they would probably just take off, realising there's literally nothing of worth to begin with - and that's a good thing, because your gun is still under your pillow in the basement.

people wouldn't execute their drunk neighbour stumbling across their lawn because they thought their life was in danger, or even just because they knew they can get away with it in that shithole of yours - they'd be annoyed, call them a drunk cunt, and that's the end of that story. no life lost.

This post was edited by fender on Jul 3 2022 07:06pm
Member
Posts: 3,908
Joined: Jun 20 2022
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2022 07:06pm
Uvalde. Off duty fed borrows a local’s 12 gauge and ends the shooting. Good guy with a gun. Also, same day several people were disarmed and detained after trying to rush in and become good guy with gun, way before the fed took care of business.
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2022 07:10pm
Quote (YeeHaw @ 4 Jul 2022 03:06)
Uvalde. Off duty fed borrows a local’s 12 gauge and ends the shooting. Good guy with a gun. Also, same day several people were disarmed and detained after trying to rush in and become good guy with gun, way before the fed took care of business.


definitely a good guy with a gun, yes.

so let's do the math now:

- how many people died that day?
- how many would have died if the attacker hadn't had a gun in the first place?

see where i'm going with this? net loss, despite the good guy. thanks for playing. was ez. gg no re.
Member
Posts: 3,908
Joined: Jun 20 2022
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2022 07:18pm
Quote (fender @ Jul 3 2022 09:10pm)
definitely a good guy with a gun, yes.

so let's do the math now:

- how many people died that day?
- how many would have died if the attacker hadn't had a gun in the first place?

see where i'm going with this? net loss, despite the good guy. thanks for playing. was ez. gg no re.



You spout nonsense constantly on this forum.
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Jul 3 2022 07:43pm
Quote (YeeHaw @ 4 Jul 2022 03:18)
You spout nonsense constantly on this forum.


i just knew you couldn't do simple math, hehe...
Member
Posts: 47,104
Joined: Sep 5 2016
Gold: 100.00
Jul 3 2022 07:55pm
Quote (fender @ Jul 3 2022 06:10pm)
definitely a good guy with a gun, yes.

so let's do the math now:

- how many people died that day?
- how many would have died if the attacker hadn't had a gun in the first place?

see where i'm going with this? net loss, despite the good guy. thanks for playing. was ez. gg no re.


crooks have guns your fairy tale wish and fairy tale gun fee zones is just you in a fairy tale.
Member
Posts: 16,161
Joined: Dec 27 2019
Gold: 69.69
Jul 3 2022 07:58pm
Quote (fender @ Jul 4 2022 01:05pm)
that's not the argument i'm making, nor is it an argument anyone has ever made, my brave conqueror of vicious strawman hordes. the actual argument (which is well supported by statistical evidence from around the globe) is that bad guys in civilised countries simply will have a much more difficult time to obtain a gun, and much less of a "need" for one to begin with. criminals, police, and everyone else would not consider literally every single fellow citizen as a potentially lethal threat.

the thing that gun-sexuals always seem to forget while day-dreaming about the incredibly unlikely (compared with the multiple times higher chance of you or one of your family members getting hurt or killed by your own firearm) "my gun saves the day" scenario is that if you live a reasonably normal life, chances are that there simply isn't anyone out there hell-bent on ending your sorry little existence.

let me paint a more likely scenario: while raiding your mom's fridge in your pink anime panties (not judging) at night, you surprise a burglar - in a civilised society, chances are they would not be prepared or even just equipped to kill you. they would probably just take off, realising there's literally nothing of worth to begin with - and that's a good thing, because your gun is still under your pillow in the basement.

people wouldn't execute their drunk neighbour stumbling across their lawn because they thought their life was in danger, or even just because they knew they can get away with it in that shithole of yours - they'd be annoyed, call them a drunk cunt, and that's the end of that story. no life lost.


That's a long way of saying I like to dream up fantasy strawmans to prove shall not be infringed doest exist.
You fervously love pointing out any and all statistics/examples as long as they support the NPC mindset you don't ever question. The second the statistics say the opposite you go off on a huge tangent how they stats are all wrong and or just completely ignore it. Let's face it you are theorycrafting larper who thought to take those ideals into PaRD. I am wiling to bet not only have you failed at just about every argument you made here but you most likely got shit on by the power gamers on any platform.

If you have a point make sure to end it with in my opinion and at the very least provide some evidence/statistics.

Here is one for you gun ownership is only prohibited in Cambodia, Eritrea, and Solomon islands. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overview_of_gun_laws_by_nation#:~:text=In%20a%20few%20countries%2C%20including,by%20civilians%20is%20completely%20prohibited.

Look at their crime rates
Eritria

Eritrean forces have carried out large-scale massacres, summary executions, widespread sexual violence including rape, gang rape, and sexual slavery, widespread pillage, attacks on refugee camps, and destruction and pillaging of crops.
https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2022/country-chapters/eritrea#:~:text=Eritrean%20forces%20have%20carried%20out,destruction%20and%20pillaging%20of%20crops.

Do you want to live in cambodia?
Let's be honest you are armcharing theories which in practical world do not apply.

This post was edited by addone on Jul 3 2022 08:13pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev123459Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll