What does it take to make a true scotsman?

If a guy writes antifa messages and the lyrics to the most widely known antifa anthem, and his friends and family talk about how he became a militant leftist in recent years, and he shoots charlie kirk- what more did he need to do to make his motive obvious to you?
We had a manifest left behind by antifa gunmen before and the media tried to downplay or deny the motive.

If actually engraving his motive on the murder weapon isn't enough for you, what more is needed? Signed autotape confession with three witnesses, public notary, a police officer and his grandmother watching saying 'thats my tyler'?

R.I.P Charlie Kirk. Your wisdom and voice of reason will never be forgotten.

Keep seeing this posted and was trying to find it on the guarding but apparently the whole bit was retracted???

It is a sad state of affairs that leftists have no interest in unity or harmony within the same country and shared history. You see that what you're doing is antagonizing millions upon millions of people, and how you cope with possible blowback is this: They simply haven't figured out how to stop you yet, but now they're so alarmed by your behavior that they feel someone, or something must stop you, and quickly. And on top of that, you are cowardly. You hide behind the safety of the constraints they themselves uphold by virtue of their morality, which you mock on the daily.

My tribe is better than your tribe. Your tribe is bad, dumb, and also dumb. My tribe is best tribe.

"Why did the romanov children shoot, grenade and acid dissolve themselves? Intra-tsarist violence is out of control!"

Ah yes the Govenor that said live on TV that he wished it was someone from another country or whatever lol



But an interesting development if true



This post was edited by Metalwise4u on Sep 13 2025 10:58am

No group wants to own the shooter. He does not represent the conservative right despite his family, I'm sure you agree on this.

The left also does not want to own him. You can point to vile online posts but if you actually look at Democrats in government or progressive influencers, the vast majority is condemning him. They are hating on the right like always, which is different than saying Kirk deserved to die

The point is that both sides are highly motivated to disown him.

You are listing data points that are collected by the right, but you omit the data points collected by the left and say the case is shut, no need to look further. In reality, the guy's politics are clearly complicated and irrational

People live in bubbles. Jsp and reddit are bubbles.

Every lefty I know has condemned the killing.