Quote (Sioux @ 4 Oct 2023 20:34)
Paul Ryan couldn't control the freedom caucus in 2016 either with a GOP trifecta. It didn't fall apart as spectacularly as McCarthy this year, but this is a systemic GOP issue, not a 2022 congress issue.
Paul Ryan and the freedom caucus had very different policy agendas, so it's not surprising they butted heads.
I already replied to the systemic factors underlying the troubles of GOP leadership to control their caucus last page:
Quote (Black XistenZ @ 4 Oct 2023 18:00)
On a broader note, this difference in leadership difficulty/caucus cohesion between Democrats and Republicans is caused by a fundamental asymmetry between the two parties: Democrats have a large set of shared ideological positions, virtually all of them agree on the general direction in which they want to steer the country. Their disagreement largely comes down to how far and how quick they want to go down this path. Republicans, on the other hand, have much deeper ideological divisions within their ranks, the direction Trump or Gaetz want is very different from the direction a Romney or a McConnell want.
Additionally, Republicans generally want to reduce the scope of (the federal) government, so they're rather happy with obstruction and gridlock. By contrast, Democrats want to proactively pass legislation, want the government to shape and change the status quo. This shared goal means that neither mainstream liberals nor hardcore progressives have an interest in obstruction.