d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > October Invasion Of Israel
Prev11701711721731741646Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Oct 13 2023 07:35pm
Quote (sirthom @ Oct 13 2023 06:33pm)
Sorry for double post. :P


:P

This post was edited by JessiWan on Oct 13 2023 07:36pm
Member
Posts: 3,908
Joined: Jun 20 2022
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Oct 13 2023 07:56pm
I was playing gta4 yesterday and I walked into the Internet cafe and every single npc was the old Jewish man who complains about his commute.
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Oct 13 2023 07:59pm
Quote (AleKsRoBerto @ Oct 13 2023 05:49pm)
If we go by what the Torah says, the Jewish people got some help from god and the Canaanites were destroyed. Anyone with a brain realizes the Jews probably murdered those people because there is no god.


If you think Jews are murderers, why do you still love them so much.
Member
Posts: 50,765
Joined: Jan 20 2010
Gold: 5,846.00
Oct 13 2023 08:11pm
Quote (Hamsterbaby @ Oct 13 2023 07:57pm)
Minefields is a no no. If DMZ is to be established, you will need a coalition of forces from UN to keep Peace like North South Korea. If the West with US leading are the ones that are keeping peace the Islamic World will not accept it.


What kind of DMZ can be enforced without manpower not available to Israel that would actually hold back a Hamas raid like this one, without minefields?
The thing about minefields is that they aren't barbaric if nobody actually goes into them.

Quote (ofthevoid @ Oct 13 2023 08:03pm)
Giving it the bubble boy treatment still doesn't solve for Hamas though, and based on what they are saying they are looking to completely dismantle them, with only real way is going in with boots on the ground.


But look at it from a practical point of view. Hamas can't actually be destroyed. Israel can go cull some of the leadership and their weapons caches and blow up building and have a big cathartic stompdown and then what? There will still be millions of Palestinians in Gaza, they will still be millions radicalized against Israel and supportive of Islamic Jihad / Hamas, and no other country will take them in. Israel isn't going to commit a genocide and wipe them all out, so where does that leave them when this is done?

Until now Israel has gone for that bubble boy treatment of soft containment. They relied upon a flimsy border with automated surveillance and interceptor missiles because they believed the threat to them was small incursions by single terrorist cells and a bunch of impotent rockets. Hamas committed a massive cross border raid that first knocked out all their automated systems and communications and then flooded the area with overwhelming manpower. They used Israeli highways to move their mechanized troops rapidly. Nothing about the status quo ante can possibly fend off that kind of attack, nor can they avoid future attacks of the same kind if all they do is pulverize Hamas and leave Gaza highly populated.

But look at Korea and Sudan and Ukraine. Look at what a DMZ can do when its heavily fortified, filled with mines, layered defenses, a no-mans-land with shoot to kill orders. Paragliders wouldn't stand a chance, raiders wouldn't be able to simply break a hole in a chain link fence and stream across a border like they're mexicans and then massacre people like they're mongols. They'd just be a bunch of corpses and vehicles stranded in a minefield and left to rot.


I maintain, this is the only logical outcome that satisfies the conditions. What's Israel's endgame, otherwise? If all they do is go blow up a stretch of Gaza like Cast Lead 2.0 then their best case scenario is they suppress Hamas for a few years- even months- before they've rearmed, smuggled enough weapons and materials to pose the thread of more raids. What do they actually need to carry out attacks like we just saw? Civilian vehicles. Light arms. Knives. RPGs and grenades and drones to take out a garrison and responders, and then cover it by launching their usual barrage of missiles. There's no way you can hold back that kind of armament with a blockade, because they were already doing it.
Israel has the capability to basically neutralize the Palestinian danger at range. Missiles don't do shit against the Iron Dome / David's Sling / etc. A couple people dead for every 100,000 missiles launched. Meanwhile a few unwashed barbarians with AK-47s break across your border and they can kill a dozen helpless jews each.


This will end with a DMZ, and probably an actual honest to god minefield around the whole perimeter
Member
Posts: 13,313
Joined: May 20 2004
Gold: 253.00
Oct 13 2023 08:12pm
IDF is putting on an air show tonight!
Member
Posts: 534
Joined: Nov 15 2014
Gold: 413.69
Oct 13 2023 08:13pm
Quote (ofthevoid @ Oct 13 2023 05:40pm)
Probably as a result of the unprecedented brutality we seen last Saturday. Murdering babies?


what the hell are you talking about? America and the West does something a ZILLION times worse than murder babies. the West mutilates the sex organs of little kids in gender reassignment surgery. American and Western courts protect the surgery action from caring and loving fathers who take them to court to try to protect their babies. A least a murder is a clean death. the West horribly destroys a child's body before they are old enough to make such decisions and leave them to grow up and live with it, knowing full well they may regret it and have to live for 50 years with the shame and trauma. Because of that, places like Russia and Palestine view America and the West as the barbarian animals. If only there was a fraction of the outrage over this in the West as there is what Hamas did.



https://www.youtube.com/shorts/JWMG8tIyEL0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7FRUDwDmkm0
Member
Posts: 8,130
Joined: Nov 16 2009
Gold: 58,608.00
Warn: 40%
Oct 13 2023 08:24pm
Quote (JessiWan @ Oct 13 2023 06:59pm)
If you think Jews are murderers, why do you still love them so much.


I’m not one of those love everyone types. I’m about principles. I want people to acknowledge facts and history. Plenty of Jews disagree with the way the Israeli government has handled all of this. I’d argue they are victims in all of this also, same as the Palestinians that aren’t extremist Hamas members.
Member
Posts: 34,186
Joined: May 25 2007
Gold: 21.00
Warn: 10%
Oct 13 2023 08:26pm
Quote (Goomshill @ Oct 13 2023 07:11pm)
What kind of DMZ can be enforced without manpower not available to Israel that would actually hold back a Hamas raid like this one, without minefields?
The thing about minefields is that they aren't barbaric if nobody actually goes into them.



But look at it from a practical point of view. Hamas can't actually be destroyed. Israel can go cull some of the leadership and their weapons caches and blow up building and have a big cathartic stompdown and then what? There will still be millions of Palestinians in Gaza, they will still be millions radicalized against Israel and supportive of Islamic Jihad / Hamas, and no other country will take them in. Israel isn't going to commit a genocide and wipe them all out, so where does that leave them when this is done?

Until now Israel has gone for that bubble boy treatment of soft containment. They relied upon a flimsy border with automated surveillance and interceptor missiles because they believed the threat to them was small incursions by single terrorist cells and a bunch of impotent rockets. Hamas committed a massive cross border raid that first knocked out all their automated systems and communications and then flooded the area with overwhelming manpower. They used Israeli highways to move their mechanized troops rapidly. Nothing about the status quo ante can possibly fend off that kind of attack, nor can they avoid future attacks of the same kind if all they do is pulverize Hamas and leave Gaza highly populated.

But look at Korea and Sudan and Ukraine. Look at what a DMZ can do when its heavily fortified, filled with mines, layered defenses, a no-mans-land with shoot to kill orders. Paragliders wouldn't stand a chance, raiders wouldn't be able to simply break a hole in a chain link fence and stream across a border like they're mexicans and then massacre people like they're mongols. They'd just be a bunch of corpses and vehicles stranded in a minefield and left to rot.


I maintain, this is the only logical outcome that satisfies the conditions. What's Israel's endgame, otherwise? If all they do is go blow up a stretch of Gaza like Cast Lead 2.0 then their best case scenario is they suppress Hamas for a few years- even months- before they've rearmed, smuggled enough weapons and materials to pose the thread of more raids. What do they actually need to carry out attacks like we just saw? Civilian vehicles. Light arms. Knives. RPGs and grenades and drones to take out a garrison and responders, and then cover it by launching their usual barrage of missiles. There's no way you can hold back that kind of armament with a blockade, because they were already doing it.
Israel has the capability to basically neutralize the Palestinian danger at range. Missiles don't do shit against the Iron Dome / David's Sling / etc. A couple people dead for every 100,000 missiles launched. Meanwhile a few unwashed barbarians with AK-47s break across your border and they can kill a dozen helpless jews each.


This will end with a DMZ, and probably an actual honest to god minefield around the whole perimeter


DMZ is an extremely weak half measure.

Ethnic cleansing and re-settlement and development is the only real option for long term peace in the area
Member
Posts: 23,970
Joined: Feb 28 2007
Gold: 35,554.14
Warn: 10%
Oct 13 2023 08:34pm
Quote (Kuggergug @ Oct 13 2023 09:13pm)
what the hell are you talking about? America and the West does something a ZILLION times worse than murder babies. the West mutilates the sex organs of little kids in gender reassignment surgery. American and Western courts protect the surgery action from caring and loving fathers who take them to court to try to protect their babies. A least a murder is a clean death. the West horribly destroys a child's body before they are old enough to make such decisions and leave them to grow up and live with it, knowing full well they may regret it and have to live for 50 years with the shame and trauma. Because of that, places like Russia and Palestine view America and the West as the barbarian animals. If only there was a fraction of the outrage over this in the West as there is what Hamas did.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DN_WpaAgS6w

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/JWMG8tIyEL0

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7FRUDwDmkm0


:hail:
Member
Posts: 70,681
Joined: Nov 28 2007
Gold: 3,622.67
Oct 13 2023 08:39pm
the 24 hours is almost up
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev11701711721731741646Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll