Quote (Thor123422 @ Jul 6 2020 01:20pm)
I agree that automation exacerbated the problem, my contention was specifically saying that private charity filled the gaps pre-1980 when federal programs were the main thing that filled the gap at that time.
your assertion has 2 issues that i can see as glaring:
1. pre 1980 programs were shit, and you're referencing them as filling gaps when in reality they were shit.
2. you aren't including the church in mental health issues, when counseling in the church has been done forever. marital counseling, substance abuse, etc. shit, AA itself is a christian organization.
the church is the private charity organization that facilitated nearly all of the help in the era im referencing. try to plug your nose and realize that the church has been feeding, clothing, and counseling people for hundreds of years in the US. since before food stamps were a thing, before programs existed to give kids clothes like coats for kids, since before public counseling existed in schools, before asylums existed in the public realm churches ran them, etc.
but, and this is my point, we're now in a place where the church definitely cant solve this, going directly against libertarian doctrine that we can fix it privately. and also that the federal govt will not fix it in the long run either, due to the problem getting worse year after year and the inability to convince the population that it should be done. basically, poor people are fucked, and only used to be kind of fucked.