d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Christianity Is Obviously Fake
Prev1162163164165166274Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 54,735
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Apr 6 2026 01:59am
You would find you didn't disprove the meme just said it was dumb and ended talking about Rome and Carthage.



So your particular god not the 1000's of other gods. Congratulations you are back on the special pleading wheel of preference/opinion


it is not special pleading as there is no other worldview that fits

it is the impossibility of the contrary
Member
Posts: 54,735
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Apr 6 2026 02:01am
Dumbest memes yet, which is impressive.

"Sin is a myth. The concept of sin was created as a recruitment method to get you to join an immoral religious organization[...]"

lol how is the religious organization immoral if sin does not exist? Moral relativism evaporates the moment you look at it.


it's smuggling in metaphysical categories and using concepts like 'good' or 'bad' without a justification of goodness. it's completely loaded with baggage it cannot justify at all, it's atheism in a nutshell truly. borrow from theism completely to justify all transcendental categories and then decide to deny the worldview that explains all of their conclusions. it's wild

"I’ve simply evolved past the need for my premises to actually support my conclusions."
Member
Posts: 16,015
Joined: Dec 27 2019
Gold: 69.69
Apr 6 2026 02:08am
it is not special pleading as there is no other worldview that fits

it is the impossibility of the contrary


You forgot to add "in my very limited opinion"

If you going to throw around statements like "no other worldview that fits" impossibility of the contrary" then yoou better have an explanation of what that actually means and proof to back it up.
Since you didn't, we are going to chalk it up to confidently ignorant.
Member
Posts: 54,735
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Apr 6 2026 02:10am
You forgot to add "in my very limited opinion"

If you going to throw around statements like "no other worldview that fits" impossibility of the contrary" then yoou better have an explanation of what that actually means and proof to back it up.
Since you didn't, we are going to chalk it up to confidently ignorant.


provide a worldview or religion that coherently grounds the transcendental categories or the necessary preconditions for logic and I will completely dismantle it. make an argument
Member
Posts: 16,015
Joined: Dec 27 2019
Gold: 69.69
Apr 6 2026 02:19am
provide a worldview or religion that coherently grounds the transcendental categories or the necessary preconditions for logic and I will completely dismantle it. make an argument


Wtf is transcendental categories? This isn't an episode of Jeopardy.
What does this have to do with my question? First explain what you mean by no worldview that fits, then provide proof or at least reasoning that isn't based on more assumptions.
Member
Posts: 54,735
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Apr 6 2026 02:29am
Wtf is transcendental categories? This isn't an episode of Jeopardy.
What does this have to do with my question? First explain what you mean by no worldview that fits, then provide proof or at least reasoning that isn't based on more assumptions.


these are basic philosophical concepts, you ever read a book on philosophy? being confused isn't an argument

you said 1000s of gods ground morality (a transcendental category) so I said provide a worldview or religion that coherently grounds transcendental categories or the necessary preconditions for logic as a direct challenge.

provide a worldview or religion, and explain how it grounds these categories, and I will dismantle your entire argument, provide the positive case for Christianity, and show the impossibility of the contrary.
Member
Posts: 46,831
Joined: Sep 5 2016
Gold: 100.00
Apr 6 2026 02:54am
I don't believe in that story remember also I didn't ask anyone to sacrifice himself for me and be in debt for eternity.
I suppose its no surprise when christians plagiarized about 75% of the bible from judaism that they started appropriating pagan celebrations also.




Ofc you don't care thats what hypocrite and a phony would say. If you really believed in the commandments of Christianity you wouldn't be celebrating a pagan holiday with chocolate eggs and easter bunnies.



What does having a family dinner whenever you want have to do with magic jesus being real?


"...hypocrite and a phony ..." dont get all mad because fake argument about what the catholic church did hundreds of years ago and on the other side of the world.

took a magic bunny holliday made it about Jesus addones mad. "you leave those magic bunnys alone"
Member
Posts: 54,735
Joined: Jun 5 2006
Gold: 7.83
Apr 6 2026 03:07am
"...hypocrite and a phony ..." dont get all mad because fake argument about what the catholic church did hundreds of years ago and on the other side of the world.

took a magic bunny holliday made it about Jesus addones mad. "you leave those magic bunnys alone"


Pascha is the holiday, and it is this coming Sunday. It is the most important holiday in Christianity, the resurrection. All of the Easter bunny stuff is irrelevant.

Pascha is found in the old testament Passover, which is a pointer or a type to come fulfilled in Christ. Like the entire purpose of old testament, to point to Christ.
Member
Posts: 46,831
Joined: Sep 5 2016
Gold: 100.00
Apr 6 2026 03:10am
Pascha is the holiday, and it is this coming Sunday. It is the most important holiday in Christianity, the resurrection. All of the Easter bunny stuff is irrelevant.

Pascha is found in the old testament Passover, which is a pointer or a type to come fulfilled in Christ. Like the entire purpose of old testament, to point to Christ.


:)
Member
Posts: 16,015
Joined: Dec 27 2019
Gold: 69.69
Apr 6 2026 04:18am
these are basic philosophical concepts, you ever read a book on philosophy? being confused isn't an argument

you said 1000s of gods ground morality (a transcendental category) so I said provide a worldview or religion that coherently grounds transcendental categories or the necessary preconditions for logic as a direct challenge.

provide a worldview or religion, and explain how it grounds these categories, and I will dismantle your entire argument, provide the positive case for Christianity, and show the impossibility of the contrary.


You really itching to talk about ontological rocks aren't you? I pointed out a contradiction of your argument not an affirmation that any of them ground morality.

Shifting the burden of proof isn't going to save you from your my question. You have to prove how this god grounds morality not just say that he/she does. Then you have to disprove how other gods can't.

You assumed at least 3 things.

1.God can only explain or ground morality by ruling out all other alternatives
2. Not just a god but your very specific god that you so happen to worship.
3. In addition your own exclusive interpretation of that very specific god (because as you know there are many different bibles and christian denominations)

You are just making an overreaching and unfalsifiable argument here.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1162163164165166274Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll