Quote (Thor123422 @ Nov 20 2020 01:54am)
The "who pays for it" argument is dumb because those programs are net positives. Having a safety net allows people to take risks. Education allows people to be more productive and competitive. The answer to who pays for it is everybody, and everybody reaps the rewards as well.
Well I wouldn't exactly call the argument "dumb," any argument with a degree of validity isn't.
"Everybody" in the "who pays for it" section of your argument, must apply to individuals' taxes/being taxed. (Correct me here if I'm wrong)
Just the same as the individuals that pay for the food stamps in my example? I've been on both sides of this personally; they were a life safer when I got sick, lost my job, apartment, gf at the time, etc and was eventually in a homeless shelter. But I made the choice to utilize those tools and move beyond. I've also partaken of steak/shrimp/beef jerky along the way from individuals who had every desire to abuse and milk the system. (Yes I am admitting all my failures here)
Leading up to the point, that yes, I agree with you that everyone can benefit collectively/as a society from both these two tools mentioned (food stamps and maybe someday free, post-high school education) but there are gonna be many that abuse it, that "we" pay for along the way. Only it may not be us, but our children. I don't want to put more taxes and burden on my kids than I have to.
It all boils down to responsibility. We want to free ourselves of the responsibility of our college debts, I'm right there with ya. But I can't have that free(dom) without someone else gifting it to me. On their sweat and blood. And idk, I just don't want to ask anymore of my fellow Americans above what they've already given for me. (Which I already can't repay)
Hope some of that made sense, it is getting late but I have enjoyed talking with you Thor 😁