d2jsp
Log InRegister
d2jsp Forums > Off-Topic > General Chat > Political & Religious Debate > Abortion Debate 2023
Prev1131415161718Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll
Member
Posts: 33,771
Joined: May 9 2009
Gold: 3.33
Mar 8 2023 03:15pm
Quote (Handcuffs @ Mar 8 2023 09:13pm)
One is not claiming that the "baby is your body". One is claiming that the baby is inside their body, and exercising bodily autonomy by having the baby removed.


The baby being inside your body isn't really relevant when it comes to 'is this a baby or not', and if the answer is yes, you are, by definition, murdering it. It's very simple and one does not have to be religious or right wing to see it.
Member
Posts: 22,437
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 96.11
Mar 8 2023 03:18pm
Quote (dro94 @ Mar 8 2023 01:15pm)
The baby being inside your body isn't really relevant when it comes to 'is this a baby or not', and if the answer is yes, you are, by definition, murdering it. It's very simple and one does not have to be religious or right wing to see it.


I've already said that the question of "When does life begin?", which is just a different way of saying "Is this a baby or not?", is irrelevant. There are justifiable ways in which people end a life, and abortion is but one example.
Member
Posts: 33,771
Joined: May 9 2009
Gold: 3.33
Mar 8 2023 03:20pm
Quote (Handcuffs @ Mar 8 2023 09:18pm)
I've already said that the question of "When does life begin?", which is just a different way of saying "Is this a baby or not?", is irrelevant. There are justifiable ways in which people end a life, and abortion is but one example.


Convenience or economic hardship don't fit that bill
Member
Posts: 22,437
Joined: Mar 3 2007
Gold: 96.11
Mar 8 2023 03:21pm
Quote (dro94 @ Mar 8 2023 01:20pm)
Convenience or economic hardship don't fit that bill


Right, hence my posts mentioning "bodily autonomy".
Member
Posts: 92,959
Joined: Dec 31 2007
Gold: 2,299.94
Mar 8 2023 03:24pm
Quote (dro94 @ Mar 8 2023 03:07pm)
If you're pregnant, you can't just absolve yourself of responsibility and claim the baby is your body so you can kill it justifiably. It's a product of your body and the choices you've made.


when people point out that without the mother's nutrients the baby dies and seek to define "life" as a being not reliant on pumped in nutrients from another, pro lifers seeks to use a coma patient on a feeding tube as a "counter example". as if pro choice people are anything but willing to also call that person not really alive. there's also the chance that a coma patient recovers, and when recovery is impossible people can ethically pull the cord and let them die.

perhaps pro life people would be ok with a mother not aborting a child, but simply having a doctor remove it and cut the cord. then if it lives, it lives. im sure a clump of 500 cells will do just fine on a cold operating table.

This post was edited by thesnipa on Mar 8 2023 03:24pm
Member
Posts: 33,771
Joined: May 9 2009
Gold: 3.33
Mar 8 2023 03:47pm
Quote (thesnipa @ Mar 8 2023 09:24pm)
when people point out that without the mother's nutrients the baby dies and seek to define "life" as a being not reliant on pumped in nutrients from another, pro lifers seeks to use a coma patient on a feeding tube as a "counter example". as if pro choice people are anything but willing to also call that person not really alive. there's also the chance that a coma patient recovers, and when recovery is impossible people can ethically pull the cord and let them die.

perhaps pro life people would be ok with a mother not aborting a child, but simply having a doctor remove it and cut the cord. then if it lives, it lives. im sure a clump of 500 cells will do just fine on a cold operating table.


No need to overcomplicate it IMO
Member
Posts: 66,666
Joined: May 17 2005
Gold: 17,384.69
Mar 8 2023 03:51pm
the debate is sterile
Member
Posts: 4,147
Joined: Jun 30 2022
Gold: 6.42
Warn: 10%
Mar 8 2023 04:02pm
I think abortion should be legal but heavily stigmatized by society. Until a woman gives birth I see it as their right to decide what happens to themselves and by proxy, the life inside of them. That said, I think it is disgusting how some pro abortion advocates treat it as a meaningless medical procedure and I don't think it being legal should shield someone from the criticism they rightly deserve for their poor choices and poor morals.
Member
Posts: 46,978
Joined: Sep 5 2016
Gold: 100.00
Mar 8 2023 04:44pm
Quote (gnarjay @ Mar 8 2023 09:58am)
another dodge straight into a rage loop, you are too easy to predict


you havent the foggiest idea why all the fuss about jabbing citizens but never gave a rats azz what is let in at the border
Member
Posts: 46,978
Joined: Sep 5 2016
Gold: 100.00
Mar 8 2023 04:49pm
Quote (gnarjay @ Mar 8 2023 09:58am)
another dodge straight into a rage loop, you are too easy to predict


oops :)

This post was edited by TiStuff on Mar 8 2023 04:50pm
Go Back To Political & Religious Debate Topic List
Prev1131415161718Next
Add Reply New Topic New Poll