Quote (Black XistenZ @ 9 Aug 2018 20:43)
I am a regular reader of fivethirtyeight and am well aware of all of this.
My point is the following: in 2016, most pundits expected a landslide when the facts actually pointed to a close race where trump was the underdog, but well within striking distance. In 2018, we're having the exact same situation again: the generic ballot and the margins of special elections, the turnout in primaries and so on are all pointing towards a good year for the democrats, but the variance within those different indicators is still very high.
A blue wave is possible, yes, but it's just as possible that it falls flat and the dems "only" win the house popular vote by something like 4%, which would allow the GOP to quite comfortably hold it. Just like in 2016, pundits consider the Dems taking the House all but guaranteed while they realistically are just slight favorites to take it as of today.
True. I agree with your points.
The GOP has rebounded quite nicely from last Fall and Winter. The Democrats were up around 7-10 points on generic ballot polls back then. I think the strong economy has a lot to do with the GOP rebound.
All in all I still think the Democrats will take the House, but I don't think it's gonna be by much. I don't see a "blue wave" occurring. It's also a midterm election and Democrats are less reliable voters.
The turnout will probably be higher than a normal midterm, but I predict Democrats will be disappointed given all their expectations. I actually think it's plausible for them to lose seats in the Senate. Rick Scott is currently ahead of Nelson in Florida. It's a terrible Senate map for Democrats across the board.