d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > October Invasion Of Israel
Prev11561571581591601658Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 19,250
Joined: Oct 23 2003
Gold: 7,104.95
Oct 13 2023 03:49pm
Quote (Elyran @ Oct 13 2023 02:42pm)

But Palestinians (hamas) always rejected it every single time, with the goal of cleansing the entire land of Jews. There is no negotiating.



this is completely false ! there was worldwide consensus on the two state solution and it was unilaterally agreed upon but the USA rejected it, not HAMAS. you might want to read up on the history of the area


Quote (Elyran @ Oct 13 2023 02:42pm)

So where do the Jews go if not stay in their historic homeland?


this I dont really have an answer for. the EU should have made other accommodations instead of displacing Palestinians to accommodate Jews, they honestly deserved their own nation state somewhere in Europe after what happened in WW2.
many, many of Palestinians living today are ancestors of Jews. thats one fact that makes this whole situation even more depressing....its cousins fighting cousins
Member
Posts: 30,165
Joined: Sep 10 2004
Gold: 0.00
Warn: 30%
Oct 13 2023 03:52pm
Quote (JohnnyMcCoy @ 13 Oct 2023 23:37)
never excused anything of the sort

the facts are that one side started this conflict and now they will have to deal with consequences

there are no clean wars and there is no possible response without collateral damage

that being said, there are two solutions

rise up against hamas digging up water pipes to build rockets or maybe.....just maybe dont kill jews

clearly number one is not an option, when even that kind of humanitarian crisis is not enough

almost everyone being a die hard hamas supporter is the only logical explanation


"i never excused anything" - but - "everyone is a die hard hamas supporter"

is like saying

"i never excused anything" - but - "every baby and civilian that was murdered by hamas terrorists was a die hard likud supporter, in favour of the brutal oppression of millions of people. clearly, not living in areas that were forcefully taken from palestinians and not legitimising an apartheid regime was no option for them."


again, you are ACTUALLY doing the thing you falsely accuse the other side of. oh, and stop pretending this conflict started six days ago. that's so ridiculously dishonest...

This post was edited by fender on Oct 13 2023 03:55pm
Member
Posts: 8,130
Joined: Nov 16 2009
Gold: 58,608.00
Warn: 40%
Oct 13 2023 03:54pm
Quote (Elyran @ Oct 13 2023 02:42pm)
Not all Palestinians are radicalized, and Israel was always for a 2 state solution.
But Palestinians (hamas) always rejected it every single time, with the goal of cleansing the entire land of Jews. There is no negotiating. So where do the Jews go if not stay in their historic homeland?

Why are Arab countries suddenly signing peace deals with Israel (abraham accords)?


Whatever you are smoking, i want some. The Israeli government has been against a real two state solution. They would not compensate Palestinians whose families were exiled, they would expect that the Palestinians would demilitarize, and the Palestinians would be dependent on Israeli infrastructure. With all that and if you still believe Israel was “always for a two state solution,” you should probs just stop talking about this.
Member
Posts: 8,130
Joined: Nov 16 2009
Gold: 58,608.00
Warn: 40%
Oct 13 2023 03:55pm
Quote (gnarjay @ Oct 13 2023 02:49pm)
this is completely false ! there was worldwide consensus on the two state solution and it was unilaterally agreed upon but the USA rejected it, not HAMAS. you might want to read up on the history of the area




this I dont really have an answer for. the EU should have made other accommodations instead of displacing Palestinians to accommodate Jews, they honestly deserved their own nation state somewhere in Europe after what happened in WW2.
many, many of Palestinians living today are ancestors of Jews. thats one fact that makes this whole situation even more depressing....its cousins fighting cousins


Yitzhak herzog wanted to go to Argentina cuz he saw all this shit coming decades ago!

This post was edited by AleKsRoBerto on Oct 13 2023 03:56pm
Member
Posts: 28,994
Joined: Jun 20 2007
Gold: 34.51
Oct 13 2023 03:59pm
Quote (Elyran @ Oct 13 2023 03:47pm)
Well it'd be fucking great if hamas men'd up and fought their own fight without needing to hide behind civilians -- they must have felt they stood a chance to win if they did what they did last week?
Why not fight army to army?

Israel's policy is to airstrike the exact location where rockets are fired from and where rockets are stored or manufactured
...and they all happen to be in schools, mosques, hospitals, innocent palestinian entities who are AGAINST hamas. So why make your people go through this?


That's not how terror works obviously just like when isralies stripped and slaughtered women and kids in villages, terrorism knows no bounds but as you know it's not a reflection of all its people and there's solutions that can still cause less pain for those who are just civilians.
Member
Posts: 61,718
Joined: Oct 13 2006
Gold: 550.00
Oct 13 2023 04:04pm
Quote (SBD @ Oct 13 2023 05:59pm)
That's not how terror works obviously just like when isralies stripped and slaughtered women and kids in villages, terrorism knows no bounds but as you know it's not a reflection of all its people and there's solutions that can still cause less pain for those who are just civilians.


Google "Gilad Shalit prisoner exchange" and see how many jailed and convicted terrorists Israel exchanged just for ONE soldier held hostage. I'll spare you the time - it's 1000 for 1.
Israel will do everything and anything for the security of their people, their homeland.

...and hamas KNOWS this yet still continue their tomfoolery. Why? Why expect a different outcome every time? Why attack in the first place when you KNOW things are going to get real ugly for themselves and for innocent palestinians?
Member
Posts: 22,264
Joined: Aug 17 2021
Gold: 1,546.83
Warn: 30%
Oct 13 2023 04:06pm
Quote (Elyran @ Oct 13 2023 03:04pm)

...and hamas KNOWS this yet still continue their tomfoolery. Why? Why expect a different outcome every time? Why attack in the first place when you KNOW things are going to get real ugly for themselves and for innocent palestinians?


If this is a serious question, then you should be asking Hamas themselves, not some dude on the internet.
Member
Posts: 61,718
Joined: Oct 13 2006
Gold: 550.00
Oct 13 2023 04:08pm
Quote (JessiWan @ Oct 13 2023 06:06pm)
If this is a serious question, then you should be asking Hamas themselves, not some dude on the internet.


I would but they'd behead me just for being Jewish.
Member
Posts: 28,994
Joined: Jun 20 2007
Gold: 34.51
Oct 13 2023 04:09pm
Quote (Elyran @ Oct 13 2023 04:04pm)
Google "Gilad Shalit prisoner exchange" and see how many jailed and convicted terrorists Israel exchanged just for ONE soldier held hostage. I'll spare you the time - it's 1000 for 1.
Israel will do everything and anything for the security of their people, their homeland.

...and hamas KNOWS this yet still continue their tomfoolery. Why? Why expect a different outcome every time? Why attack in the first place when you KNOW things are going to get real ugly for themselves and for innocent palestinians?


Don't mean to quote Alfred here but some people genuinely just want to watch the world burn and just like our war on terror do you think the actual terrorists saw people as their people, not a chance. Do you think the people see Hamas as their leader, no, they just don't want to be shot for saying otherwise, which is the consequences for disobedience. Just like any African country, no one actually wants whatever dictator is oppressing the, they just don't want to be hacked to death and left in the ditch for being born in the wrong country.

Member
Posts: 4,621
Joined: Jan 30 2021
Gold: 751.50
Oct 13 2023 04:11pm
Quote (fender @ Oct 13 2023 11:52pm)
"i never excused anything" - but - "everyone is a die hard hamas supporter"

is like saying

"i never excused anything" - but - "every baby and civilian that was murdered by hamas terrorists was a die hard likud supporter, in favour of the brutal oppression of millions of people. clearly, not living in areas that were forcefully taken from palestinians and not legitimising an apartheid regime was no option for them."


again, you are ACTUALLY doing the thing you falsely accuse the other side of. oh, and stop pretending this conflict started six days ago. that's so ridiculously dishonest...


not what i meant, i keep saying that the muslim massacres against jews go back all the way to the 1920s

the religion of peace just cant help it ^_^

arent you tired of defending the scum of the earth? illegal immigrant criminals, scumbag politicians, ukranian nazis, muslim jihadists

no matter what the alleged victims are doing, derp will find a big fat BUT

again fenderp, even those that never experienced the alleged israeli "occupation" while living in the west are out in the streets shouting "death to israel"

this is where your argument fails, hatred against jews in general and israel is the standard among muslims everywhere in the world

you will dodge anyway, but please tell us how the terror is the result of israels actions and at the same time there are rallies around the world by people that are not affected

entire countries not affected by israels actions send money and weapons to kill jews

they share two things, islam and its antisemitism
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev11561571581591601658Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll