Quote (dro94 @ 24 Jul 2024 20:44)
I'm not an expert on American politics so correct me if I'm wrong, but don't typically red states have a lower number of voters and are overweighted in electoral college votes, so if there's a poll where it's close e.g. Harris 44% Trump 42%, with that represented in the actual election then Trump would still probably win the race?
Turnout variations between states aren't that dramatic. Nor is the overweighting of small rural states in the Electoral College.
What primarily drives the Trump-era edge of Republicans in the EC is the winner take all system in which Democrats are not rewarded with extra electoral votes if they win deep-blue coastal states like California or New York by stalinesque margins.
An interesting way to illustrate this was done in the NYT. In 2019, they looked at the results from the 2016 presidential election on the most granular level available, the level of voting precincts (generally a few blocks of houses):

The finding was that while Hillary received almost 3 million more votes than Trump, a majority of Americans lived in precincts won by Trump.
The red bars in this chart add up higher than the blue bars, but the center of mass of this chart lies in the blue region.
The tldr with regard to 2024 is that Trump most definitely still enjoys a significant advantage in the electoral college; if the national popular vote is tied, Trump should be a 60:40 to 75:25 favorite.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Jul 24 2024 03:51pm