Quote (ampoo @ 22 Aug 2017 16:50)
of course you cant, even if most of the afghan borders are impassable anyway
basic control at the main points is good enough and at least in theory the idea is that these guys dont want to leave their little caliphate anyway
expansion and spreading the religion are major aspects of islam obviously, but other motivations like "they are bombing my country so i am bombing theirs" could go away
i wouldnt say 9/11 was a result of doing nothing in afghanistan, more like opposite if you go back further in time
soviet invasion, america arming mujahideen, being friends with bin laden etc
well, ofc a lot of the shit that's going down in afghanistan is due to the mess the cia and the soviets have caused decades ago. but the shit
has already hit the fan, now we have to deal with the fallout.
I gotta disagree with your point about "control the main border crossings and you're good". if taliban fighters can seep in across the wilderness in groups of 2 to a few dozens at once, you will still have to deal with them inside afghanistan. as long as they have space to back off, you wont get rid of this plague. their refuge is pakistan, but also tajikistan and turkmenistan. good luck getting those countries to
effectively fight against the taliban. and pakistan is a 200 mil shithole with nukes and a sizable army. even the united states cant push them around just like that. to put real pressure on pakistan, the US would have to concentrate MASSIVE amounts of troops in front of their shore. risky, no guarantee for success, extremely costly, politically no longer feasible considering how tired the american public is of the ongoing wars.
so, if you dont get pakistan to commit fully to the fight against the taliban, they will have their refuge over there whenever you kick their asses in afghanistan. you cant prevent them from coming back. the afghan public apparently is either too weak to drive them away on their own, or there is too much support for a taliban rule inside the afghan people. either way, the issue isnt going away. therefore, the best we can do is a "damage control mode" in which we try to commit as few troops and resources as possible while keeping the taliban at bay, preventing afghanistan from again becoming a safe haven for islamistic terrorists of all kind. its not the 'win' everyone was hoping for, but deployment of 8-12k soldiers to afghanistan can be sustained permanently if necessary.
This post was edited by Black XistenZ on Aug 22 2017 06:30pm