d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Another Day In America
Prev11617181920Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 34,186
Joined: May 25 2007
Gold: 21.00
Warn: 10%
May 9 2023 01:02pm
Quote (thesnipa @ May 9 2023 11:59am)
how would you define "nazi ideology" if not as i described above? (take over world, kill ze juden)

unless we're saying the Azov Battalion has aspirations to take the globe and start a 4th Reich but just lacks the resources.


You could do your own research on the Nazi ideology, I'm not an expert but I've read alot - its the same ideology, descendants of Hyperborea, Esoteric Gnosticism etc etc... there is alot of unpack and it cannot be described simply as "kill the jews"
Member
Posts: 92,959
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
May 9 2023 01:08pm
Quote (El1te @ May 9 2023 02:02pm)
You could do your own research on the Nazi ideology, I'm not an expert but I've read alot - its the same ideology, descendants of Hyperborea, Esoteric Gnosticism etc etc... there is alot of unpack and it cannot be described simply as "kill the jews"


i've done a lot of research, but you're skirting the basic question.

to lay it out: you and i can differ on what we think a "Nazi" really is in the modern context. that's fine. but is it possible to come to a common ground about what a "problematic Nazi" is, in the context of Nazi aims? can we agree that the Azogs are neither trying to take over the globe nor genocide jews?

if so what we're left with is calling cooked noodles "spaghetti". no sauce, no meat, just wet noodles on a plate.
Member
Posts: 38,137
Joined: May 28 2006
Gold: 0.00
May 9 2023 01:11pm
Quote (YeeHaw @ May 9 2023 09:42pm)
Why do you bother quoting me with your moronic replies. The man is a Hispanic.

This is a fact.

The collage of pictures were obtained from some obscure Russian social media page.

This is a fact.


I did literally nothing but state two of very few facts about this man.


Besides bulk of the pictures have been exposed to not even be his

They are confirmed to be years old, from different countries, and hosted on a leftist reddit page (now deleted ofcourse to not break the fake narrative but screenshots below) :

https://twitter.com/stillgray/status/1655670726182191105

considering the fresh tattoos, looks more and more as a leftist taking one for the team

This post was edited by HeLiCaL on May 9 2023 01:12pm
Member
Posts: 34,186
Joined: May 25 2007
Gold: 21.00
Warn: 10%
May 9 2023 01:20pm
Quote (thesnipa @ May 9 2023 12:08pm)
i've done a lot of research, but you're skirting the basic question.

to lay it out: you and i can differ on what we think a "Nazi" really is in the modern context. that's fine. but is it possible to come to a common ground about what a "problematic Nazi" is, in the context of Nazi aims? can we agree that the Azogs are neither trying to take over the globe nor genocide jews?

if so what we're left with is calling cooked noodles "spaghetti". no sauce, no meat, just wet noodles on a plate.


I think we are thinking about two different ideas so theres a misunderstanding, I'm not reading pretty deep typing pretty fast atm

In the context of Nazi aims I don't think there's a big concern here for the Ukrainian Nazis. In my eyes, its more than the Nazis historically committed so many crimes against Russia that they have the moral right to eradicate such ideology even if it is not a direct threat (though I'm sure they believe it is a very real direct threat that a NATO-backed Ukraine could launch an invasion of Russia)
Member
Posts: 92,959
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
May 9 2023 01:26pm
Quote (El1te @ May 9 2023 02:20pm)
I think we are thinking about two different ideas so theres a misunderstanding, I'm not reading pretty deep typing pretty fast atm

In the context of Nazi aims I don't think there's a big concern here for the Ukrainian Nazis. In my eyes, its more than the Nazis historically committed so many crimes against Russia that they have the moral right to eradicate such ideology even if it is not a direct threat (though I'm sure they believe it is a very real direct threat that a NATO-backed Ukraine could launch an invasion of Russia)


to me the conversation goes like this:

A: "should we arm ukraine?"

B: "well no, they're LITERAL NAZIS"

A: "so will they do nazi stuff with the guns?"

B: "whats nazi stuff"

A: "you know, killing jews and gypsies, taking over the whole globe, viewing all nonwhites as the next targets for genocide, that stuff"

B:"well no, but they have a nazi flag"


as i said im not for arming ukraine, and i dont like phony nazis, but them being nazis is such a low prio issue its not worth mentioning. there's 10 better reasons to be against arming ukraine.
Member
Posts: 34,186
Joined: May 25 2007
Gold: 21.00
Warn: 10%
May 9 2023 01:31pm
Quote (thesnipa @ May 9 2023 12:26pm)
to me the conversation goes like this:

A: "should we arm ukraine?"

B: "well no, they're LITERAL NAZIS"

A: "so will they do nazi stuff with the guns?"

B: "whats nazi stuff"

A: "you know, killing jews and gypsies, taking over the whole globe, viewing all nonwhites as the next targets for genocide, that stuff"

B:"well no, but they have a nazi flag"


as i said im not for arming ukraine, and i dont like phony nazis, but them being nazis is such a low prio issue its not worth mentioning. there's 10 better reasons to be against arming ukraine.


They do do some nazi stuff with the weapons though. They are notorious for committing war crimes in the Donbas region since the war started in 2015.
Member
Posts: 92,959
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
May 9 2023 01:37pm
Quote (El1te @ May 9 2023 02:31pm)
They do do some nazi stuff with the weapons though. They are notorious for committing war crimes in the Donbas region since the war started in 2015.


not all rectangles are squares. "war crimes" being a tag for "nazi" is way too loose. war crimes are sadly way too common for all armies, thus is the nature of warfare in populated regions.

we've now shifted from "nazi ideology" to "what stuff do they do that nazis did too". im sure some enjoy a stout beer, busty blonde, and wurtz in kraut as well.
Member
Posts: 34,186
Joined: May 25 2007
Gold: 21.00
Warn: 10%
May 9 2023 01:41pm
Quote (thesnipa @ May 9 2023 12:37pm)
not all rectangles are squares. "war crimes" being a tag for "nazi" is way too loose. war crimes are sadly way too common for all armies, thus is the nature of warfare in populated regions.

we've now shifted from "nazi ideology" to "what stuff do they do that nazis did too". im sure some enjoy a stout beer, busty blonde, and wurtz in kraut as well.


I agree that war crimes are certainly not specific to nazis, of course Russia has also committed and are currently committing war crimes - but in my opinion, this means that we should not be supporting either side. Which we both agree on, so it is still legitimate to say we should not be supporting Ukraine because of this
Member
Posts: 9,899
Joined: May 7 2006
Gold: 550.00
May 9 2023 01:46pm
Quote (YeeHaw @ May 9 2023 11:42am)
Why do you bother quoting me with your moronic replies. The man is a Hispanic.

This is a fact.

The collage of pictures were obtained from some obscure Russian social media page.

This is a fact.


I did literally nothing but state two of very few facts about this man.


Lol

This post was edited by Sioux on May 9 2023 01:47pm
Member
Posts: 15,802
Joined: Jul 31 2006
Gold: 24.06
May 9 2023 02:00pm
Quote (thesnipa @ May 9 2023 01:26pm)
to me the conversation goes like this:

A: "should we arm ukraine?"

B: "well no, they're LITERAL NAZIS"

A: "so will they do nazi stuff with the guns?"

B: "whats nazi stuff"

A: "you know, killing jews and gypsies, taking over the whole globe, viewing all nonwhites as the next targets for genocide, that stuff"

B:"well no, but they have a nazi flag"


as i said im not for arming ukraine, and i dont like phony nazis, but them being nazis is such a low prio issue its not worth mentioning. there's 10 better reasons to be against arming ukraine.


Nazi has been redefined by the left. It’s quite prudent to not dead name in this sense.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev11617181920Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll