d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > China / Taiwan
Prev1234513Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Jul 29 2022 12:00pm
Quote (ownyaah @ 29 Jul 2022 22:55)
Taiwan an island of 20 million, close to china, with a significant 5th column is going to stand against a 1.4 billion population super power with a GDP of 15billion.

This topic is 100% legit. Too many people have brains fried by marvel movies. China will either take taiwan by force, or the 1000% more likely outcome that they do it through soft power and diplomacy over the coming decades.. China is an economical powerhouse, it doesn't need to fight wars to get what it wants.

US shouldn't really force the issue and turn it into a war, because there is no scenario where that tiny island stands up to 1.4 billion. It is far preferable for everyone involved that they just let it be absorbed peacefully


Taiwan is a core issue for China. For the United States it is a peripheral issue.
The only reason why a war will get triggered comes mainly from the USA.
There are good reasons to trigger it, they want a similar situation to happen to China like how it did to Russia.
And militarily, USA can really test out how far the Chinese have advanced to gauge their competence without losing their precious lives.

The USA will probably fight till every last Taiwanese and Japanese just to slow down China's development for at least 30 to 40 years.
Member
Posts: 23,947
Joined: Jul 15 2008
Gold: 122,361.69
Jul 29 2022 12:14pm
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Jul 29 2022 08:00pm)
Taiwan is a core issue for China. For the United States it is a peripheral issue.
The only reason why a war will get triggered comes mainly from the USA.
There are good reasons to trigger it, they want a similar situation to happen to China like how it did to Russia.
And militarily, USA can really test out how far the Chinese have advanced to gauge their competence without losing their precious lives.

The USA will probably fight till every last Taiwanese and Japanese just to slow down China's development for at least 30 to 40 years.


Personally i think taiwan will be absorbed slowly, i think the sword-rattling isn't really gonna play out. I could be wrong though

Also no japanese is gonna die for taiwan, that take is a bit silly, but otherwise i agree with you

This post was edited by ownyaah on Jul 29 2022 12:15pm
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Jul 29 2022 12:23pm
Quote (ownyaah @ 30 Jul 2022 02:14)
Personally i think taiwan will be absorbed slowly, i think the sword-rattling isn't really gonna play out. I could be wrong though

Also no japanese is gonna die for taiwan, that take is a bit silly, but otherwise i agree with you


Part of the Reason why Pelosi is going or wanting to go to Taiwan is because she will not continue as her current role anymore.
Furthermore there is a chance that Democrats will lose the House and Senate.

So she needs to go on a world tour and go out with a bang.
Throughout her time in politics in the United States, she is very very anti china. For a woman she does have some balls so as to speak.

She did this in China 31 years ago on China's soil.
If she does goes to Taiwan, this will seal her legacy.

And if she does goes to Taiwan this coming month, it will trigger some sort of reaction from China.

https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/28/pelosi-china-taiwan-00048352

As for the Japanese part, the government have already put pressure on themselves that they will help. If they don't , it will look really bad.
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Jul 29 2022 12:47pm
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Jul 29 2022 02:00pm)
Taiwan is a core issue for China. For the United States it is a peripheral issue.
The only reason why a war will get triggered comes mainly from the USA.
There are good reasons to trigger it, they want a similar situation to happen to China like how it did to Russia.
And militarily, USA can really test out how far the Chinese have advanced to gauge their competence without losing their precious lives.

The USA will probably fight till every last Taiwanese and Japanese just to slow down China's development for at least 30 to 40 years.


Taiwan is a core issue for both the United States and Japan. The loss of Taiwan cuts through the first island chain, which threatens America's ability to come to the defense of Japan, and puts both Okinawa and the Japanese home islands at risk. It would simultaneously allow China unrestricted access to the Pacific, and threaten America's access to the same. Given the enormous economic and strategic importance of both Japan and Pacific trade, the United States is not in a position where it feels that it can allow that to happen. For its part, Japan cannot risk losing Taiwan, as it jeopardizes national security, both directly and indirectly through economic blockade.

If a conflict were to break out tomorrow, Chinese nationalism will probably be the reason why. The CCP needed Han nationalism to replace defunct communist ideology, but it's a fire that's easier to start than to put out.

Quote (ownyaah @ Jul 29 2022 10:55am)
Taiwan an island of 20 million, close to china, with a significant 5th column is going to stand against a 1.4 billion population super power with a GDP of 15billion.

This topic is 100% legit. Too many people have brains fried by marvel movies. China will either take taiwan by force, or the 1000% more likely outcome that they do it through soft power and diplomacy over the coming decades.. China is an economical powerhouse, it doesn't need to fight wars to get what it wants.

US shouldn't really force the issue and turn it into a war, because there is no scenario where that tiny island stands up to 1.4 billion. It is far preferable for everyone involved that they just let it be absorbed peacefully


The multi-decade trend has been pro-independence. The Taiwanese increasingly see themselves as belonging to a different nationality, and this trend is likely to continue as the old guard continue to die out. Unsurprisingly, CCP totalitarianism doesn't look so great from the outside.

China would certainly defeat Taiwan in an armed conflict, but seizing the island would represent the largest naval invasion in history, and almost certainly involve the immediate intercession of both the Americans and the Japanese on the side of Taiwan. The voices calling for armed NATO intervention in Ukraine, a country of very limited significance to world affairs, the invasion of Taiwan would be seismic in scope.

This post was edited by bogie160 on Jul 29 2022 12:52pm
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Jul 29 2022 12:54pm
Quote (bogie160 @ 30 Jul 2022 02:47)
Taiwan is a core issue for both the United States and Japan. The loss of Taiwan cuts through the first island chain, which threatens America's ability to come to the defense of Japan, and puts both Okinawa and the Japanese home islands at risk. It would simultaneously allow China unrestricted access to the Pacific, and threaten America's access to the same. Given the enormous economic and strategic importance of both Japan and Pacific trade, the United States is not in a position where it feels that it can allow that to happen. For its part, Japan cannot risk losing Taiwan, as it jeopardizes national security, both directly and indirectly through economic blockade.

If a conflict were to break out tomorrow, Chinese nationalism will probably be the reason why. The CCP needed Han nationalism to replace defunct communism ideology, but it's a fire that's easier to start than to put out.


I take some of the comments my late Prime Minister say on the world stage quite a fair bit.

Scroll to 11.20 if you want to hear about his views on Taiwan and China.




This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Jul 29 2022 12:55pm
Member
Posts: 28,878
Joined: Aug 11 2013
Gold: 10,712.00
Jul 29 2022 12:56pm
People seriously underestimate how difficult it is to invade an island in the modern age. It would be a complete nightmare for China and considering Taiwan would expect and has prepared for an amphibious type invasion for decades, China would legit lose hundreds of thousands of troops.

They will choke out Taiwan economically and eventually force them into the fold imo.
Member
Posts: 45,719
Joined: Aug 25 2008
Gold: 40,130.00
Jul 29 2022 01:01pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ 30 Jul 2022 02:56)
People seriously underestimate how difficult it is to invade an island in the modern age. It would be a complete nightmare for China and considering Taiwan would expect and has prepared for an amphibious type invasion for decades, China would legit lose hundreds of thousands of troops.

They will choke out Taiwan economically and eventually force them into the fold imo.


I can say with 90% certainty that China will not invade Taiwan mainland. Not going to happen.

By the Way, I think Pelosi will visit Taiwan, for a couple of hours but not stay over night.

This post was edited by Hamsterbaby on Jul 29 2022 01:09pm
Member
Posts: 34,649
Joined: Jul 2 2007
Gold: 273.37
Jul 29 2022 02:21pm
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Jul 29 2022 02:54pm)
I take some of the comments my late Prime Minister say on the world stage quite a fair bit.

Scroll to 11.20 if you want to hear about his views on Taiwan and China.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_gr3dtBaic


LKY is probably the single most talented leader of the 20th century, but in this case the material circumstances have changed. The rapprochement that began with Nixon has ended. The Chinese economy is slowing, the signs of which predate the pandemic. The tech sector is being clamped down on, and a gargantuan property bubble is roiling beneath the surface. In 2013, it was a fait accompli that the Chinese economy would eventually (and quickly) surpass that of the United States. That's no longer the case. The Chinese demographic crisis creates a window of opportunity in which China must act, and the question is whether their economic and military capabilities will be sufficient to act before that window closes.
Member
Posts: 92,973
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Jul 29 2022 02:30pm
FUCK CHINA
Member
Posts: 23,970
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,554.14
Warn: 10%
Jul 29 2022 02:32pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Jul 29 2022 03:30pm)
FUCK CHINA


Yu no rike crab rangoon?
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1234513Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll