Not the same thing at all. Jews didn’t just pop up here after “thousands of years.” There’s been a Jewish community here nonstop, my own family included. What changed was that in the 1900s we actually built stuff: schools, farms, hospitals, even defense groups because every time there were riots or massacres we had to protect ourselves. That’s how we were ready to form a state.

Also, after 1948 almost a million Jews got kicked out of Arab countries, most of them came here and rebuilt their lives. And yeah, five Arab armies tried to wipe us out right at the start, we won, we stayed. That’s not some “colonial return,” that’s survival and self-determination in our actual homeland.

Well then, who are these kind, peaceful people who didn't bother them for so long? Here's another example. As a Slav (such an interesting word, with a pretense to BLM even), I have a claim to Berlin, from where we were undoubtedly pushed out by the Germans over a thousand years ago. Moreover, they turned it into their capital, committed a bit of genocide, and assimilated us to taste, so there's still some non-stop community there. And if they disagree with my point of view, which is quite fair, I'll call them Hitler.

Your Berlin example doesn’t land. Berlin isn’t the root of Slav identity, but this land is the root of Jewish identity - our language, prayers, holidays, everything points here. Jews never stopped living here either.

And it’s not like we came back to some peaceful utopia. There were riots, massacres, and in 1948 five armies tried to wipe us out. We survived because we built and defended ourselves, not because we invented some fake historic claim.

Of course it is, and clearly was. Pomerania, the island of Rügen, Arkona, the sanctuary of Sventovit. They've held it for a thousand years, and that's enough; it's time to give it back. The logic is the same. And the fact that we live in Russia and Ukraine- that wasn't by choice. The Jews also lived here and returned to Israel, and we also want to go back to our roots.

, answer for your crimes, you fascist

This post was edited by Norlander on Sep 29 2025 04:33am

No, the sole and only reason you survived was from superior fire power you got illegally from the USA.
Now tell then how they used those weapons to implement Plan Dalet, in which Zionist forces attacked, conquered, and depopulated cities, villages, and territories in Mandatory Palestine in preparation for the establishment of a Jewish state.
Need a map?

We didn’t receive American weapons. At first we purchased arms from Czechoslovakia or produced our own, including armored vehicles, the Davidka mortar, and small arms. Later we advanced to manufacturing machine guns, the Uzi, the Galil, and more.

But dont let me confuse you with facts

This post was edited by Many_Names on Sep 29 2025 06:51am

You’re comparing two very different things. Slavs may have roots in multiple regions of Europe, but you’ve had continuous states, lands, and sovereignty across Russia, Ukraine, Poland, the Balkans and more. No one erased your entire homeland from history, scattered you worldwide, and then tried to keep you out when you returned.

For Jews, this land isn’t “one of many,” it’s the only homeland. Our history, faith, and identity all originate here, and even in exile Jews never stopped living here. That’s why coming back wasn’t colonialism, it was survival and restoration.

Fixed it for you

Polish rolling eyes

Not in the present days, but everything you mentioned already happened to us. Expelled from the Homeland, conquered and enslaved.

This post was edited by Norlander on Sep 29 2025 07:00am