d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Almost One Mass Shooting A Day In Us > .98 Per Day On Average
Prev1151617181929Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 93,001
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Nov 13 2018 10:43am
Quote (fender @ Nov 11 2018 01:43pm)
- if we want to have a SERIOUS discussion about gun violence, we will have to talk about what PERCENTAGE of gun crime is committed by democrats.

- ok, what is the percentage?

- erm, well, there is no data, but you know, like, errrr... b-b-but face validity, a-a-and there is no way to get data on criminals - because they lie...



i hope you don't actually think that's how it works, that's almost adorably naive. seriously though, you would have been better off just admitting that you were trying make a national issue somehow a partisan problem in order to create a flimsy excuses for the NRA funded party (but hey, that's just free speech and has no influence on policy at all, right?) that opposes ANY attempt to tackle the issue.

not that it made much sense to begin with because obviously you can't make policies based on party affiliation. by that 'logic' you might as well just target MEN - something that's scientifically actually supported...


ahh i see in the bold where u made your issue. i wasn't talking about a serious policy discussion, i was talking about even a general discussion. Gun Control is near taboo levels in the US, we're largely turning a blind eye because of the deep political division. we need to bridge the gap before we try and send a tank across said bridge. that starts with simple allowances of fault from both sides and a softening of rhetoric.

Policy talk requires lots of accurate stats, generally the kind of stats the left doesn't have to back up the reliability of the measures they suggest. such as how many gun crimes measures would prevent, or how many legal purchases would be effected as a result of laws, or whether its even constitutional. it's generally all emotional appeal mixed with blaming the right, the right in turn blames the left. i grew up in gun culture, and my post was an attempt to show leftists what they're up against, the mentality gap they need to bridge. hopefully after reading this you'll get it, finally, but alas i have negative hope.
Member
Posts: 33,928
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Nov 13 2018 11:45am
Quote (thesnipa @ Nov 13 2018 12:43pm)
ahh i see in the bold where u made your issue. i wasn't talking about a serious policy discussion, i was talking about even a general discussion. Gun Control is near taboo levels in the US, we're largely turning a blind eye because of the deep political division. we need to bridge the gap before we try and send a tank across said bridge. that starts with simple allowances of fault from both sides and a softening of rhetoric.

Policy talk requires lots of accurate stats, generally the kind of stats the left doesn't have to back up the reliability of the measures they suggest. such as how many gun crimes measures would prevent, or how many legal purchases would be effected as a result of laws, or whether its even constitutional. it's generally all emotional appeal mixed with blaming the right, the right in turn blames the left. i grew up in gun culture, and my post was an attempt to show leftists what they're up against, the mentality gap they need to bridge. hopefully after reading this you'll get it, finally, but alas i have negative hope.


This wont happen because of the media unfortunately.
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Nov 13 2018 11:52am
Hate crime increase by 17% in 2017 - in U.S -

I CANT IMAGINE FOR 2018
Member
Posts: 93,001
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Nov 13 2018 12:11pm
Quote (EndlessSky @ Nov 13 2018 11:45am)
This wont happen because of the media unfortunately.


i think it can happen, because of the ever shrinking number of bipartisan issues to focus on. moderate gun control is a bipartisanship issue for the populace. and the lifers in congress/senate need a small but steady supply of "what have you dont for me lately" bipartisan issues to talk about inbetween the partisan hackery. Historically the two largest hurdles have been the NRA lobbying the left/right/center to vote NO on all measures and the left creating omnibus packages that have zero chance to get passed into law rather than handling aspects of gun control on a case by case basis. well, the NRA is having very little traction with the leftist politicians (despite having convinced Fenderp that the right is the only one who takes NRA cash, even though we're not even a decade removed from leftists taking massive piles of cash), and simple reforms are gaining more traction.

tl;dr the media coverage will remain relatively the same, but congress might pass SOMETHING small in spite of that.
Member
Posts: 33,928
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Nov 13 2018 01:03pm
Quote (Saucisson6000 @ Nov 13 2018 01:52pm)
Hate crime increase by 17% in 2017 - in U.S -

I CANT IMAGINE FOR 2018



Fake hate crime increase by 300%.

Gee I wonder what is happening
Member
Posts: 1,775
Joined: Feb 2 2017
Gold: 945.00
Nov 13 2018 01:08pm
Quote (EndlessSky @ Nov 13 2018 08:03pm)
Fake hate crime increase by 300%.

Gee I wonder what is happening


I'm under the impression that crime is measured by convictions and not accusations. Excluding the "fake" hate crime.
Member
Posts: 33,928
Joined: Oct 9 2008
Gold: 2,528.52
Nov 13 2018 01:11pm
Quote (Knoppie @ Nov 13 2018 03:08pm)
I'm under the impression that crime is measured by convictions and not accusations. Excluding the "fake" hate crime.



Youre making a mistake if youre placing your faith in the intellectual faculties of french sausage here.
Member
Posts: 1,775
Joined: Feb 2 2017
Gold: 945.00
Nov 13 2018 01:14pm
Quote (EndlessSky @ Nov 13 2018 08:11pm)
Youre making a mistake if youre placing your faith in the intellectual faculties of french sausage here.


He's actually funnier than most on this forum for me. Bringing some intellectual valid points, being thrown aside by partisan citizens. Mainly with the excuse of being "French". haha lol, no argument.
Member
Posts: 93,001
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Nov 13 2018 01:20pm
Quote (Knoppie @ Nov 13 2018 01:08pm)
I'm under the impression that crime is measured by convictions and not accusations. Excluding the "fake" hate crime.


generally both are used. the UCR data measures criminal conviction, and many organizations also do polling to measure crime generally as a comparison.

Hate crimes from a conviction standpoint aren't that reliable of a metric because they're not applied in 100% of cases where they're applicable.

Hate crimes from a societal polling perspective aren't reliable either in the other direction, because you have overlaps in reporting and polls generally return excess results by their very nature.

most studies bring both stats in and give a judgement about where in the middle they think the actual numbers are.
Member
Posts: 1,775
Joined: Feb 2 2017
Gold: 945.00
Nov 13 2018 01:28pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Nov 13 2018 08:20pm)
generally both are used. the UCR data measures criminal conviction, and many organizations also do polling to measure crime generally as a comparison.

Hate crimes from a conviction standpoint aren't that reliable of a metric because they're not applied in 100% of cases where they're applicable.

Hate crimes from a societal polling perspective aren't reliable either in the other direction, because you have overlaps in reporting and polls generally return excess results by their very nature.

most studies bring both stats in and give a judgement about where in the middle they think the actual numbers are.


trying to find a middle ground with increased accusation rate resulting into increased convictions as well, while actually numbers of hate crimes committed might actually not have increased.
Seems to make one want to invest into what Samus said.

Yet for now I'll keep expecting hate crimes to increase due to polarization of US society, with a role to play for the government in it as well.
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1151617181929Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll